Downing North Korean missiles is hard. so the US Is Experimenting. – NY Times

13:46 • 18.11.17



By David E Sanger and William J Broad


Concerned that the missile defense system designed to protect American cities is insufficient by itself to deter a North Korean attack, the Trump administration is expanding its strategy to also try to stop Pyongyang’s missiles before they get far from Korean airspace.


The new approach, hinted at in an emergency request to Congress last week for $4 billion to deal with North Korea, envisions the stepped-up use of cyberweapons to interfere with the North’s control systems before missiles are launched, as well as drones and fighter jets to shoot them down moments after liftoff. The missile defense network on the West Coast would be expanded for use if everything else fails.


In interviews, defense officials, along with top scientists and senior members of Congress, described the accelerated effort as a response to the unexpected progress that North Korea has made in developing intercontinental ballistic missiles capable of delivering a nuclear bomb to the continental United States.


“It is an all-out effort,” said Senator Jack Reed of Rhode Island, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, who returned from a lengthy visit to South Korea last month convinced that the United States needed to do far more to counter North Korea. “There is a fast-emerging threat, a diminishing window, and a recognition that we can’t be reliant on one solution.”


For years, that single solution has been the missile batteries in Alaska and California that would target any long-range warheads fired toward the American mainland, trying to shoot them down as they re-enter the atmosphere. Such an approach, known as “hitting a bullet with a bullet,” remains of dubious effectiveness, even after more than $100 billion has been spent on the effort. Antimissile batteries on ships off the Korean coast and in South Korea protect against medium-range missiles, but not those aimed at American cities.


So the administration plans to pour hundreds of millions of dollars into the two other approaches, both of which are still in the experimental stage. The first involves stepped-up cyberattacks and other sabotage that would interfere with missile launches before they occur — what the Pentagon calls “left of launch.” The second is a new approach to blowing up the missiles in the “boost phase,” when they are slow-moving, highly visible targets.


President Trump has praised the existing missile defense system, insisting last month that it “can knock out a missile in the air 97 percent of the time,” a claim that arms control experts call patently false. In trial runs, conducted under ideal conditions, the interceptors in Alaska and California have failed half of the time. And the Pentagon has warned administration officials that the North will soon have enough long-range missiles to launch volleys of them, including decoys, making the problem far more complex.


That helps explain the rush for new protections.


“They’re looking at everything,” said Thomas Karako, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, who recently led two antimissile studies and closely monitors the administration’s planning. “What you’re seeing is a lot more options on the table.”


The $4 billion emergency budget sought by the White House is on top of the $8 billion that the Missile Defense Agency has already been granted for this fiscal year, as well as what other military services and agencies are putting into missile defense. Another $440 million was moved from existing programs to antimissile work two months ago, as the North Korea threat became more serious.


In the emergency request to Congress, and in documents made public by its committees, the precise use of the funds is cloaked in deliberately vague language.


Hundreds of millions of dollars, for example, are allotted for what the documents called “disruption/defeat” efforts. Several officials confirmed that the “disruption” efforts include another, more sophisticated attempt at the kind of cyber and electronic strikes that President Barack Obama ordered in 2014 when he intensified his efforts to cripple North Korea’s missile testing.


Using cyberweapons to disrupt launches is a radical innovation in missile defense in the past three decades. But in the case of North Korea, it is also the most difficult. It requires getting into the missile manufacturing, launch control and guidance systems of a country that makes very limited use of the internet and has few connections to the outside world — most of them through China, and to a lesser degree Russia.


In the operation that began in 2014, a range of cyber and electronic-interference operations were used against the North’s Musudan intermediate-range missiles, in an effort to slow its testing. But that secret effort had mixed results.


The failure rate for the Musudan missile soared to 88 percent, but it was never clear how much of that was due to the cyberattacks and how much to sabotage of the North’s supply chain and its own manufacturing errors. Then Kim Jong-un, the country’s president, ordered a change in design, and the test-launches have been far more successful.


The experience has raised difficult questions about the effectiveness of cyberweapons, despite billions of dollars in investment. “We can dream of a lot of targets to hack,” said Michael Sulmeyer, director of the Cyber Security Project at Harvard and formerly the director for cyberpolicy planning and operations in the office of the defense secretary. “But it can be hard to achieve the effects we want, when we want them.”


Congressional documents also talk of making “additional investments” in “boost-phase missile defense.” The goal of that approach is to hit long-range missiles at their point of greatest vulnerability — while their engines are firing and the vehicles are stressed to the breaking point, and before their warheads are deployed.





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

09:40 • 20/06

Mice chew up cash worth Rs 12 lakh in Assam ATM

09:32 • 20/06

2019 BMW 8 Series Coupe launched with 523 horses on tap

09:25 • 20/06

US quits UN human Rights Council, saying it’s anti-Israel

09:12 • 20/06

France and Germany agree on common Eurozone plan

17:56 • 19/06

New Armenian government’s program deserves intn’l support - Alex Johnon’s article in The Hill

17:28 • 19/06

IT sector good platform 'to revise emigration models’ – Nikol Pashinyan

16:54 • 19/06

Perth Zoo has farewels world's oldest Sumatran Orangutan

16:30 • 19/06

Ex-army general faces criminal charges after being stripped of immunity

15:51 • 19/06

Armenian police seize trucks loaded with food for soldiers

14:44 • 19/06

Emilia Clarke says goodbye to Game Of Thrones  

14:19 • 19/06

Azerbaijan shoots down Armenian drone in Artsakh

14:05 • 19/06

Inside America's Armageddon bunkers: Pictures show once secret doomsday hideouts built to withstand a nuclear apocalypse

13:43 • 19/06

Armenian parliament strips notorious lawmaker of immunity  

13:00 • 19/06

Aznavour delays comeback from fall

12:51 • 19/06

Turkey's Erdogan vows 'third nuclear power plant' plan

12:20 • 19/06

Armenia's prosecutor general asks parliament to strip former army general of immunity

12:02 • 19/06

Fewer Armenians seek asylum in Europe - report

11:41 • 19/06

Zhamanak: Armenia-Artsakh relations 'in interstate domain'

10:57 • 19/06

Garo Paylan: I am happy for Armenia and ready to assist in future dialogue with Turkey  

10:17 • 19/06

Apple fined for misleading customers in Australia

10:01 • 19/06

Croatia send striker home for refusing to play

09:52 • 19/06

Russians launch giant Soyuz spacecraft over World Cup city

09:28 • 19/06

North Korea leader visits China after Trump summit

09:12 • 19/06

Trump plans to reclaim America's spot as 'world's greatest spacefaring nation'

18:24 • 18/06

Audi chief arrested in Germany over diesel scandal

18:18 • 18/06

John Travolta mob film gets whacked by critics

17:38 • 18/06

Nikol Pashinyan calls for comprehensive probe into former army general's criminal case  

16:52 • 18/06

Turkey opens natural gas pipeline from Azerbaijan

13:21 • 18/06

Bulgaria ratifies EU-Armenia agreement

12:32 • 18/06

First tourism information center opens in Yerevan

11:46 • 18/06

Bitcoin 'bringing internet to halt'

10:35 • 18/06

Taliban ends truce in Afghanistan despite plea

10:29 • 18/06

WC 2018: Brazil 1-1 Switzerland

10:23 • 18/06

Chic or shocking? Meghan Markel's £4k floaty wrap dress gets mixed reactions as she and Harry are guests at his cousin's wedding

10:11 • 18/06

At least 3 killed, 200+ injured after 6.1 quake strikes Osaka, Japan

09:45 • 18/06

Mayor of Echmiadzin resigns

09:12 • 18/06

Conservative politician elected Columbia president

15:02 • 16/06

No geopolitical context behind Armenia's 'velvet revolution', Prime Minister tells Russia Today  

13:58 • 16/06

Georgian president confirms nomination of new prime minister

13:40 • 16/06

Grand Chess Tour: Aronian leads tournament ahead of final day

13:17 • 16/06

BarCamp opens annual master class series in Yerevan

12:09 • 16/06

Nikol Pashinyan starting ‘short trip’ to Artsakh

11:44 • 16/06

Zhoghovurd: Azerbaijan’s belligerent intentions towards Artsakh ‘big challenge’

11:08 • 16/06

Adults in polyamorous relationship declared legal parents of child in Canada

10:16 • 16/06

Zhoghovurd: Armenia’s social affairs minister may retract resignation?   

10:04 • 16/06

Japan hit by tropical storm

09:58 • 16/06

WC 2018: Portugal 3-3 Spain

09:43 • 16/06

Trump says meeting with Putin ‘possible’ this summer

09:28 • 16/06

Greece, Macedonia to sign name change accord

09:13 • 16/06

Eiffel Tower perimeter fence built to stop terrorism

18:30 • 15/06

Russia seeking 'increased influence' on Armenia, Artsakh, warns poltiical analyst

17:53 • 15/06

Fox apologizes for Robbie Williams’ WC 2018 gesture

17:20 • 15/06

Taner Akçam: Turkey’s apologies for Genocide ‘not enough’ to reinstate historical justice

16:06 • 15/06

Kremlin spokesperson: Too early to talk about Russian-Armenian-Azerbaijani presidential summit

15:36 • 15/06

Ucom to launch Viasat Family Channels

15:15 • 15/06

Surveillance video shows man stealing Banksy artwork from Toronto show  

14:00 • 15/06

Stephen Hawking's voice to be beamed into space

13:51 • 15/06

Erdogan blamed for collapse of Turkish Lira  

13:26 • 15/06

Convicted Nagorno-Karabakh former top commander freed (updated)

12:49 • 15/06

Armenia’s permanent representative to ECHR steps down

12:27 • 15/06

Armenia shows democratic reform can triumph even in Russia’s shadow – Washington Post

12:09 • 15/06

Baku 'testing’ Armenian authorities – Russian expert

11:37 • 15/06

Trump and family sued by New York attorney general over alleged charity violations

11:14 • 15/06

Germany migrant row threatens Angela Merkel coalition

10:45 • 15/06

Hraparak: OSCE Minsk Group ‘slowing plans’ to ensure Karabakh’s direct engagement in peace talks

09:42 • 15/06

Trump questioned why allies opposed Russia's annexation of Crimea

09:28 • 15/06

World Cup 2018: Russia beat Saudi Arabia 5-0

09:21 • 15/06

16 killed in Indonesia ferry accident

09:14 • 15/06

Anthony Bourdain cremated in France

17:52 • 14/06

Zohrab Mnatasakanyan holds phone conversation with UK state minister

17:25 • 14/06

Glendale leaders honor Armenian Americans by voting to name street after Artsakh

17:16 • 14/06

Wounded leopard strays Into village in China

17:08 • 14/06

Turkey proposes Russia joint production of missiles

16:51 • 14/06

OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs sum up meetings with Armenian officials

16:24 • 14/06

Armenian prime minister attends unveiling of Hamazasp Babajanyan's bust in Moscow

15:35 • 14/06

Ship carrying 900 migrants docks in Sicily as Italy fights back over row over turning away aid ship with 600 on board

14:19 • 14/06

Nikol Pashinyan visits Armenian church in Moscow (photos, video)

13:36 • 14/06

EU ambassador hails Armenia's progress in Eastern Partnership Project

13:03 • 14/06

Museum seeking world record for largest paper plane

12:58 • 14/06

No 'Party Like A Russian' for Robbie Williams at 2018 World Cup opening

12:53 • 14/06

Bill Clinton's thriller sees fastest fiction sales in two years

12:48 • 14/06

Ten-year-old Hermes Birkin handbag sells for $ 217.000

12:39 • 14/06

Armenian prime minister meets with VTB Bank top official in Moscow

12:12 • 14/06

Armen Sarkissian attends Queen’s Day celebration events at British Embassy

11:52 • 14/06

Turkey’s Erdogan vows to lift state of emergency if re-elected

11:44 • 14/06

Georgian Prime Minister Giorgi Kvirikashvili resigns after anti-government protests

11:37 • 14/06

Armenian parliament passes State Budget execution bill

11:19 • 14/06

Antarctica loses three trillion tonnes of ice in 25 years

11:06 • 14/06

US lays out terms of North Korea sanctions relief

10:45 • 14/06

Pashinyan, Putin discuss Armenian-Russian relations in Moscow

09:36 • 14/06

Macedonian president says he won't sign 'disastrous' name deal with Greece

09:13 • 14/06

France's National Front founder Jean-Marie Le Pen hospitalized

17:52 • 13/06

Egypt named safest country in Africa

17:42 • 13/06

Russian, Azerbaijani leaders meet in Moscow  

17:16 • 13/06

Trump says North Korea ‘no longer a nuclear threat’ to US

17:03 • 13/06

Armenia-Artsakh cooperation discussed in Stepanakert

16:49 • 13/06

Meghan Markel's first official role as a member of British monarchy is revealed as she formally becomes part of The Royal Foundation

16:35 • 13/06

Armenian prime minister welcomed at Moscow airport

16:26 • 13/06

US, Canada and Mexico to host 2016 FIFA World Cup

16:12 • 13/06

Armenian court frees civic activists convicted over coup plot