Tensions escalate at Istanbul Armenian Patriarchate as Ateshian refuses to step down

12:44 • 17.03.17



The refusal by the Patriarchate’s Vicar General Archbishop Aram Ateshian to step down following Wednesday’s election of a Locum Tenens and his apparent collusion with the Istanbul Governor’s office, which deemed the process illegal, have escalated tensions within the Patriarchate.


Immediately after the Patriarchate’s Clerical Assembly elected Archbishop Karekin Bekdjian as Locum Tenens—Patriarchal alternate—Ateshian produced a letter signed by Istanbul’s deputy governor charging that the election process for a new patriarch, which began in October of last year, was “legally impossible.” Soon after the vote Thursday, the governor’s office release its letter to the press.


The decision for Ateshian to step down after the alternate’s election was agreed to last month at Etchmiadzin, where His Holiness Karekin II, Catholicos of All Armenians, had summoned Ateshian and the Patriarchate’s Religious Council chair Bishop Sahak Mashalian, who had resigned earlier as a protest to Ateshian’s interference in the electoral process.

In an interview with Agos, published on Thursday, Mashalian said that the notice from the governor’s office had rendered the Patriarchate dysfunctional. He added that a meeting should be held at the governor’s office immediately, a sentiment echoed by the newly-elected Locum Tenens, Archbishop Bekdjian.


Mashalian also raised the possibility of collusion between Ateshian and the governor’s office, saying that the fact that the notice was revealed after the election raises unanswered questions.

“There are two possibilities,” Mashalian told Agos. “Either it [the governor’s notice] came earlier and it wasn’t going to be revealed if Ateshian were elected; or it was designed as a notice that would be revealed if Ateshian lost. We don’t know. However, the problem is that this notice caused a storm in our church once again.”

Mashalian said that the situation should be handled in a calm manner to prevent clashes with the state and to restore “our freedom to worship.”

However, the events of the last 24 hours have created a situation whereby the Patriarchate does not have a religious leader, according to Mashalian.


“His Eminence Karekin is our elected deghabah [Armenian word for Locum Tenens]. And according to the same law, His Eminence Aram is no longer the vicar. Now, after this improper and untimely interference, we have a vicar who is not a vicar and a deghabah who is not a deghabah,” stressed Mashalian.

 

“His Eminence Aram’s resignation would solve everything,” added Mashalian who cited the meeting in Etchmiadzin last month, when all sides agreed to a smooth transition toward the election of a Patriarch in Istanbul.

 

Meanwhile, more revelations have come to light about Thursday’s tense meeting and the election.

According to Agos, after the votes were counted and it became clear that Bekdjian had won, Ateshian made the announcement and stormed out of the room, only to return a few minutes later with the governor’s notice in hand.


After the revelation of the notice, Mashalian, Ateshian and Bekdjian reportedly retreated to a nearby office, from where shouts were heard.


Sources who overheard the heated exchange between the top clerics at the Istanbul Patriarchate told Agod that Mashalia urged Ateshian to accept the results of the election and go to the governor’s office to explain the decision of the Clerical Assembly.


“They [the state] are trampling on our religious life. This is interference. This election happened.

We have to go to the governor’s office and tell that Bekdjian is our deghabah. You are the one who should do it,” Mashalian reportedly told Ateshian, to which the latter responded “I am holding my seat until the state gives permission.”





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:34 • 25/04

PACE president expected to tender resignation on Friday, says member of Armenian delegation

17:42 • 25/04

Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to make $186m from Verizon deal

17:11 • 25/04

Donald Trump summons US Senate to White House briefing on North Korea

17:02 • 25/04

Armenian premier, Indian vice president discuss bilateral relations

16:57 • 25/04

Serena Williams ‘disappointed’ by ‘racist’ comments

16:47 • 25/04

Serzh Sargsyan hosts delegation led by Indian vice president

16:39 • 25/04

State Revenue Committee pledges measures to relieve vendors’ tax burden

16:04 • 25/04

Russia sees OSCE's efforts to reach peace over Karabakh - Lavrov

15:50 • 25/04

Bernard Arnault's LVMH scoops up Christian Dior for £10bn

15:23 • 25/04

Ivanka Trump joins world leaders for G20 summit

15:09 • 25/04

PACE reopens monitoring against Turkey

14:46 • 25/04

Armenian vendors protest against government-imposed tax procedures

14:02 • 25/04

Trump to call International Space Station to congratulate record breaking female austonaut

13:20 • 25/04

Tourism is in beneficiary’s role in practically all areas, says chief of state committee

11:17 • 25/04

Silent encourages tormentor - Khloe Kardashian remembers Genpcide victims

10:36 • 25/04

Turkey Foreign Ministry slams Trump’s April 24 address

10:24 • 25/04

Samantha Power: ‘I am Sorry that We in Obama Administration did not Recognize Armenian Genocide’

10:17 • 25/04

Historical record of Genocide is clear despite repeated denial – Nancy Pelosi  

09:59 • 25/04

Nagorno-Karabakh soldier fatally wounded by Azerbaijani bullet

09:43 • 25/04

Tens of Thousands hold march for justice to Los Angeles Turkish Consulate

09:39 • 25/04

Rising death toll reported in Venezuela protests

09:29 • 25/04

Elton John recovers from potentially deadly infection

09:12 • 25/04

We honor the victims of ‘Meds Yeghern’ – Trump’s address on Genocide Remembrance Day

08:57 • 25/04

France elections: Le Pen steps aside to focus on presidential campaign

17:52 • 24/04

Pope Francis conveyed message of peaceful dialogue – Mikael Minasyan

16:28 • 24/04

Keeping the Promise – Huffington Post

16:12 • 24/04

Aurora names five finalists for 2017 award (photos)

15:28 • 24/04

Driverless car trials approved in London

15:02 • 24/04

Genocide remembrance not just experience of past grief – US-Armenian philanthropist

14:23 • 24/04

Cyprus reiterates support to Armenian Genocide recognition

14:14 • 24/04

Istanbul police hamper Armenian Genocide march  

13:35 • 24/04

Thousands commemorate Armenian Genocide at Montebello monument

13:27 • 24/04

This genocide must be eventually recognized – parliament official

12:42 • 24/04

Istanbul church hosts Armenian Genocide mass

12:18 • 24/04

Naming the Armenian genocide for what it is – Chris Bohjalian

11:55 • 24/04

Armenian Genocide victims remembered in special Mass

11:30 • 24/04

Syria’s Kessab hit in fresh rocket attack

11:02 • 24/04

Euro jumps after French presidential election

10:50 • 24/04

Istanbul-Armenians to remember Genocide victims  

10:30 • 24/04

We will not allow more crimes of genocide – Serzh Sargsyan

10:17 • 24/04

Armenians marking Genocide anniversary today

09:30 • 24/04

Football: Messi scores last-second winner

09:16 • 24/04

French election: Macron appears set for Elysee in runoff with Le Pen

15:30 • 22/04

US to honor refugee deal with Australia, says Mike Pence

15:18 • 22/04

Canadians solemnly commemorate Armenian Genocide victims – Justin Trudeau

15:16 • 22/04

Trump was cut from an Al Pacino film after demanding role

14:58 • 22/04

National Archives to publish new editions on Armenian Genocide

14:08 • 22/04

Putin, Erdogan to meet in Turkey in May

13:39 • 22/04

US congressman calls for proper recognition of Armenian Genocide

13:27 • 22/04

Eco-friendly development ‘pressing demand’ in Armenia - minister

12:30 • 22/04

All-electric ‘flying car’ take its first test flight in Germany

12:15 • 22/04

Armenian premier calls for stronger efforts to boost social well-being

11:31 • 22/04

Ibrahimovic to retire: Man United star to end career after horror injury - reports

11:24 • 22/04

Zhoghovurd: Russian low-coster’s disappointing shock

10:30 • 22/04

Demi Moore sells NYC iconic penthouse for $45M

10:13 • 22/04

Azerbaijan keeps Karabakh frontline under heavy fire  

10:00 • 22/04

8-year-old Siberian albino girl being flooded with modeling offers for unique beauty

09:30 • 22/04

Wyoming becomes 45th US State to Recognize Armenian Genocide

09:10 • 22/04

Obama to return to public eye  after three-month vacation

18:05 • 21/04

 Nation-Army ideology should attract also diaspora-Armenians, says minister

17:44 • 21/04

Terrorists receive chemical weapons from Turkey, says Syria’s Assad

17:19 • 21/04

Genocide recognition should be step towards reinstating state borders

16:43 • 21/04

'X-Files' returns for new season

16:40 • 21/04

Mercedes launches S-Class Sedan

16:12 • 21/04

Criminal case launched over Armenian conscript's death

15:43 • 21/04

Armenian ombudsman highlights police abuses in July events

14:47 • 21/04

Former England defender dies Ugo Ehiogu dies

14:43 • 21/04

Armenian conscript fatally wounded in military unit

13:51 • 21/04

Parties running for Yerevan City Hall launching political campaign today

13:08 • 21/04

US discriminating against Chinese firms, says TCL boss

12:55 • 21/04

Armenian activists blast ombudsman as ‘authorities’ puppet’ (photos)

12:17 • 21/04

Turkey’s new constitution to bring about  most radical overhaul of state – The Economist

12:03 • 21/04

Zhamanak: Ohanyan to be promoted to senior post in Russia?

11:35 • 21/04

Trump administration unlikely to recognize Genocide – Richard Giragosian

10:31 • 21/04

German police arrest suspect in Borussia Dortmund bus attack

10:16 • 21/04

Azerbaijan shoots heavy fire on Karabakh frontline

10:06 • 21/04

Armenian Genocide Committee announces March for Justice coalition

09:47 • 21/04

Azerbaijan shells interstate highway section connecting Armenian villages

09:09 • 21/04

Paris shootout leaves police officer, gunman dead

18:08 • 20/04

I am now focused on investment projects in Armenia, Artsakh, says former minister

17:18 • 20/04

Facebook building brain-computer interfaces for typing and skin-hearing

17:00 • 20/04

Celebrities warned of Instagram ads

16:35 • 20/04

French presidential hopeful calls for support to Genocide denial criminalization

15:26 • 20/04

Indonesian bride's fairytale wedding gown sparks a social media frenzy

15:10 • 20/04

Defense minister announces new projects to boost military education  

14:14 • 20/04

Fresh claims of Azerbaijan vote-rigging at European human rights body – The Gurdian

13:26 • 20/04

Armenian Genocide movie in theaters on Friday

13:14 • 20/04

Turkey’s Erdogan snubs objections to referendum results

12:48 • 20/04

Armenian president pledges housing support to families of killed, disabled servicemen

12:19 • 20/04

Juventus 0-0 Barcelona

12:02 • 20/04

Yerevan hosts 'Nation-Army 2017' conference

11:31 • 20/04

California Assembly committee passes Turkey divestment bills

11:11 • 20/04

EU-Armenia visa liberalization ‘absolutely transparent process’ – lawmaker

10:12 • 20/04

Australia overhauls citizenship process

10:08 • 20/04

Nagorno-Karabakh reports more Azerbaijani ceasefire violations

09:45 • 20/04

Zhoghovurd: Why don’t we have airports?

09:15 • 20/04

Iran accused of alarming provocations

09:08 • 20/04

Bomb blasts outside Athens bank, causing minor damage

18:04 • 19/04

 Physicists create fluid with ‘negative mass’

17:43 • 19/04

France must support Armenian Genocide recognition campaign, says presidential runner