Google urged to hand over salary details in gender equality court battle

11:55 • 17.07.17



A judge has ordered Google to hand over salary records to the government in an ongoing investigation by the US Department of Labor, which has accused the technology corporation of systematically discriminating against women, the Guardian reports.


Google must provide the federal government with a 2014 snapshot of the data, along with contact information for thousands of employees for possible interviews, according to a ruling made public on Sunday.


Judge Steve Berlin, however, also denied part of the government’s request for records and partially sided with Google, which had argued the department’s demands were overly broad and could violate employee privacy.


The limited records Google must release could help the Department of Labor (DoL) build a formal pay discrimination case against the company, which has repeatedly refused to disclose key data in what has become one of the most high-profile court battles to date regarding wage inequality in Silicon Valley. The department – which had argued that additional records would help explain the “extreme” gender pay gap it uncovered in an initial audit – said in a statement the decision “vindicates” its “vigorous enforcement” efforts.


The provisional order, written Friday, comes at a time of growing scrutiny of gender discrimination and sexual harassment across the tech industry, including a major scandal at Uber and a string of recent controversies involving prominent venture capitalists. 


The DoL first publicly accused Google of “systemic compensation disparities” in April, testifying in a hearing that its preliminary investigation found that women across a wide range of positions at the Mountain View campus were paid less than men.


Berlin’s decision resolves a more narrow court battle stemming from a DoL lawsuit filed against Google in January, which accused the corporation of violating federal laws in its refusal to turn over salary history and employee contact information. Google has contracts with the federal government, which means it is obliged to comply with equal opportunity laws and has to allow the DoL to review certain internal records.


Google originally provided a 2015 snapshot of salaries. The DoL subsequently requested compensation history and contact information for employees so it could conduct confidential interviews, but Google argued the demands violated fourth amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure.


Berlin’s ruling, which is a recommended order that still has to be finalized, said Google must provide the comparable 2014 snapshot, though he said the DoL’s demands for contact information for more than 25,000 workers was “over-broad, intrusive on employee privacy, unduly burdensome, and insufficiently focused”.

Instead, Google has to provide personal information for up to 8,000 employees the DoL selects, the ruling said. Berlin also denied the department’s broader request for salary and job history data, saying the

demands “create an unreasonable burden on Google and its employees”.

The department’s regional solicitor Janet Herold praised the decision in a statement, saying, “The court’s decision vindicates [DoL]’s vigorous enforcement of the disclosure and anti-discrimination obligations federal contractors voluntarily accept in exchange for taxpayer funds. Contractors will be held to their promise to let [DoL] fully audit their employment practices.”

Google has vehemently denied that it discriminates against women, publicly claiming that it has closed its gender pay gap globally. In a Sunday blogpost, Google said it was “pleased” with the decision and would comply with the order, providing the “much more limited data set of information”.

In a final hearing last month, Google argued it was financially burdensome and logistically challenging to compile and hand over the salary records the DoL had requested, saying it would have to spend up to 500 hours and $100,000 to comply with the ongoing demands. The defense earned a strong rebuke from the DoL and others in the industry who noted Google has touted its $150m “diversity” efforts and has a nearly $28bn annual income as one of the world’s wealthiest companies, building some of the most advanced technology.

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:59 • 25/07

No harm in buying Russian missile defense system, says Turkey's Erdogan

17:51 • 25/07

German prosecutors blame neo-Nazi suspect in racist killings  

17:32 • 25/07

Yerevan mayor, Chinese ambassador discuss cooperation prospects

16:52 • 25/07

Nagorno-Karabakh dismisses Azerbaijani disinformation on 'flying drones'  

15:56 • 25/07

Clash between pilot and flight attendant delays flight at New York Airport

15:32 • 25/07

Israeli regional cooperation minister to visit Armenia

15:06 • 25/07

Lord of The Rings author biopic draws Finnish director Dome Karukoski

14:34 • 25/07

Knife-wielding man attacks police officers near the Spanish-Moroccan border

14:09 • 25/07

Armenia has counterbalance to Russian-Azerbaijani weapons sale – politician

13:19 • 25/07

Alphabet reports profit decline after EU fine  

13:06 • 25/07

Olympic festival: Armenian junior tennis player celebrates first victory

12:38 • 25/07

US company to microchip employees

12:25 • 25/07

Armenia-EU relations discussed in Yerevan

11:55 • 25/07

New James Bond movie gets 2009 release date

11:49 • 25/07

US National Archives begins online release of JFK assassination records

11:11 • 25/07

Canadian polygamist found guilty after marrying 25 women and fathering over 145 children (photos)

10:54 • 25/07

Canadian defense deal with Azerbaijan raises more questions about arms export controls

10:42 • 25/07

Armenian anchor, reciter Vera Hakobyan dies at 89

10:03 • 25/07

A chill emanating from the White House reaches State Department - CNN  

09:45 • 25/07

Mgn 3 earthquake shakes Armenia’s south

09:31 • 25/07

Azerbaijan jails newspaper financial director

09:12 • 25/07

US House expected to approve Russia sanctions bill limiting Trump's influence

18:01 • 24/07

Five hurt in Switzerland chainsaw attack

17:17 • 24/07

Iran hosts Armenian Movie Week

17:04 • 24/07

Dubai hospital gets Guinness award for removing world’s largest kidneys

16:32 • 24/07

Armenian FM honors outgoing Polish envoy  

16:13 • 24/07

Subscribers of U! prepay tariff plans by Ucom to call MegaFon Russia network unlimitedly

16:05 • 24/07

Iran interested in building bridges with EEU across Armenia - expert

15:24 • 24/07

Warhol classic discovered after 40 years  

15:13 • 24/07

Trump’s son-in-law Kushner denies Russia collusion

14:51 • 24/07

Armenian parliament speaker attends 15th Armenian EyeCare Project conference

14:05 • 24/07

Free trade zone on Iranian border to boost bilateral trade – Armenian expert

13:23 • 24/07

Olympic legend fails to race a Great White during Discovery show

12:38 • 24/07

Passenger reported dead at Yerevan airport

12:18 • 24/07

Staff of leading Turkish paper face trial in press freedom test

11:52 • 24/07

Stubbs the cat, Alaska's honorary feline mayor, dies at 20 (photos)

11:46 • 24/07

Suicide car bomb leaves 24 killed in Afghan capital

11:30 • 24/07

Armenia joins Moscow International Army Games

10:55 • 24/07

Mkhitaryan: Last season's difficulties helped me improve

10:46 • 24/07

Strong earthquake breaches walls in southeast Iran

10:20 • 24/07

Russia deepens partnership with Azerbaijan while tightening grip on Armenia – expert  

09:33 • 24/07

IMF downgrades US and UK growth

09:12 • 24/07

British boat crew find £100M of Nazi gold in Hitler's shipwreck

16:00 • 23/07

Armenian border village heavily damaged in Azerbaijani gunfire (photos)

15:34 • 23/07

Turkish journalist exposes exclusive archive record on Genocide

14:45 • 23/07

'The things I'd have said to her... if I knew it was the last time we'd speak': William and Harry's agony over final phone call with Diana as they share unseen photos 

14:19 • 23/07

Armenia has no serious reason to quit EEU, says Republican lawmaker

13:50 • 23/07

Man City seal signing of Real Madrid right-back Danilo for £26.5m

13:28 • 23/07

US Congress in deal on new Russia sanctions

12:44 • 23/07

‘Melted nuclear fuel’ spotted in Fukushima

12:02 • 23/07

Macron’s rating falls by 10% over month, showing Worst Dynamics Since 1995 – poll

11:37 • 23/07

Armenian sportsmen win bronze in deaf wrestling championship  

11:06 • 23/07

Armenian church celebrating Vardavar or Transfiguration of Christ

10:17 • 23/07

Putin, Aliyev discuss Karabakh peace in Sochi

18:01 • 21/07

Kansas National Guard medical and hazardous material experts to train firefighters in Armenia

17:45 • 21/07

China to allow rice imports from US

17:12 • 21/07

Justin Bieber banned from China concerts for 'bad behavior'

17:01 • 21/07

Indian musician plays guitar during his brain surgery (video)  

16:44 • 21/07

Jerusalem clashes erupt amid holy site tensions

16:28 • 21/07

US to ban citizens from travel to North Korea, tour operators say

16:09 • 21/07

US Embassy can issue visas in extended valid passports – statement

15:47 • 21/07

Russian, Azerbaijani presidents set to meet in Sochi

15:14 • 21/07

Armenian youth basketball team wins Azerbaijan (video)

14:41 • 21/07

75% of Artsakh population backed incumbent leader - pollster  

13:52 • 21/07

Ford claims first 'pursuit rated' police pickup truck 

13:39 • 21/07

Ucom decreases prices for 'Internet in Roaming' bundles

13:06 • 21/07

Artsakh presidential elections stemmed from real hazards – Armenian analyst

12:15 • 21/07

No Armenians reported among survivors of Greek Island earthquake

11:59 • 21/07

Linkin Park vocalist Chester Bennington dies

11:47 • 21/07

Cooperation with US Department of Commerce discussed in Yerevan  

10:43 • 21/07

Russia extradites convicted bus driver to Armenia

10:17 • 21/07

Salvador Dali body exhumed

09:46 • 21/07

Azerbaijani director adapts Turkey’s failed coup into documentary

09:26 • 21/07

2 killed, 120 injured in Greek island earthquake

09:11 • 21/07

Deadly clashes in Venezuela as millions strike

18:00 • 20/07

Iranian tourist’s Armenia T-shirt spurs anger in Baku

17:46 • 20/07

Stevie Wonder marries third wife

17:31 • 20/07

Minister of labor and social affairs briefs president on welfare reforms

17:16 • 20/07

Ardshinbank օffers unprecedented terms of Cashback for non-cash transactions

16:49 • 20/07

Armenian cabinet approves plan to create joint military troops with Russia  

16:25 • 20/07

India launches first solar-panelled train in bid to cut down diesel use

16:06 • 20/07

Saudi king orders arrest of son for abusive behavior

15:47 • 20/07

US lifts laptop ban on Saudi Arabia flights

15:16 • 20/07

Armenia hosts first contemporary art triennial

14:17 • 20/07

Longest movie in history of cinema to last 720 hours (photos)

13:44 • 20/07

4.2 mgn quake hits Azerbaijan; jolts felt also in Nagorno-Karabakh

13:27 • 20/07

Azerbaijan sends Russian-Israeli blogger to 3 years in prison

13:14 • 20/07

Nagorno-Karabakh to have reformed state after transitional period – official

12:04 • 20/07

Excessive use of natural resources major concern – Karen Karapetyan  

11:21 • 20/07

Two new Harry Potter editions coming this October

11:01 • 20/07

Members of US Congress demand Erdogan apologize for embassy attack

10:18 • 20/07

Turkey school curriculum drops evolution theory to teach jihad

09:46 • 20/07

‘Erdogan regime’s days are numbered!’ - Turkish-Armenian public figure to Armenian Weekly

09:30 • 20/07

John McCain diagnosed with brain cancer, spokesman says

09:11 • 20/07

Trump's son and aides to testify in Senate about Russia

17:56 • 19/07

First double hand transplant involving child declared a success

17:50 • 19/07

Hungary police search international trains after bomb threat

17:42 • 19/07

US family of five is kicked off a JetBlue flight and banned from the airline after a heated row with a manager

17:30 • 19/07

Top French military official quits over cuts

17:17 • 19/07

Despacito named most streamed song of all time with 4.6 billion plays