Judge clears way for joint police officer lawsuit against Glendale
12:03 • 26.06.12

Four current and a former Glendale Armenian American police officers can move forward with their federal discrimination and harassment lawsuit against the city after a judge last week refused to throw out the claims, Glendale News-Press reports.
U.S. District Court Judge Josephine Tucker denied most of the city’s motion to throw out the claims, although some that were filed against certain police commanders were dropped.
“We were confident that the ruling would occur as it has,” the officers’ attorney Carney Shegerian said in an email. “The defendants have no real defenses to the allegations in our complaint — they are all true and will be proven as such at trial.”
Officers Vahak Mardikian, John Balian, Tigran Topadzhikyan, Robert Parseghian and former Officer Benny Simonzad filed a joint federal lawsuit in 2010 against the city and Police Department, alleging years of on-the-job discrimination, retaliation and harassment because they're Armenian.
Mardikian, Balian and Topadzhikyan filed a separate lawsuit in March in Los Angeles County Superior Court alleging continued racial discrimination and retaliation in the Police Department after they filed their federal case.
Tucker denied the city’s motions to drop the discrimination and retaliation claims filed by all the officers except for Parseghian. In doing so, the judge let stand a mix of charges, including that some were intentionally not promoted and that commanders failed to prevent harassment.
“We were hopeful that the court would dismiss more of the case at this stage,” City Atty. Mike Garcia said in a statement Monday. “However, we are pleased that the court resolved several claims in favor of some of the individual city defendants.”
With the next step being a jury trial, Garcia said attorneys will “successfully explain” instances in Tucker’s order in which she describes some of the officers’ evidence as lacking foundation.
“We have strong evidence showing the city's actions were for legitimate, non-discriminatory business reasons,” he said.
Tucker’s order pointed out that the officers’ failed to show statistical evidence for discrimination against Armenians.
But Tucker did identify “potentially relevant” conduct, including a memo that was posted in the Police Department’s briefingroom that allegedly mocked Armenian Genocide commemorative events.
The judge also took note of alleged comments made to certain officers, including that they were “watched closely because you are Armenian” and derogatory statements and stereotypes of Armenians, according to the court order.
Mardikian also alleges the Police Department hired a private investigator to conduct surveillance on him.
LATEST NEWS • All Today news
15:47 • 18/05
Serj Tankian congratulates Dorians on Eurovision success
15:36 • 18/05
Azeri FM to head to Moscow for official visit
15:21 • 18/05
Football: Shirak to host Tbilisi’s Dinamo
15:05 • 18/05
Man who shot Armenian conscript to face criminal charges
14:10 • 18/05
Meteor slams into moon causing explosion
13:58 • 18/05
Conscripts killed in roadway crash in Azerbaijan
13:27 • 18/05
Gas price hike plan aimed to pressure Armenia – statement
12:48 • 18/05
Haykakan Zhamanak: Armenia gives up new nuke plant plan?
12:27 • 18/05
Christoph Waltz left shaken after man points hand-gun at him, threatening to blow up studio (video)
12:05 • 18/05
Protest over killed conscripts death averted; family returning to village (update 6, photos) 
11:32 • 18/05
Same-sex marriage legalized in France as Hollande signs bill
11:23 • 18/05
Europe car sales break losing steak
11:15 • 18/05
Zhoghovurd: Circle around Karabakh conflict getting tight
10:55 • 18/05
US criticizes Russia over missiles
10:49 • 18/05
Greeks, Armenians call for conditions on Turkey trade deal
10:27 • 18/05
Dozens reported injured in US train crash
23:18 • 17/05
No liberation without struggle - Zhirair Sefilyan
19:42 • 17/05
NKR Foreign Ministry delegation participating in the anniversary events in Abkhazia
19:34 • 17/05
Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs meet in Poland: press release put out
19:17 • 17/05
Spayka cold storage insured, executive director says
18:30 • 17/05
Armenian MP speaks of agricultural problems
17:32 • 17/05
Karabakh president discusses construction of new sport complex in capital Stepanakert
17:20 • 17/05
Cannes film festival suffers $1m jewellery theft
17:10 • 17/05
Scores killed in Iraq mosque bombing
17:00 • 17/05
Talks about disintegration of Free Democrats party unserious – party’s leader
16:50 • 17/05
Armenian defense minister receives Swiss ambassador
16:49 • 17/05
Armenia’s government to submit program to Parliament
16:24 • 17/05
Prosperous Armenia party leader visits hail-stricken communities of Armavir (video)
16:16 • 17/05
Ambassador of New Zealand presents credentials to Armenian president
Most popular articles
12:05 • 18/05
Protest over killed conscripts death averted; family returning to village (update 6, photos) 
23:18 • 17/05
No liberation without struggle - Zhirair Sefilyan
19:34 • 17/05
Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs meet in Poland: press release put out
19:42 • 17/05
NKR Foreign Ministry delegation participating in the anniversary events in Abkhazia
19:17 • 17/05
Spayka cold storage insured, executive director says
16:50 • 17/05
Armenian defense minister receives Swiss ambassador
16:16 • 17/05
Ambassador of New Zealand presents credentials to Armenian president
17:00 • 17/05
Talks about disintegration of Free Democrats party unserious – party’s leader
17:10 • 17/05
Scores killed in Iraq mosque bombing
16:24 • 17/05
Prosperous Armenia party leader visits hail-stricken communities of Armavir (video)
- Protest over killed conscripts death averted; family returning to village (update 6, photos)
- No liberation without struggle - Zhirair Sefilyan
- Armenian MP speaks of agricultural problems
- Karabakh president discusses construction of new sport complex in capital Stepanakert
- Talks about disintegration of Free Democrats party unserious – party’s leader



















