Google urged to hand over salary details in gender equality court battle

11:55 • 17.07.17



A judge has ordered Google to hand over salary records to the government in an ongoing investigation by the US Department of Labor, which has accused the technology corporation of systematically discriminating against women, the Guardian reports.


Google must provide the federal government with a 2014 snapshot of the data, along with contact information for thousands of employees for possible interviews, according to a ruling made public on Sunday.


Judge Steve Berlin, however, also denied part of the government’s request for records and partially sided with Google, which had argued the department’s demands were overly broad and could violate employee privacy.


The limited records Google must release could help the Department of Labor (DoL) build a formal pay discrimination case against the company, which has repeatedly refused to disclose key data in what has become one of the most high-profile court battles to date regarding wage inequality in Silicon Valley. The department – which had argued that additional records would help explain the “extreme” gender pay gap it uncovered in an initial audit – said in a statement the decision “vindicates” its “vigorous enforcement” efforts.


The provisional order, written Friday, comes at a time of growing scrutiny of gender discrimination and sexual harassment across the tech industry, including a major scandal at Uber and a string of recent controversies involving prominent venture capitalists. 


The DoL first publicly accused Google of “systemic compensation disparities” in April, testifying in a hearing that its preliminary investigation found that women across a wide range of positions at the Mountain View campus were paid less than men.


Berlin’s decision resolves a more narrow court battle stemming from a DoL lawsuit filed against Google in January, which accused the corporation of violating federal laws in its refusal to turn over salary history and employee contact information. Google has contracts with the federal government, which means it is obliged to comply with equal opportunity laws and has to allow the DoL to review certain internal records.


Google originally provided a 2015 snapshot of salaries. The DoL subsequently requested compensation history and contact information for employees so it could conduct confidential interviews, but Google argued the demands violated fourth amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure.


Berlin’s ruling, which is a recommended order that still has to be finalized, said Google must provide the comparable 2014 snapshot, though he said the DoL’s demands for contact information for more than 25,000 workers was “over-broad, intrusive on employee privacy, unduly burdensome, and insufficiently focused”.

Instead, Google has to provide personal information for up to 8,000 employees the DoL selects, the ruling said. Berlin also denied the department’s broader request for salary and job history data, saying the

demands “create an unreasonable burden on Google and its employees”.

The department’s regional solicitor Janet Herold praised the decision in a statement, saying, “The court’s decision vindicates [DoL]’s vigorous enforcement of the disclosure and anti-discrimination obligations federal contractors voluntarily accept in exchange for taxpayer funds. Contractors will be held to their promise to let [DoL] fully audit their employment practices.”

Google has vehemently denied that it discriminates against women, publicly claiming that it has closed its gender pay gap globally. In a Sunday blogpost, Google said it was “pleased” with the decision and would comply with the order, providing the “much more limited data set of information”.

In a final hearing last month, Google argued it was financially burdensome and logistically challenging to compile and hand over the salary records the DoL had requested, saying it would have to spend up to 500 hours and $100,000 to comply with the ongoing demands. The defense earned a strong rebuke from the DoL and others in the industry who noted Google has touted its $150m “diversity” efforts and has a nearly $28bn annual income as one of the world’s wealthiest companies, building some of the most advanced technology.

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

13:58 • 21/09

Putin, Erdogan to discuss Syria peace plan next week

13:49 • 21/09

Chelsea, Man City face FIFA investigation over youth signing

13:35 • 21/09

Zhoghovurd: Government lavishes funds on Armenia-Diaspora conference

13:21 • 21/09

Justin Trudeau sports Chewbacca socks for meeting with IMF chief Christine Lagarde 

13:08 • 21/09

Brussels to offer help border regions

12:53 • 21/09

Game of Thrones' star to open up 'closed shop' film industry

12:41 • 21/09

The $147bn team photo: Warren Buffett takes to the stage with fellow billionaires and Diddy for Forbes' 100th birthday party

12:24 • 21/09

Putin congratulates Armenian president on independence anniversary

12:15 • 21/09

Apple concedes new smartwatch has connectivity glitch  

12:07 • 21/09

Turkey hosts NATO naval drills amid tensions

11:45 • 21/09

Artsakh war heroes remembered on independence anniversary

11:20 • 21/09

Iraqi Kurdistan referendum poses challenge for Turkey – Financial Times

10:44 • 21/09

September 21 carries invaluable message for Armenians - opinions

09:38 • 21/09

Flourishing and prosperous country is the dream of all Armenians – Bako Sahakyan

09:24 • 21/09

Mexico quake: Race to find survivors under collapsed school  

18:01 • 20/09

Azerbaijan imparting religious context to Karabakh conflict - official  

17:15 • 20/09

Barcelona condemn Spanish crackdown on Catalan independence vote

16:55 • 20/09

Serzh Sargsyan affirmed Armenia's position on Karabakh from UN podium – politician

16:13 • 20/09

US State Department tightens visa rules

16:05 • 20/09

‘Architects of Denial’ screening to open 2017 ANCA-WR grassroots conference

15:51 • 20/09

Porsche officially launches $16m hybrid yacht (ohotos)

15:30 • 20/09

Armenian president’s UN speech strong message to back Nagorno-Karabakh’s self-determination - official  

14:18 • 20/09

US congressmen strengthen solidarity with Artsakh during working visit to Shushi and Stepanakert

13:05 • 20/09

Armenian official blasts Azerbaijan over stalemate in Karabakh peace talks

12:10 • 20/09

Serzh Sargsyan says Armenia will be 'consistent in promoting UN goals'

11:55 • 20/09

British woman, 47, gives birth to healthy baby seven years after menopause

11:35 • 20/09

Azerbaijan Laundromat: Merkel ally 'received cash from regime' – The Guardian  

11:22 • 20/09

Armenian American orphans Christmas telethon strives to be most successful one yet – LA Times Jeff Landa

10:50 • 20/09

Nalbandian to meet with OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs in NYC

10:22 • 20/09

Nagorno-Karabakh president meets with US congress members in Yerevan

10:01 • 20/09

Erdogan reiterates call on Kurds to cancel independence referendum

09:53 • 20/09

Serzh Sargsyan meets with President of Poland in New York

09:35 • 20/09

Trump slams Maduro at UN, calling him Hitler

09:16 • 20/09

Right to self-determination vital element in Karabakh peace – Serzh Sargsyan

18:08 • 19/09

Armenia needs active Diaspora investments  -  economist  

17:01 • 19/09

Russian arms supplies to Abkhazia, Tskhinvali pose regional hazards - Georgian ambassador

16:43 • 19/09

Ardshinbank offers mortgages with lower interest rates

15:33 • 19/09

Armenian figure skaters to join Olympic Qualifier in Germany

14:54 • 19/09

Armenian delegates hamper passage of pro-Azerbaijani report by PACE committee

14:22 • 19/09

Only democratic Turkey can recognize Armenian Genocide – Garo Paylan

13:36 • 19/09

World’s first all-electric yacht unveiled (photos)

13:11 • 19/09

Hayk Kotanjian: The importance of engaging renowned Diaspora Armenians in the cause of the establishment of Cyber Resources Management System in the RA

12:46 • 19/09

Conjoined twins born to US parents who already have five children

12:16 • 19/09

Erdogan, Stoltenberg discuss S-400 deal with Russia, KRG referendum

12:01 • 19/09

Idea to build effectively developing modern state inspiring for all Armenians – Karen Karapetyan

11:24 • 19/09

US ‘shocked’ by Russian-Turkish missile system deal  – Armenian analyst

10:16 • 19/09

US Senate passes $700bn defense policy bill

09:52 • 19/09

Zhamanak: Georgia backs new Armenian ambassador's appointment

09:32 • 19/09

US withdraws proposed arms sale to Erdogan’s security detail

09:13 • 19/09

Hurricane Maria lashes Dominica

14:11 • 18/09

Nagorno-Karabakh’s exclusion from peace talks accounts for Azerbaijani aggression - Karen Mirzoyan

13:35 • 18/09

Emmys: Diversity reigns over Trump as ‘Big Little Lies,’ ‘Handmaid’s Tale,’ ‘SNL’ dominate

13:20 • 18/09

President: Just and developing country lays firm groundwork to preserve Armenian identity  

12:44 • 18/09

Rolling Stone magazine up for sale

12:18 • 18/09

Our key objective is to increase Armenia’s population to 4 million by 2040 – Serzh Sargsyan

11:24 • 18/09

Automated police station opens in Dubai (photos)

11:12 • 18/09

Armenia-Diaspora conference good platform to unite over common concerns - Manoyan

10:47 • 18/09

China, Russia launch naval drills in North Korea  

10:35 • 18/09

I am very happy to be in Armenia – Garo Paylan

10:14 • 18/09

Eight killed in powerful storm in Romania

09:57 • 18/09

Turkey summons German ambassador over pro-PKK rally in Cologne

09:40 • 18/09

Sixth Armenia-Diaspora conference opens in Yerevan

09:10 • 18/09

Man Utd 4-0 Everton: Martial and Mkhitaryan stats highlight contrast with last season

21:58 • 16/09

Public and private sector cooperation is vital for AI development in Armenia: PicsArt co-founder H. Avoyan

14:58 • 16/09

Former CNN employee received $2.6m through ‘Azerbaijani laundromat’

14:32 • 16/09

Millions of world’s children lack birth certificate

14:12 • 16/09

Francis Bacon painting hidden away for almost 50 years set to sell for a record price at auction

14:01 • 16/09

Rosatom plans to start building Turkish nuclear plant in early 2018

13:40 • 16/09

Chance of 'catastrophic' climate change completely wiping out humanity by 2100 is now 1-in-20

13:15 • 16/09

London terror threat level raised to critical, says PM

13:06 • 16/09

Jennifer Lawrence planning hiatus

12:55 • 16/09

Turkey, US urge Kurdish leader to cancel planned independence referendum

12:30 • 16/09

Armenia, Nagorno-Karabakh host annual sporting festival

12:13 • 16/09

Full-size Titanic replica ‘half-complete’ (photos)

11:41 • 16/09

US Congress members planning 'unprecedented trip' to Armenia

10:44 • 16/09

North Korea seeks ‘equilibrium of force’ with US – Kim Jong-un

10:34 • 16/09

Lapshin urges Armenians to ‘stay strong,’ denies Azerbaijan’s suicide claims

10:09 • 16/09

US artist uses up to 20,000 screws to create impressive portraits

09:43 • 16/09

Queen Letizia of Spain celebrates 45th birthday

09:31 • 16/09

EU Council expands North Korea sanctions list after latest missile launch

09:12 • 16/09

IS claims responsibility for London attack

17:59 • 15/09

Ardshinbank general sponsor of unprecedented mega-show

17:53 • 15/09

South Korean artist captures beauty of falling in love in romantic pictures

17:27 • 15/09

Breast cancer breakthrough: Reducing belly fat could have life-saving effect

16:55 • 15/09

European court orders Armenia to pay €6,000 over failure to ensure effective investigation  

16:01 • 15/09

Home-made bomb caused explosion on London train

15:46 • 15/09

Ex CIA chief quits Harvard over Mannig

15:19 • 15/09

UEFA opens disciplinary proceedings over Arsenal-Cologne crowd chaos

15:12 • 15/09

Mercedes-Benz X-CLass ‘appalling’, says BMW (photos)

14:53 • 15/09

Hurricane Irma wipes out Barbuda island, US ambassador reveals (photos, video)

14:47 • 15/09

Turkey's purchase of Russian missile system may trigger sanctions, says US official  

14:40 • 15/09

Turkey feels betrayed over EU accession, says minister

14:20 • 15/09

Minister reports 35% economic growth in Armenia's IT sector  

13:40 • 15/09

Several injured in 'terrorist' incident on London underground train (updates, photos)  

13:18 • 15/09

He stands for champion of truth in Cause for Justice on Genocide – Turkish intellectuals remember Dink on birthday anniversary

11:58 • 15/09

Lady Gaga hospitalized with 'severe pain'

11:11 • 15/09

EU must change its view of Turkey - Chavushoglu

10:56 • 15/09

Angelina Jolie meets with UN Secretary General António Guterres in NYC

10:43 • 15/09

Armenia, EU close to signing new cooperation deal – European official

10:14 • 15/09

Haykakan Zhamanak: Three reported missing after illegally crossing Armenia-Turkey border