Google urged to hand over salary details in gender equality court battle

11:55 • 17.07.17



A judge has ordered Google to hand over salary records to the government in an ongoing investigation by the US Department of Labor, which has accused the technology corporation of systematically discriminating against women, the Guardian reports.


Google must provide the federal government with a 2014 snapshot of the data, along with contact information for thousands of employees for possible interviews, according to a ruling made public on Sunday.


Judge Steve Berlin, however, also denied part of the government’s request for records and partially sided with Google, which had argued the department’s demands were overly broad and could violate employee privacy.


The limited records Google must release could help the Department of Labor (DoL) build a formal pay discrimination case against the company, which has repeatedly refused to disclose key data in what has become one of the most high-profile court battles to date regarding wage inequality in Silicon Valley. The department – which had argued that additional records would help explain the “extreme” gender pay gap it uncovered in an initial audit – said in a statement the decision “vindicates” its “vigorous enforcement” efforts.


The provisional order, written Friday, comes at a time of growing scrutiny of gender discrimination and sexual harassment across the tech industry, including a major scandal at Uber and a string of recent controversies involving prominent venture capitalists. 


The DoL first publicly accused Google of “systemic compensation disparities” in April, testifying in a hearing that its preliminary investigation found that women across a wide range of positions at the Mountain View campus were paid less than men.


Berlin’s decision resolves a more narrow court battle stemming from a DoL lawsuit filed against Google in January, which accused the corporation of violating federal laws in its refusal to turn over salary history and employee contact information. Google has contracts with the federal government, which means it is obliged to comply with equal opportunity laws and has to allow the DoL to review certain internal records.


Google originally provided a 2015 snapshot of salaries. The DoL subsequently requested compensation history and contact information for employees so it could conduct confidential interviews, but Google argued the demands violated fourth amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure.


Berlin’s ruling, which is a recommended order that still has to be finalized, said Google must provide the comparable 2014 snapshot, though he said the DoL’s demands for contact information for more than 25,000 workers was “over-broad, intrusive on employee privacy, unduly burdensome, and insufficiently focused”.

Instead, Google has to provide personal information for up to 8,000 employees the DoL selects, the ruling said. Berlin also denied the department’s broader request for salary and job history data, saying the

demands “create an unreasonable burden on Google and its employees”.

The department’s regional solicitor Janet Herold praised the decision in a statement, saying, “The court’s decision vindicates [DoL]’s vigorous enforcement of the disclosure and anti-discrimination obligations federal contractors voluntarily accept in exchange for taxpayer funds. Contractors will be held to their promise to let [DoL] fully audit their employment practices.”

Google has vehemently denied that it discriminates against women, publicly claiming that it has closed its gender pay gap globally. In a Sunday blogpost, Google said it was “pleased” with the decision and would comply with the order, providing the “much more limited data set of information”.

In a final hearing last month, Google argued it was financially burdensome and logistically challenging to compile and hand over the salary records the DoL had requested, saying it would have to spend up to 500 hours and $100,000 to comply with the ongoing demands. The defense earned a strong rebuke from the DoL and others in the industry who noted Google has touted its $150m “diversity” efforts and has a nearly $28bn annual income as one of the world’s wealthiest companies, building some of the most advanced technology.

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

13:35 • 25/11

Armenian officer with amputated limbs named world armwrestling champion

12:54 • 25/11

Clause on Artsakh ‘too generalized’ in EU-Armenia agreement – presidential spokesperson

11:52 • 25/11

Aravot: EU-Armenia agreement reflects reasonable policy choice – analyst

11:16 • 25/11

US military funds AI brain implants to handle post-traumatic stress disorders

11:00 • 25/11

Russia erects monument to assassinated Turkey ambassador

10:41 • 25/11

Nalbandian to attend La Francophonie Ministerial Conference in Paris

10:16 • 25/11

Zhoghovurd: EU-Armenia agreement to bring major changes to Armenia’s politics

09:38 • 25/11

Polish parliament adopts resolution marking the 650-year-long presence of Armenians in Poland

09:28 • 25/11

Egypt mosque attacked; at least 235 reported dead

09:16 • 25/11

EU, Armenia sign Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement (photos)

17:33 • 24/11

Eastern Partnership Summit Declaration adopted  

17:21 • 24/11

Serzh Sargsyan: EU-Armenia agreement defines guidelines for developing relations

16:54 • 24/11

EU-Armenia Agreement 'will be signed today' – Antonio Tajani

16:33 • 24/11

Converse Bank launching Woman’s card for Lady EXPO exhibition

16:18 • 24/11

Russia key role-player for Armenia, Azerbaijan – Germany’s Merkel

15:36 • 24/11

Christmas has arrived for the Queen! Her Majesty has a jaw-dropping 20 FOOT Nordmann Fir tree put up at Windsor Castle

15:00 • 24/11

UK to call out 'hostile' Russia at EU summit

14:34 • 24/11

Armenian President taking part in Eastern Partnership summit (photos)

14:00 • 24/11

Mitsubishi shares slump on data scandal

13:56 • 24/11

People have cancer because of their sins - Indian state minister

13:44 • 24/11

Like mother, like daughter! Kim Kardashian shares precious throwback video of her four-year-old self

13:36 • 24/11

Robinho denies sexual assault after 9 years in jail sentence

13:14 • 24/11

Armenian president, Belgian premier discuss bilateral agenda

12:56 • 24/11

Bright flash in night sky over Japan lights up police hotlines and the internet

12:44 • 24/11

Uma Thurman vents anger at Harvey Weinstein  

12:30 • 24/11

Azerbaijan urged to lift travel ban on journalist

11:59 • 24/11

EU opens EaP summit in Brussels amid Armenia’s expectations to sign new cooperation deal (live)

11:15 • 24/11

All-Armenian fund raises $12,505,456 in 2017 telethon (photos)

10:53 • 24/11

Haykakan Zhamanak: 20,000 Armenians reside in Baku, says Azerbaijani scholar

10:13 • 24/11

Eight 'North Korean fishermen' wash ashore in Japan

10:01 • 24/11

Debate on withdrawal from EEU strengthens Armenia's positions – Richard Giragosian

09:13 • 24/11

Zimbabwe to swear in new president

17:09 • 23/11

EU-Armenia agreement offers vast guarantees for state sovereignty  - opinion

16:16 • 23/11

Saudi elite facing torture by US mercenaries

16:04 • 23/11

Azerbaijani army captain found dead close to Armenia’s state border

15:46 • 23/11

NATO warns against escalations in Karabakh  

15:14 • 23/11

Turkey sends extradition demands for Gulen to US

15:08 • 23/11

Deal signed to return Rohingya to Muslims

15:02 • 23/11

We will hail Azerbaijan’s EEU accession if commitments respected - official

14:34 • 23/11

Kim Kardashian's new fragrance line sells out in 6 DAYS raking in $14 million

14:12 • 23/11

Coordinated approach to Karabakh key element in EU-Armenia agreement - analyst

13:24 • 23/11

Stunning 'Farewell to Saturn' mosaic created from Cassini's final views of the planet

12:48 • 23/11

Armenian premier orders specific steps to develop digital agenda

12:13 • 23/11

Putin, Rouhani and Erdogan discuss Syria in Sochi

12:00 • 23/11

George Avakian, jazz producer and scholar, dead at 98

11:37 • 23/11

Turkey, Azerbaijan still unlikely to accept Armenia’s plan to use regional rail link – Georgian expert

10:41 • 23/11

Zhoghovurd: EU, Armenia may call off partnership agreement

10:29 • 23/11

Samsung Electronics to launch AI research center

10:15 • 23/11

EU: Press Azerbaijan on Rights at Summit – Human Rights Watch

09:56 • 23/11

Zhamanak: EU-Armenia agreement not yet ratified by eight countries

09:37 • 23/11

Paris police use tear gas to combat education plan protest

09:23 • 23/11

Four killed in Georgia terror siege

18:02 • 22/11

House that takes 6 hours to build and costs just $33K

17:48 • 22/11

Boeing jets auctioned online for $48m

17:34 • 22/11

Britain's most notorious prisoner refused parole or chance to move to an open jail just days after wedding

17:23 • 22/11

Hot lips: Eyes and a smiling mouth spotted in Ethiopian volcano

17:11 • 22/11

Georgia says suspected militant captured in ongoing counterterrorism operation

16:53 • 22/11

Only Russia can resolve Karabakh conflict – Erdogan

16:21 • 22/11

US prosecutors charge Iranian in 'Game of Thrones' hack

15:59 • 22/11

3-year-old pays whopping $2.64M for car license plate in Abu Dhabi

15:51 • 22/11

US Navy plane crashes in Philippine Sea; 3 missing

15:47 • 22/11

Mladic jailed for life over Bosnia war genocide

15:34 • 22/11

Lebanon: Hariri says to hold off resignation as PM

15:21 • 22/11

No serious changes expected in Karabakh peace talks – political analyst

14:38 • 22/11

More details released in fatal incident at Artsakh military post

14:12 • 22/11

Mugabe successor due back to Zimbabwe from exile

13:22 • 22/11

Lavrov underlined parity principle with Armenia, Azerbaijan - analyst

12:33 • 22/11

Skype removed from China app stores

12:24 • 22/11

Sevilla coach reveals cancer during draw with Liverpool

12:11 • 22/11

Karabakh should be axiomatic priority in EaP Summit Declaration – Armenian parliamentarian

11:36 • 22/11

Uber paid hackers for massive data breach cover-up

11:30 • 22/11

Ivanka and Tiffany Trump join National Thanksgiving Turkey Presentation

11:20 • 22/11

Hariri back in Lebanon for first time since resignation

11:07 • 22/11

'Partridge Family' heartthrob David Cassidy dies at 77

10:56 • 22/11

Armenian youth actively joins European HIV-Hepatitis testing week

10:16 • 22/11

Turkey: Zaman journalist sentenced to 7.5 years in prison

10:01 • 22/11

Zhoghovurd: No technical obstacles to EU-Armenia agreement - Switalski

09:40 • 22/11

Three Armenian soldiers die in mine explosion in Nagorno-Karabakh

09:25 • 22/11

Zimbabwe celebrates end of Mugabe era

09:12 • 22/11

Trump, Putin hold hour-long phone call on foreign affairs

18:19 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s EEU integration impossible without Armenia’s consent – Russian analyst

17:16 • 21/11

Converse Bank launches special product for customers receiving foreign transfers

16:29 • 21/11

Armenia to receive 1.3m NATO assistance

15:47 • 21/11

UEFA release team of 21st century

15:40 • 21/11

US ending temporary permits for almost 60,000 Haitians

15:32 • 21/11

Barron Trump towers over Melania - aged just 11 - as the pair greet the official White House Christmas tree

15:19 • 21/11

Egyptian singer held for ‘suggestive video’

14:52 • 21/11

VEON Ltd conducts leadership meeting in Armenia  

14:40 • 21/11

Merkel hints fresh elections after coalition defeat

14:24 • 21/11

Kim Kardashian's pregnant surrogate shows off baby bump while running errands (photos)

14:10 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s statements run counter to practical steps – Nalbandian

13:40 • 21/11

Iran’s Rouhani declares end of Islamic State

13:15 • 21/11

All elements to resolve Karabakh conflict 'in place' – Sergey Lavrov

12:40 • 21/11

168 Zham: EU-Armenia agreement 'no threat to Russia and Eurasian Union' – analyst

12:13 • 21/11

NASA reveals bizarre shape of interstellar asteroid

11:50 • 21/11

Zhamanak: Lavrov gave Azerbaijan clear message on Karabakh, says Russian expert

10:45 • 21/11

US approves $75m sale of Javelin anti-tank missiles to Georgia

10:27 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s EEU membership 'not acceptable now' - Armenian economist

10:03 • 21/11

Syria military operations nearing end; Putin and Assad meet in Sochi

09:43 • 21/11

Game of Thrones operator Mark Milsome dies in Ghana