Tensions escalate at Istanbul Armenian Patriarchate as Ateshian refuses to step down

12:44 • 17.03.17



The refusal by the Patriarchate’s Vicar General Archbishop Aram Ateshian to step down following Wednesday’s election of a Locum Tenens and his apparent collusion with the Istanbul Governor’s office, which deemed the process illegal, have escalated tensions within the Patriarchate.


Immediately after the Patriarchate’s Clerical Assembly elected Archbishop Karekin Bekdjian as Locum Tenens—Patriarchal alternate—Ateshian produced a letter signed by Istanbul’s deputy governor charging that the election process for a new patriarch, which began in October of last year, was “legally impossible.” Soon after the vote Thursday, the governor’s office release its letter to the press.


The decision for Ateshian to step down after the alternate’s election was agreed to last month at Etchmiadzin, where His Holiness Karekin II, Catholicos of All Armenians, had summoned Ateshian and the Patriarchate’s Religious Council chair Bishop Sahak Mashalian, who had resigned earlier as a protest to Ateshian’s interference in the electoral process.

In an interview with Agos, published on Thursday, Mashalian said that the notice from the governor’s office had rendered the Patriarchate dysfunctional. He added that a meeting should be held at the governor’s office immediately, a sentiment echoed by the newly-elected Locum Tenens, Archbishop Bekdjian.


Mashalian also raised the possibility of collusion between Ateshian and the governor’s office, saying that the fact that the notice was revealed after the election raises unanswered questions.

“There are two possibilities,” Mashalian told Agos. “Either it [the governor’s notice] came earlier and it wasn’t going to be revealed if Ateshian were elected; or it was designed as a notice that would be revealed if Ateshian lost. We don’t know. However, the problem is that this notice caused a storm in our church once again.”

Mashalian said that the situation should be handled in a calm manner to prevent clashes with the state and to restore “our freedom to worship.”

However, the events of the last 24 hours have created a situation whereby the Patriarchate does not have a religious leader, according to Mashalian.


“His Eminence Karekin is our elected deghabah [Armenian word for Locum Tenens]. And according to the same law, His Eminence Aram is no longer the vicar. Now, after this improper and untimely interference, we have a vicar who is not a vicar and a deghabah who is not a deghabah,” stressed Mashalian.

 

“His Eminence Aram’s resignation would solve everything,” added Mashalian who cited the meeting in Etchmiadzin last month, when all sides agreed to a smooth transition toward the election of a Patriarch in Istanbul.

 

Meanwhile, more revelations have come to light about Thursday’s tense meeting and the election.

According to Agos, after the votes were counted and it became clear that Bekdjian had won, Ateshian made the announcement and stormed out of the room, only to return a few minutes later with the governor’s notice in hand.


After the revelation of the notice, Mashalian, Ateshian and Bekdjian reportedly retreated to a nearby office, from where shouts were heard.


Sources who overheard the heated exchange between the top clerics at the Istanbul Patriarchate told Agod that Mashalia urged Ateshian to accept the results of the election and go to the governor’s office to explain the decision of the Clerical Assembly.


“They [the state] are trampling on our religious life. This is interference. This election happened.

We have to go to the governor’s office and tell that Bekdjian is our deghabah. You are the one who should do it,” Mashalian reportedly told Ateshian, to which the latter responded “I am holding my seat until the state gives permission.”





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:16 • 21/11

Converse Bank launches special product for customers receiving foreign transfers

16:29 • 21/11

Armenia to receive 1.3m NATO assistance

15:47 • 21/11

UEFA release team of 21st century

15:40 • 21/11

US ending temporary permits for almost 60,000 Haitians

15:32 • 21/11

Barron Trump towers over Melania - aged just 11 - as the pair greet the official White House Christmas tree

15:19 • 21/11

Egyptian singer held for ‘suggestive video’

14:52 • 21/11

VEON Ltd conducts leadership meeting in Armenia  

14:40 • 21/11

Merkel hints fresh elections after coalition defeat

14:24 • 21/11

Kim Kardashian's pregnant surrogate shows off baby bump while running errands (photos)

14:10 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s statements run counter to practical steps – Nalbandian

13:40 • 21/11

Iran’s Rouhani declares end of Islamic State

13:15 • 21/11

All elements to resolve Karabakh conflict 'in place' – Sergey Lavrov

12:40 • 21/11

168 Zham: EU-Armenia agreement 'no threat to Russia and Eurasian Union' – analyst

12:13 • 21/11

NASA reveals bizarre shape of interstellar asteroid

11:50 • 21/11

Zhamanak: Lavrov gave Azerbaijan clear message on Karabakh, says Russian expert

10:45 • 21/11

US approves $75m sale of Javelin anti-tank missiles to Georgia

10:27 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s EEU membership 'not acceptable now' - Armenian economist

10:03 • 21/11

Syria military operations nearing end; Putin and Assad meet in Sochi

09:43 • 21/11

Game of Thrones operator Mark Milsome dies in Ghana

09:28 • 21/11

Trump declares N Korea ‘sponsor of terror’

09:13 • 21/11

Zimbabwe crisis: Mugabe could lose presidency in days

17:51 • 20/11

Germany: Merkel suffers blow as coalition plan fails

17:38 • 20/11

Honest intentions key to future peace over Karabakh – Thomas Greminger

16:55 • 20/11

Iraqi Federal Court rules Kurdish referendum unconstitutional  

16:44 • 20/11

‘Visible steps’ to reach Karabakh breakthrough - Mammadyarov

16:27 • 20/11

Former Wimbledon champion Jana Novotna dies at 49

16:16 • 20/11

Germany bans smartwatches for kids

16:09 • 20/11

Atom Egoyan to be honored with Lifetime Achievement Award at IFFI 2017

15:37 • 20/11

Turkey-Armenia rapprochement 'left for different spring' – Taner Akcam

14:52 • 20/11

Armenia may be unaffected by Turkey-Russia thaw, says expert

14:20 • 20/11

Lavrov highlights progress in Karabakh peace  

13:59 • 20/11

Saakashvili tells Kiev protesters he is ready to become Ukraine's prime minister

13:49 • 20/11

Russia would hail Azerbaijan’s EEU accession – Lavrov

13:01 • 20/11

Gold leaf from Napoleon’s crown fetches $735,000 in Paris

12:55 • 20/11

US bans alcohol for troops in Japan

12:43 • 20/11

Amended referendum law to take effect after new President’s inauguration – CEC chairman

12:02 • 20/11

Selana Gomez unveils a sassy new style as she and pop princess Demi Lovato turn heads in bold black numbers at the American Music Awards

11:53 • 20/11

National Defense Research University ends intra-agency executive education pilot course

11:42 • 20/11

Turkey unaffected by EU's trim of funding

11:27 • 20/11

Armenian politician declares hunger-strike against 'anti-constitutional' order

11:03 • 20/11

Chales Manson whose followers killed 83 people dies at 83

10:46 • 20/11

Artsakh president starts working visit to France (photos)

10:17 • 20/11

Armenian Genocide monument raises Turks’ anger in Cologne  

09:51 • 20/11

German coalition plan fails after deadlock on migration, energy

09:42 • 20/11

FIDE Grand Prix 2017: Aronian wins Anish Giri  

09:27 • 20/11

Syria army liberates Abu Kamal from ISIS militants

09:08 • 20/11

Mugabe stuns Zimbabwe by defying pressure to resign

15:06 • 18/11

6.9 magnitude quake hits southern China

14:51 • 18/11

Iraqi forces recapture last Islamic State-held town

14:38 • 18/11

Conte to grow beard until Chelsea’s next defeat

14:28 • 18/11

NATO reiterates apology to Turkey over Ataturk, Erdogan reports

14:09 • 18/11

Small progress as UN climate talks end in Bonn

13:55 • 18/11

Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations on Karabakh frontline

13:46 • 18/11

Downing North Korean missiles is hard. so the US Is Experimenting. – NY Times

13:11 • 18/11

EU-Armenia visa liberalization linked to cooperation agreement - expert

12:02 • 18/11

Armenia approaches EU from EEU’s orbit – New Europe

11:47 • 18/11

Aravot: Nalbandian-Mammadyarov meeting plan signals no progress – politician

11:09 • 18/11

Hollywood stars to support Children of Armenian Fund gala

10:55 • 18/11

Zhamanak: Government to lift ban on investment liberalization

10:35 • 18/11

Russia vetoes resolution on Syria chemical attacks

10:19 • 18/11

168 Zham: Karabakh’s absence from peace talks rules out chances of progress

09:53 • 18/11

168 Zham: Stall in Karabakh peace threatens further escalations by Azerbaijan

09:26 • 18/11

Four killed as aircraft and helicopter crash over  Buckinghamshire

09:12 • 18/11

UK accuses Germany, France over Brexit talks deadlock

18:01 • 17/11

West behind anti-Russian sentiments in Armenia – expert

17:15 • 17/11

Belarus signs law to ratify EEU Customs Treaty

17:06 • 17/11

Armenia appoints new ambassador to Romania

16:58 • 17/11

World's first human head transplant has successfully completed

16:52 • 17/11

Too early to make any statement now – Nalbandian on EaP Summit Declaration

16:13 • 17/11

Economic reforms to encourage more people to stay in Armenia – US ambassador

14:42 • 17/11

Saudi authorities offer 'freedom for money' to princes and businessmen

13:51 • 17/11

US priorities responsible for low level of relations with Armenia – political scientist

12:27 • 17/11

Serena Williams marries millionaire Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian in a Beauty and the Beast themed wedding (photos)

11:33 • 17/11

European Parliament reaffirms its recognition of Nagorno-Karabakh's right to self-determination

11:24 • 17/11

New earthquake in Azerbaijan rocks also Nagorno-Karabakh  

11:02 • 17/11

Matthew Bryza: Karabakh conflict good example of cooperation between US and Russia

10:38 • 17/11

State Revenue Committee officials conduct working meetings in China

10:04 • 17/11

Serzh Sargsyan hosts ceremony of 2017 Presidential Award for global contribution to IT industries

09:53 • 17/11

Zhamanak: EaP summit declaration in deadlock over Karabakh wording

09:33 • 17/11

Australian diplomat dies after falling from NY balcony

09:12 • 17/11

Zimbabwe crisis: Mugabe 'resisting calls’ to step down

18:13 • 16/11

Minsk Group co-chairs sum up meetings with Nalbandian, Mammadyarov  

18:01 • 16/11

'Leonardo da Vinci artwork' sells for record $450m in New York

17:36 • 16/11

Mammadyarov agrees to meet with Nalbandian in Vienna

16:52 • 16/11

Nagorno-Karabakh priority concern for Russia, says Foreign Ministry rep

16:32 • 16/11

Turkey, Afghanistan sign corridor agreement with ex-Soviet trio

16:20 • 16/11

Armenian church on the brink of collapse in Turkey’s Bitlis

15:48 • 16/11

Ucom launches IP television, fixed Internet services in Hrazdan, expanding mobile network

15:36 • 16/11

Mediators want confidence-building over Karabakh – Armenian official

14:52 • 16/11

Russia to extend $100bn military supply loan to Armenia

14:18 • 16/11

Kim Kardashian inadvertently reveals future baby’s sex

13:55 • 16/11

Government program promises higher-level social well-being in Armenia – minister  

13:20 • 16/11

HRW Presents 1st ‘Promise’ award to the late Chris Cornell

13:13 • 16/11

Russia, Venezuela agree to restructure debts

12:21 • 16/11

Armenian-Russian high-level talks held in Moscow

12:13 • 16/11

Deadly flash floods cause 'biblical damage' in Athens

11:56 • 16/11

Armenia rated as low-risk country on Global Terrorism Index

11:26 • 16/11

168 Zham: Putin opposed to Erdogan’s engagement in Karabakh settlement process – Polish analyst

11:00 • 16/11

5.3 mgn quake in Azerbaijan rocks also Armenia

10:34 • 16/11

Zhamanak: Russia seeking to emphasize active role-player's status in Karabakh talks, says expert