Nalbandian: Azerbaijan’s intentions can be easily tracked by its expenditures – Nalbandian

16:30 • 07.12.17



Armenian Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian addressed the unresolved Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) conflict in his recent speech at the OSCE’s 24th Ministerial Conference, blaming the Azerbaijani leadership for hampering the internationally-mediated peace efforts.


In his speech at the meeting in Vienna, Armenia’s top diplomat also enumerated nine major reasons accounting for the failure to end the long-lasting land dispute.


His full speech, published by the Foreign Ministry’s press service, is provided below:



Mr Chairman,


Dear Colleagues,


Ladies and Gentlemen,


I would like to thank the Chairmanship-in-Office for leading the organization throughout the year, good organisation of the Ministerial Council and the warm hospitality.


Armenia has always been a strong advocate for advancing the indivisible security in the OSCE area and has continuously contributed to the discussions aimed at reinvigoration of the framework of arms control and CSBMs.


Building trust and confidence does not rest only with the first dimension. We strongly believe that the economic and environmental basket of our Organization has an untapped potential. In this regard the OSCE could be a natural platform for promoting an inclusive dialogue between participating States, including on regional integration processes.


About two weeks ago Armenia signed a Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement with the European Union. It vividly demonstrated that the membership to one integration framework, in the case of Armenia to the Eurasian Economic Union, does not preclude cooperation with the others. We hope that pragmatic and result oriented dialogue will be the driving force of the economic cooperation in the whole OSCE area.


We would also like to emphasize Armenia’s contribution to the human dimension of our activities and highlight in this regard our effective cooperation with the OSCE institutions. The April Parliamentary elections in Armenia demonstrated that the progress achieved in upholding fundamental freedoms is irreversible and sustainable and we acknowledge the contribution of the OSCE institutions in this regard.


We are glad that the theme of protection of the ethnic and religious groups from identity based violence and atrocities especially in our neighboring region – in the Middle East, is getting more and more attention within the OSCE. Armenia has been among the first to raise this issue and support the strengthening of the OSCE commitments in this regard. The further development of effective measures to counter hate crime and discrimination against Christians and members of other religions was the main focus of the recent high-level conference in Yerevan, co-organized by the OSCE Chairmanship and ODIHR with the support of the Armenian Foreign Ministry.


Ladies and Gentlemen,


The Ministerial Councils provide an opportunity to talk about the achievements and vision for the future. However, it is equally important not to omit to address the setbacks of the Organization in an open and candid manner.


The consequences of the closure of the OSCE Office in Yerevan pertain to very essence of the OSCE, which is designed to settle the issues through dialogue and cooperation and never through imposing the position of one participating State at the expense of all others and the entire Organization. It created a very negative precedent. The refusal of Azerbaijan to join the consensus on the extension of the mandate of the Office damaged not merely the integrity of the field missions of the OSCE, but its capacity of inclusive cooperation. Azerbaijan failed to respect the OSCE commitments and eliminated the OSCE Office in its own country before it attacked and closed the last OSCE full-fledged mission in the region. It is particularly deplorable that the Office was closed against the will and consistent efforts for its preservation exerted by the host country and all participating States with one exception - Azerbaijan. We would like to recall that both German and Austrian Chairmanships rejected the accusations of Azerbaijan against Yerevan Office. It does not come as a surprise that Azerbaijan found itself in isolation in challenging the OSCE Office in Yerevan.


We are determined to continue our close cooperation within the OSCE framework. The “Armenia cooperation programme” opens good opportunities in this regard.


Mr Chairman,


Ten years ago the Basic Principles for the Peaceful Settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict were presented to the sides by the Minsk Group Co-Chair countries in the margins of the OSCE Ministerial Council in Madrid.


Two years later the Athens Ministerial Council of the OSCE adopted a statement on behalf of all participating States that strongly supported the Basic Principles and noted the commitment of the parties to reach an agreement on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict resolution based upon the principles of Non-Use of Force or Threat of Force, Territorial Integrity, and the Equal Rights and Self-Determination of Peoples. The presidents of the Co-Chair countries in their five joint statements issued since 2009 reiterated their support to these principles and main elements for the conflict resolution which were presented by them as an integrated whole. Since then the Co-Chairs have reaffirmed this approach on many occasions, including during almost all OSCE Ministerial Councils and most recently in their joint statement made in Hamburg. On numerous occasions Armenia has continuously reiterated its readiness to continue negotiations based on these principles and elements with the aim of the exclusively peaceful settlement of the conflict.


There are several reasons why till now it has not been possible to advance the peace process despite numerous meetings on the presidential and ministerial levels, many rounds of negotiations, the tireless mediation by the Co-Chair countries, and the strong endorsement of the OSCE and all others who have supported the efforts and approaches of the Co-Chairs.


First, Azerbaijan made a step back and has refused the abovementioned three principles of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict resolution as a basis for the conflict settlement.


Second, Azerbaijan adopted a selective approach towards the elements proposed by the Co-Chairs, who have continuously warned against such practice, since they conceive their proposals as an indivisible whole, and made it clear that any attempt to select some principles and elements over others would make it impossible to achieve a solution.


Third, Baku does not comply with the reached agreements and backtracks from them, as it happened during many rounds of negotiations, most notably during the Summits in St. Petersburg (June 2010), Astrakhan (October 2010), Sochi (March 2011), Kazan (June 2011). The pattern of refusal by Azerbaijan to honor prior agreements seriously questions Baku’s credibility as a negotiating party.


Fourth, almost constant profanation of the Co-Chairs’ efforts and the attempts to shift the mediation to other formats have been illustrative of Azerbaijan’s intentions to derail the negotiations. It does not come as a surprise that the Co-Chairs in their public statements called on Baku to reverse this stance.

 

Fifth, the use or threat of use of force by Azerbaijan, regular ceasefire violations and provocations, unnotified military exercises in a blatant noncompliance to the OSCE Vienna document, bellicose statements of the high-ranking officials of Azerbaijan demonstrate that Baku considers the war as a viable option. The Co-Chairs have appealed to Azerbaijan to refrain from the escalation of the situation, to reaffirm the commitment to peaceful settlement. Nobody doubts that it is Azerbaijan that constantly violates the ceasefire and resorts to the escalation of the situation.


Sixth, a serious damage was caused to the negotiation process by Azerbaijan’s aggression against Nagorno-Karabakh in April 2016 that was accompanied by the grave violations of international humanitarian law, atrocities against the civilian population, including children, women and elderly persons, mutilation of the bodies, DAESH-style beheadings.


Seventh, after April aggression the Co-Chairs organized two summits in Vienna and St. Petersburg with the participation of the Presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan to address the consequences of the war. Azerbaijan refused to implement what had been agreed upon and emphasized in the framework of these Summits particularly on the exclusively peaceful settlement of the conflict, full adherence to the 1994-1995 trilateral ceasefire agreements, which do not have time limitations, creation of mechanism for the investigation of ceasefire violations, expansion of the team of the Personal Representative of the OSCE Chairperson-in-Office with the aim to increase efficiency of the monitoring capacities on the ground. The reported goal of these agreements was to create conditions for the advancement of the peace process, thus, by rejecting them Baku intentionally hinders the negotiations.


Eighth, Azerbaijan continues to practice anti-Armenian hate speech, it calls all Armenians of the world its enemy number one, it writes in the textbooks that Armenians are genetic enemies of Azerbaijan, it erases all traces of indigenous Armenian cultural heritage and religious sites, it claims that allegedly territories of Armenia are ancient Azerbaijani lands. Azerbaijan has long blacklisted the people of Nagorno-Karabakh, and then it started to put in the blacklist all those who visit Nagorno-Karabakh. Those who genuinely aspire for peace do not do such actions.


Ninth, after many years of negotiations on the Basic Principles, Azerbaijan started to claim that there is no need for adopting them, in a sheer disrespect to other negotiating parties, to the Co-Chair countries and huge efforts and time invested in the process.


Azerbaijan’s uncompromising and maximalist stance has become a serious obstacle to the advancement of the peace process and has heavily contributed to the preservation of the status-quo. The Co-Chairs’ conflict settlement proposals are a way that could bring to the change of the status-quo. However, Azerbaijan rejects those proposals, doing everything to keep the status-quo intact at the same time claiming that allegedly it is advocating for the change of status-quo.


Azerbaijan’s intentions can be easily tracked by its expenditures: Baku spends billions to buy influence in the world capitals, as once again became obvious through notorious “Laundromat” affair, it spends much more for purchases of advanced weaponry, but it has not invested anything so far to prepare its population for peace, as the Co-Chairs have been continuously urging.


If Baku abides to the calls of the Co-Chairs to strictly respect the ceasefire, implements previously reached agreements, reiterates its adherence to the principles of the conflict resolution proposed by the Co-Chairs and constructively engages in the negotiations that will pave the way to move the peace process forward and change the status-quo.

We are convinced that there is no alternative to the peace talks and there is a need to conduct intensive negotiations based on the proposals of the Co-Chair countries.


It is with this understanding that I met six times with my Azerbaijani colleague during past year and the last one was just yesterday in the framework of this Ministerial Council. The meetings between the Ministers and the able mediation of the Co-Chairs helped to prepare the Geneva Summit of Presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan on October 16th, 2017. This was the first meeting between the Presidents after about sixteen months interval and it passed mostly in a positive mood.


For the first time in about four years at the Geneva Summit it was possible to adopt, although quite brief, a joint statement. On numerous previous occasions Armenia expressed its readiness to join the statements of the Co-Chairs, however, Azerbaijan always refused to have a common statement. This joint statement reflected what Armenia has been long advocating for: to take additional steps to reduce tensions on the Line of Contact. These steps have been identified in the statements made at the Vienna and St. Petersburg Summits of 2016. The Geneva statement also stressed the necessity to intensify the negotiation process, and this too has always been strongly advocated by Armenia.


Unfortunately, just after the Summit Baku again resorted to its language of groundless accusations and warmongering.


Yesterday’s meeting with my Azerbaijani colleague generally passed in the positive mood. We will see the developments after it.


Mr Chairman,


Next year people of Nagorno-Karabakh will mark 30 years of their struggle for the right to choose their destiny, for human dignity and freedom. In three decades people of Artsakh despite the devastating war and all difficulties, succeeded to create a society based on the respect of human rights, fundamental freedoms and democratic institutions. The settlement of the conflict should respect all inherent rights of the people of Artsakh and should ensure their unhindered implementation.


Mr Chairman,


In conclusion, I would like to assure Italy, the incoming Chair that it can count on Armenia’s support. I would also like to welcome Slovakia’s joining the Troika.


 

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:57 • 13/12

2017 marked serious progress in Armenia-NATO relations – debate

18:04 • 13/12

Amal and George Clooney 'hand out personalised headphones and notes' to fellow plane passengers on flight with twins

17:34 • 13/12

FBI agent removed from Russia investigation calls Trump an 'idiot'

17:08 • 13/12

Opposition MP says political team 'considers alternative candidate' for prime minister

16:19 • 13/12

European Central Bank could use Steinhoff mess to improve QE

16:01 • 13/12

Princes William and Harry inspect  Star Wars troops in London premiere

15:46 • 13/12

Palestinians will not accept any US role in peace process 'from now on', says Mahmoud Abbas

15:29 • 13/12

Erdogan calls on Jerusalem to be recognized as Palestinian capital 

15:15 • 13/12

No challenges to NATO-Armenia relations - liason officer

14:20 • 13/12

Australian Greens recognize Nagorno-Karabakh Republic

13:14 • 13/12

US ready for North Korea talks, says Tillerson

13:07 • 13/12

6.2 quake hits south-eastern Iran

12:52 • 13/12

Armenian parliament passes anti-domestic violence law

12:34 • 13/12

Fossil hunters find bones of human-sized penguin on New Zealand beach

12:22 • 13/12

Nalbandian: Azerbaijan's disrespect for peace over Karabakh questions their credibility in negotiations  

11:57 • 13/12

Disney set to seal $60bn 21st Century Fox takeover

11:44 • 13/12

Armenia free to develop balanced dialogue with EU and Russia –  European expert

09:35 • 13/12

US Democrat wins seat in Alabama in blow to Trump

09:12 • 13/12

Hamas announces beginning of third 'Intifada' against US decision on Jerusalem

18:06 • 12/12

Armenian biker to join international race in Portugal

17:51 • 12/12

Terrifying footage shows newlywed bride attacked by shark during Caribbean honeymoon swim

17:40 • 12/12

France proposes ban for mobile phones in schools from September

17:16 • 12/12

European court orders Azerbaijan to pay €35,000 in compensation to displaced Armenian family  

16:31 • 12/12

Musician who lost arm can play piano again with 'insanely cool prosthetic' (video)

16:06 • 12/12

Armenia can build EEU’s bridge with Europe in case of securing safe hub for businesses – French Ambassador  

15:12 • 12/12

Canadian lawmaker speaks of April war in Artsakh in parliament address (video)

14:33 • 12/12

Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson and Lauren Hashian can't hide delight as she debuts blossoming baby bump at Jumanji 2 premiere in LA... hours after revealing pregnancy news

14:24 • 12/12

Private arrested over reported fatality in Nagorno-Karabakh army

13:56 • 12/12

Donald Trump wants to send man back to Moon, on to Mars

13:47 • 12/12

'Violent explosion' at Austrian gas plant leaves 'one dead and dozens injured' (photos, video)

13:37 • 12/12

Nagorno-Karabakh conflict ‘far from frozen’ - French ambassador

13:12 • 12/12

Bomber strikes near times square, disrupts New York City, killing none

13:05 • 12/12

Erdogan, Putin warn of further tension over Trump’s Jerusalem move

13:02 • 12/12

'Ucomisation': Ucom launches new revolutionary offer

12:45 • 12/12

Armenian Genocide bill stops short of reaching Georgian local government

11:53 • 12/12

Nagorno-Karabakh conscript fatally wounded by fellow serviceman  

11:40 • 12/12

168 Zham: EU-Armenia agreement reflects smart policy choice – Lithuanian analyst

11:00 • 12/12

Turkey seeks to provoke tensions with neighbors instead of normalizing ties– expert  

09:30 • 12/12

Nalbandian to conduct official visit to Greece

09:13 • 12/12

Ukrainian court releases Saakashvili from detention

18:01 • 11/12

Hidden keylogger found on HP laptops

17:51 • 11/12

Golden Globe announces complete list of 75th nominations  

17:22 • 11/12

Armenian parliament speaker hosts chief of UNDP country mission

16:38 • 11/12

Ucom to keep on supporting Armath engineering lab in Armenian border village

16:28 • 11/12

Nalbandian hosts delegation from Armenian Assembly of America

16:22 • 11/12

Uruguay hosts world’s biggest barbecue

15:56 • 11/12

Former batsman banned after spot-fixing investigation

15:43 • 11/12

Saudi Arabia to allow to reopen cinemas after decades’ ban

15:18 • 11/12

US intelligence warned Congress of N Korea nuke threats in 2006

15:09 • 11/12

Putin orders withdrawal of Russian troops from Syria

14:55 • 11/12

Japanese investors need adequate legal guarantees in Armenia – ambassador

14:03 • 11/12

Trump's visa restrictions not applicable to Armenians holding dual citizenship– US Embassy

13:06 • 11/12

Ex-ombudsperson complains about massive human rights abuses in Armenia

12:08 • 11/12

Stunned man spots himself as child photobombing his fiancee's holiday photo 10 years ago

11:24 • 11/12

Poverty rate 'steadily high' in Armenia since 2006 – economist  

10:18 • 11/12

California could still be fighting fires at Christmas thanks to 16-day drought and unusually warm weather

10:03 • 11/12

Power and travel disruption across UK

09:44 • 11/12

Erdogan calls Israel a 'child-murderer' state

09:32 • 11/12

Venezuela’s Maduro bans opposition from running in 2018 election

09:08 • 11/12

Bitcoin futures surge past $18,000; Asian shares firm

19:56 • 09/12

Rafaella Carnevalle in Yerevan to design first boutique hotel in Fendi, Feragammo style and conduct Xcat boat race in Sevan

15:07 • 09/12

Ronaldo ‘best player in history’ - Zidane

15:00 • 09/12

Armenians feel morally obliged to assist in intn’l genocide campaign

14:53 • 09/12

‘Mermaid baby’ dies in India hours after birth, with doctors unable to identify gender

14:44 • 09/12

France bids farewell to Johnny Hallyday

14:23 • 09/12

Apple in talks to acquire Shazam

14:06 • 09/12

EU-Armenia agreement no reason to contrast West with Russia – analyst

13:08 • 09/12

Constitution objectively testifies to our democracy-building – Bako Sahakyan

12:49 • 09/12

No need for witch-hunt to fight corruption in Armenia – lawyer

12:01 • 09/12

Queen Elizabeth spotted wearing identical outfit as her Nigerian guest

11:34 • 09/12

US airstrikes kill 5 al-Qaida operatives in Yemen

11:06 • 09/12

168 Zham: Russia opposed to Turkish intervention in Karabakh peace - Paul Goble

10:32 • 09/12

Oxford tops ranking of world's best universities

10:04 • 09/12

EU, Japan conclude world's largest free trade deal

09:30 • 09/12

Instagram testing direct, standalone messaging app that replaces current inbox

09:18 • 09/12

Saakashvili arrested in Ukraine

14:25 • 08/12

Ucom sponsors launch of online portal for interactive methods and distant learning

13:26 • 08/12

Confrontational Erdogan stuns Greek hosts on Athens visit – The Guardian

12:17 • 08/12

Armenia to pay €15,000 to ECHR applicant

11:24 • 08/12

Armenian parliament adopts state budget for 2018

10:53 • 08/12

Turkish intellectuals refuse to make apologies for Artsakh visit

10:28 • 08/12

North Korea ready to open direct talks with US

10:12 • 08/12

Chorrord Ishkanutyun: Top Armenian military commander set to resign

09:48 • 08/12

Martin Schulz proposes 'United States of Europe' plan

09:33 • 08/12

US warns against scrapping Abbas talks after Trump’s Jerusalem move

09:15 • 08/12

OSCE Minsk Group co-chairing states call for mutual responsibility to end Karabakh conflict

18:01 • 07/12

Armenian premier pledges Gyumri development plan  

17:57 • 07/12

Ardshinbank named best foreign exchange provider in Armenia  

17:24 • 07/12

Florida burglar swipes guns, ammo from Florida police car

16:58 • 07/12

Australian parliament backs same-sex marriages

16:39 • 07/12

Palestinians and Israelis clash following Trump’s move on embassy

16:30 • 07/12

Nalbandian: Azerbaijan’s intentions can be easily tracked by its expenditures – Nalbandian

16:05 • 07/12

Rex Tillerson: US backs Minsk Group efforts towards Karabakh peace

15:39 • 07/12

Trump’s Jerusalem statement major concern to world Christians - Armenian patriarch

14:36 • 07/12

Russell Crowe under fire over ‘sodomising’ female co-star

14:17 • 07/12

Leonardo da Vinci painting heads to Louvre Abu Dhabi  

14:09 • 07/12

Bitcoin surges above $14,000 to new high

14:01 • 07/12

Georgian woman captured while trying to enter Turkey in suitcase

13:40 • 07/12

Gyumri plunging into deeper poverty due to failure to eliminate disaster risks – NGO president

12:35 • 07/12

168 Zham: EU seeks concessions over EaP program to avoid conflicts with Russia - expert