Turkey’s new constitution to bring about  most radical overhaul of state – The Economist

12:17 • 21.04.17



It was a vote that turned out to be as controversial as it was hotly contested. Even before all of the ballots had been counted, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Turkey’s president, stepped in front of a crowd of supporters in Istanbul and proclaimed victory. “My nation stood upright and undivided,” he said, referring to the referendum on a constitution that will give him new, virtually unchecked powers. “April 16th was a victory for all of Turkey.”

Yet it was hardly the win Mr Erdogan had expected. The Yes camp, which the president headed, limped away with just 51.4% of the vote. The opposition accused the country’s electoral authority of foul play. Outside observers charged the government with stacking the odds in its favour. Anti-government demonstrations broke out in a number of Turkish cities. The country awoke the following morning more divided than ever.


The new constitution will bring about the most radical overhaul of the state since 1923, when it went from being an imperial Islamic power to a secular republic under Kemal Ataturk, the founder of modern Turkey. After fresh elections in 2019, Mr Erdogan will rule uncontested, appointing senior officials, judges and members of his own cabinet, with little oversight by an expanded but weakened parliament. The office of prime minister will cease to exist.


Yet the constitution is already mired in controversy. The main opposition, the secular Republican People’s party (CHP), has asked for the referendum results to be annulled. A last-minute decision by the country’s electoral board to accept unstamped ballot papers created the risk of mass fraud, the CHP said. Claims of vote-rigging, especially in the Kurdish southeast, have been pouring in. In a scathing assessment, observers from the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), an intergovernmental body, said the board’s move had “undermined an important safeguard and contradicted the law”. A state of emergency imposed shortly after an attempted coup in July, accompanied by nearly 50,000 arrests and a climate of intimidation and nationalist hysteria, was hardly the proper setting for a referendum on systemic changes. “Voters were not provided with impartial information about key aspects of the reform and limitations on fundamental freedoms had a negative effect,” the OSCE said.


There is next to no chance of a recount. The electoral board rejected the opposition’s appeal on April 19th, but promised to look into individual allegations of fraud. (Official results are expected towards the end of April.) Mr Erdogan asked foreign observers to keep their concerns to themselves. “We don’t care about the opinions of ‘Hans’ or ‘George’,” he said. His prime minister added: “The people’s decision is clear and the result is a Yes.”


The allegations will haunt Mr Erdogan for years, leaving the country even more polarised than before. Mr Erdogan might be “the most unassailable Turkish leader since Ataturk but this legitimacy issue will hang over his head,” says Soner Cagaptay, a fellow at the Washington Institute.

International reaction has been muted. Other than Donald Trump’s America, which joined model democracies such as Russia, Sudan, Hungary and Djibouti in congratulating Mr Erdogan, no leader of a big Western country has welcomed the vote. Britain, Germany and the EU called instead for dialogue and an impartial inquiry. Mr Erdogan did not appear particularly keen to rebuild bridges with Europe: on the day of the vote, he pledged once again to do his part to reinstate the death penalty, which would threaten the membership of Turkey in the Council of Europe and torpedo its already comatose accession talks with the EU.


One-man show


Supporters of the new constitution say it will improve decision-making by concentrating power in Mr Erdogan’s hands, precluding unwieldy political coalitions and neutralising powerful unelected officials. “From now on, it’s the people who are going to rule Turkey,” says Ufuk, a young Yes voter relaxing outside a polling booth.


Opponents say it will transform the government, already dominated by Mr Erdogan, into an authoritarian regime. “This is the beginning of one-man rule,” says Ali Bayramoglu, a columnist who used to be sympathetic to the ruling Justice and Development (AK) party. After he said earlier this month that he would oppose the new constitution, Mr Bayramoglu was assaulted by AK supporters at a polling station on the day of the vote.


Some of the changes will come into effect immediately. An impartiality clause that required the president to sever links with any political party (which he flouted) will expire. Mr Erdogan is expected formally to rejoin AK as soon as official results are announced this week. Within a month, the country’s most influential judicial body, the council of judges and prosecutors, will shrink and move from a system of election by peers to one of appointment by parliament and the president.


Mr Erdogan’s initial comments suggest he will disregard the slim margin of victory and portray the referendum as a sign of support for his crackdown. The day after the vote, his government extended the state of emergency until July 19th. Two days after that, police arrested some 38 people accused of participating in protests.


Turkey is saddled with a constitution opposed by nearly half of all voters in a referendum tainted by fraud claims and held under conditions that made open debate impossible. Mr Erdogan has the powers he has long coveted. They come at the cost of tension at home and isolation abroad.

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:51 • 26/07

Turkish PM to be in charge of state, wealth funds after cabinet reshuffle

17:37 • 26/07

Ivanka Trump reads to children with Betsy DeVos and snaps selfies at museum before speaking at a Mike Pence fundraiser

17:11 • 26/07

Armenian wrestlers win fifth medal in surdolympic games

16:48 • 26/07

Armenian parliament speaker, Argentine envoy discuss bilateral agenda

16:14 • 26/07

Armenia's energy exports to grow 20% by late 2017 - minister

15:40 • 26/07

Almost 12,000 evacuated after wildfire on France's Mediterranean coast

15:31 • 26/07

Britain will ban new petrol and diesel cars from 2040, says minister

15:23 • 26/07

David Backham meets Madrid stars in LA

15:17 • 26/07

French mayor eats a rat after losing bet on Barcelona comeback against PSG (video)

15:07 • 26/07

Armenian-Israeli economic cooperation discusssed in Yerevan

14:30 • 26/07

Frank Sinatra's widow, Barbara Sinatra, dies sat 90

14:20 • 26/07

Russia not willing to arrange Armenian-Azerbaijani presidential talks – analyst  

14:00 • 26/07

Philippines’ Duterte threatens to bomb indigenous schools

13:30 • 26/07

Karabakh not key issue on Russian-Azerbaijani agenda - opinion

13:18 • 26/07

North Korea threatens 'merciless' nuclear strike 'at the heart of the US' if Trump administration tries to take out Kim Jong-Un regime

13:07 • 26/07

Age is nothing but a number! Chinese Grandmas strut their stuff down the runway in bikinis for  senior swimsuit competition

12:49 • 26/07

In Turkey, Freedom of Expression is in the dock – Human Rights Watch

12:39 • 26/07

Eurovision 2018 host country named

12:32 • 26/07

Lenovo showcases foldable tablet (video)

12:07 • 26/07

Armenia, Israel sign convention banning double taxation

11:39 • 26/07

US Administration officials open to talks on US-Armenia double tax treaty

11:10 • 26/07

European court judgments against Armenia should entail disciplinary measures against judges – ex prosecutor general

10:25 • 26/07

Turkish minister urges luxurious hotels to serve smaller food portions in bid to avoid waste

10:10 • 26/07

Aravot: Talish recovering from devastations of four-day war

09:30 • 26/07

US moves one step closer to imposing fresh Russia sanctions

09:11 • 26/07

US State Department denies reports on Tillerson departure

17:59 • 25/07

No harm in buying Russian missile defense system, says Turkey's Erdogan

17:51 • 25/07

German prosecutors blame neo-Nazi suspect in racist killings  

17:32 • 25/07

Yerevan mayor, Chinese ambassador discuss cooperation prospects

16:52 • 25/07

Nagorno-Karabakh dismisses Azerbaijani disinformation on 'flying drones'  

15:56 • 25/07

Clash between pilot and flight attendant delays flight at New York Airport

15:32 • 25/07

Israeli regional cooperation minister to visit Armenia

15:06 • 25/07

Lord of The Rings author biopic draws Finnish director Dome Karukoski

14:34 • 25/07

Knife-wielding man attacks police officers near the Spanish-Moroccan border

14:09 • 25/07

Armenia has counterbalance to Russian-Azerbaijani weapons sale – politician

13:19 • 25/07

Alphabet reports profit decline after EU fine  

13:06 • 25/07

Olympic Festival: Armenian junior tennis player celebrates first victory

12:38 • 25/07

US company to microchip employees

12:25 • 25/07

Armenia-EU relations discussed in Yerevan

11:55 • 25/07

New James Bond movie gets 2019 release date

11:49 • 25/07

US National Archives begins online release of JFK assassination records

11:11 • 25/07

Canadian polygamist found guilty after marrying 25 women and fathering over 145 children (photos)

10:54 • 25/07

Canadian defense deal with Azerbaijan raises more questions about arms export controls

10:42 • 25/07

Armenian anchor, reciter Vera Hakobyan dies at 89

10:03 • 25/07

A chill emanating from the White House reaches State Department - CNN  

09:45 • 25/07

Mgn 3 earthquake shakes Armenia’s south

09:31 • 25/07

Azerbaijan jails newspaper financial director

09:12 • 25/07

US House expected to approve Russia sanctions bill limiting Trump's influence

18:01 • 24/07

Five hurt in Switzerland chainsaw attack

17:17 • 24/07

Iran hosts Armenian Movie Week

17:04 • 24/07

Dubai hospital gets Guinness award for removing world’s largest kidneys

16:32 • 24/07

Armenian FM honors outgoing Polish envoy  

16:13 • 24/07

Subscribers of U! prepay tariff plans by Ucom to call MegaFon Russia network unlimitedly

16:05 • 24/07

Iran interested in building bridges with EEU across Armenia - expert

15:24 • 24/07

Warhol classic discovered after 40 years  

15:13 • 24/07

Trump’s son-in-law Kushner denies Russia collusion

14:51 • 24/07

Armenian parliament speaker attends 15th Armenian EyeCare Project conference

14:05 • 24/07

Free trade zone on Iranian border to boost bilateral trade – Armenian expert

13:23 • 24/07

Olympic legend fails to race a Great White during Discovery show

12:38 • 24/07

Passenger reported dead at Yerevan airport

12:18 • 24/07

Staff of leading Turkish paper face trial in press freedom test

11:52 • 24/07

Stubbs the cat, Alaska's honorary feline mayor, dies at 20 (photos)

11:46 • 24/07

Suicide car bomb leaves 24 killed in Afghan capital

11:30 • 24/07

Armenia joins Moscow International Army Games

10:55 • 24/07

Mkhitaryan: Last season's difficulties helped me improve

10:46 • 24/07

Strong earthquake breaches walls in southeast Iran

10:20 • 24/07

Russia deepens partnership with Azerbaijan while tightening grip on Armenia – expert  

09:33 • 24/07

IMF downgrades US and UK growth

09:12 • 24/07

British boat crew find £100M of Nazi gold in Hitler's shipwreck

16:00 • 23/07

Armenian border village heavily damaged in Azerbaijani gunfire (photos)

15:34 • 23/07

Turkish journalist exposes exclusive archive record on Genocide

14:45 • 23/07

'The things I'd have said to her... if I knew it was the last time we'd speak': William and Harry's agony over final phone call with Diana as they share unseen photos 

14:19 • 23/07

Armenia has no serious reason to quit EEU, says Republican lawmaker

13:50 • 23/07

Man City seal signing of Real Madrid right-back Danilo for £26.5m

13:28 • 23/07

US Congress in deal on new Russia sanctions

12:44 • 23/07

‘Melted nuclear fuel’ spotted in Fukushima

12:02 • 23/07

Macron’s rating falls by 10% over month, showing Worst Dynamics Since 1995 – poll

11:37 • 23/07

Armenian sportsmen win bronze in deaf wrestling championship  

11:06 • 23/07

Armenian church celebrating Vardavar or Transfiguration of Christ

10:17 • 23/07

Putin, Aliyev discuss Karabakh peace in Sochi

18:01 • 21/07

Kansas National Guard medical and hazardous material experts to train firefighters in Armenia

17:45 • 21/07

China to allow rice imports from US

17:12 • 21/07

Justin Bieber banned from China concerts for 'bad behavior'

17:01 • 21/07

Indian musician plays guitar during his brain surgery (video)  

16:44 • 21/07

Jerusalem clashes erupt amid holy site tensions

16:28 • 21/07

US to ban citizens from travel to North Korea, tour operators say

16:09 • 21/07

US Embassy can issue visas in extended valid passports – statement

15:47 • 21/07

Russian, Azerbaijani presidents set to meet in Sochi

15:14 • 21/07

Armenian youth basketball team wins Azerbaijan (video)

14:41 • 21/07

75% of Artsakh population backed incumbent leader - pollster  

13:52 • 21/07

Ford claims first 'pursuit rated' police pickup truck 

13:39 • 21/07

Ucom decreases prices for 'Internet in Roaming' bundles

13:06 • 21/07

Artsakh presidential elections stemmed from real hazards – Armenian analyst

12:15 • 21/07

No Armenians reported among survivors of Greek Island earthquake

11:59 • 21/07

Linkin Park vocalist Chester Bennington dies

11:47 • 21/07

Cooperation with US Department of Commerce discussed in Yerevan  

10:43 • 21/07

Russia extradites convicted bus driver to Armenia

10:17 • 21/07

Salvador Dali body exhumed

09:46 • 21/07

Azerbaijani director adapts Turkey’s failed coup into documentary

09:26 • 21/07

2 killed, 120 injured in Greek island earthquake