Armenian authorities fail to protect women victims of domestic violence - HRW  

17:39 • 12.01.18



The lives and well-being of women and children in Armenia who have survived domestic violence are in jeopardy because of the Armenian government’s failure to ensure their protection, Human Rights Watch said today.

In December 2017, Armenia’s parliament passed a law on violence in the family, but women and children remain at risk until the government comprehensively changes how police respond to complaints of violence and provides accessible, quality services for survivors.


Human Rights Watch spoke with 12 survivors of severe domestic abuse in Armenia. The women said their husbands or male partners punched and kicked them, raped them, struck them with furniture and other objects, confined them in their homes, stalked them, and threatened or attempted to kill them with knives or other sharp objects. Five women said the attacks against them continued during pregnancy; three said they had miscarriages after their husbands beat them.


“Armenian authorities have failed to protect women and others from domestic violence, putting women’s and children’s health and lives in jeopardy,” said Jane Buchanan, associate Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “The new law is one important step, but until authorities take reports of domestic violence seriously and ensure that women and children get the legal, medical, and social help they need, the danger remains.”


Those interviewed said that when they reported abuse to police or other authorities, the authorities did nothing to prevent further violence, investigate cases, or hold the attackers accountable. In some cases, the authorities encouraged women to drop complaints and reconcile with their abusers. The authorities did not refer the women for services or assistance.


Armenia’s Coalition to Stop Violence against Women, an alliance of nongovernmental women’s rights organizations, reported that at least four women were killed by their partners or other family members in the first half of 2017, and at least 50 were killed between 2010 and 2017. The Coalition received 5,299 calls about incidents of domestic violence from January through September 2017.


In one case, Human Rights Watch documented Gayane (not her real name), 45, said that her former husband repeatedly beat her during their eight-year marriage, stalked her after she divorced him, and frequently broke into her house to rob and attack her, most recently in November. “He grabbed me by the hair and threw me on to the sofa,” Gayane said. “He jumped on top of me and put his elbows on my throat, trying to strangle me. I bit him in the arm and he let go, but he dragged me off the sofa, threw me down on the floor, and started to kick me all over, shouting, ‘Die!’”


When Gayane ran to the police in her nightclothes, they said, “Oh, so you came and want to do something about your husband? He beat you? And so? Why did you let him in?” After receiving treatment at the hospital for a sprained wrist and numerous bruises, Gayane returned home to find her former husband asleep in her house with her two sons. Police refused to intervene.


Children witnessed abuse against their mothers, often for many years, and several women said their
husbands committed violence against their children. Human Rights Watch also documented other family members, such as in-laws, abused women.


The new law requires police to urgently intervene “when there is a reasonable assumption of an immediate threat of repetition or the continuation of violence” in the family. Urgent measures include police removing the alleged attacker from the home and prohibiting them from approaching or communicating with the victim. Courts can issue six-month protection orders, with two possible three-month extensions.


Many women said they lived with their abusers for years because they had no means of escape. The country has only two domestic violence shelters, both in the capital, Yerevan, run by nongovernmental organizations, each with a capacity for five women and their children. Council of Europe standards call for at least one specialized shelter in every region, and one shelter space per 10,000 people. With a population of approximately 2.9 million, Armenia should have approximately 290 shelter spaces. The new law mandates creating government-run shelters, but does not specify the number of shelters or their capacity. 


The law defines domestic violence as “a physical, sexual, psychological, or economic act of violence” between family members, including spouses in unregistered marriages. It is not clear if the law applies to couples who are not in registered or unregistered marriages.


Just before submitting the law to parliament in mid-November, the government revised the law to include “strengthening of traditional values in the family” as a key principle. Authorities also changed the title to add the concept of “restoring harmony in the family.”


The Coalition to Stop Violence against Women expressed concerns that the new law’s principle of “traditional values” could be used to reinforce obsolete and problematic gender roles and stereotypes. Activists also fear an emphasis on “restoring harmony” could be used to pressure women to remain in abusive relationships.


During a December 6 meeting, Armenia’s minister of justice, David Harutyunyan, told Human Rights Watch that the concept of “restoring harmony in the family” recognizes the government’s obligation to not only protect victims, but to provide services to the alleged abuser, such as alcohol or drug treatment. He said that these initiatives would not take priority over protection.


The new law requires authorities to investigate alleged crimes in the family even if the victim withdraws a complaint to the police. It also mandates training for police, prosecutors, judges and others in the criminal justice system on how to respond to complaints and investigate and prosecute cases.


The European Union insisted the government of Armenia pass a domestic violence law as a condition for certain budgetary support. The European Commission also called on Armenia to ratify the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence, known as the Istanbul Convention. In late December, the government approved the possible signature of the convention, but has not yet done so.


“Women in Armenia need the government to provide meaningful protection from abusive husbands and partners, not to reinforce gender stereotypes about men’s dominance or family roles that can contribute to violence in the first place,” Buchanan said.


Accounts from Domestic Violence Survivors


Human Rights Watch conducted in-depth interviews with 12 survivors of domestic violence in Armenia: 11 in December 2017 and one in May 2016. Human Rights Watch also interviewed women’s rights activists and representatives of organizations providing services to survivors of domestic violence, who described similar accounts of abuse, authorities’ response to domestic violence, and obstacles to accessing services for survivors. Everyone interviewed was informed of the purpose of the interview, its voluntary nature, and the ways the information would be used. All provided verbal informed consent. The interviews highlighted survivors’ experiences and the legal and other protection gaps that the government should address, including through the new law on family violence. Where necessary, pseudonyms have been used to protect interviewees’ identities.





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:12 • 25/04

Genocide-era mass graves found in Rwanda

18:05 • 25/04

Barcelona Open: Djokovic beaten in second round by Martin Klizan

17:58 • 25/04

Modigliani sets world record with estimate in excess of $150m

17:52 • 25/04

WhatsApp raises minimum age to 16 in Europe ahead of GDPR

17:30 • 25/04

Karen Karapetyan 'not resigning from post' despite strong anti-government protests

17:11 • 25/04

Iran rejects West’s nuclear proposal

16:49 • 25/04

A toast to 'unbreakable friendship': Trump and Melania pull out all the stops as they host President Macron, French first lady and 120 guests at the White House for glittering state dinner

16:32 • 25/04

Gmail gets self-destruct option ahead of GDPR

16:10 • 25/04

ARF-D lawmaker joining opposition protests  

15:29 • 25/04

Rare blue diamond ring fetches $6.7 million at Sotheby’s

15:19 • 25/04

Trump tightens Turkey’s grip over US policy on Genocide

14:34 • 25/04

Erdogan hosts dinner for Azerbaijani counterpart

14:18 • 25/04

Acting minister of sport steps down

13:51 • 25/04

President Armen Sarkissian to hold political consultations with parties

13:38 • 25/04

Opposition parties extend support to Pashinyan's movement 'against Republican PM'

12:55 • 25/04

We place no restrictions on political agenda – Karen Karapetyan

11:57 • 25/04

Coast Guard confiscates nearly $1b worth of cocaine and marijuana off the coast of Florida

11:44 • 25/04

Armenian opposition continues civil disobedience campaign

11:26 • 25/04

Zhoghovurd: Political developments in Armenia ‘pave way to resolving corruption scandals’  

10:53 • 25/04

Armenian opposition leader calls for 'stepping up campaign against Republican’

10:07 • 25/04

US urges for constructive transition of power in Armenia

09:49 • 25/04

Armenian-Americans flood LA streets as they call on government to formally recognize Genocide

09:35 • 25/04

Nicaragua faces detained protesters

09:13 • 25/04

Trump warns Iran of 'big problems'

18:30 • 24/04

Ex France midfielder Henri Michel dies at 70

17:51 • 24/04

What happened to the Armenians? – Turkish columnist

17:02 • 24/04

How Trump could tell the truth about Armenian genocide – CNN

16:42 • 24/04

Azerbaijan's ruling families linked to secret investments via Maltese bank – The Guardian

16:23 • 24/04

Aurora Prize committee names three potential recipients of 2018 award

16:05 • 24/04

Karen Karapetyan hosts Russian-Armenian businessman  

15:14 • 24/04

Serzh Sargsyan's downfall 'not about geoppolitics' - Thomas de Waal

14:54 • 24/04

Genocide changed our people’s fate, but 'we proved really stronger' – Karen Karapetyan

14:29 • 24/04

Oscars Academy sets key dates for 91st ceremony

13:52 • 24/04

EU envoy pledges to step up ratification of CEPA

13:29 • 24/04

‘Historic day for Armenia’ – Kim Kardashian

13:18 • 24/04

Trump, Macron plant oak tree outside White House

13:10 • 24/04

Aliyev to visit Turkey

12:50 • 24/04

Turkey will accept truth on Genocide 'sooner or later' - ARF-D member

12:02 • 24/04

Blue for a boy! London landmarks burst with light to mark the arrival of Kate and William's third child

11:28 • 24/04

Special ritual served in Tsitsernakaberd in memory of Genocide victims  

10:58 • 24/04

Memory of Armenian Genocide ‘refers to each of us’ - Emmanuel Macron

10:26 • 24/04

Eight cabinet ministers re-appointed

10:08 • 24/04

April 24 marks 103rd anniversary of Armenian Genocide

09:10 • 24/04

Serzh Sargsyan yields to public pressure, resigns as PM amid opposition protests

18:27 • 21/04

President Armen Sarkissian says ready to meet with opposition leader  

17:48 • 21/04

Queen Elizabeth marks 92nd birthday with gun salutes in central London and a party at the Royal Albert Hall

17:03 • 21/04

Turkish Foreign Ministry says US remarks on early polls 'unacceptable'

16:41 • 21/04

RFE/RL journalist attacked during protest In Armenia

15:45 • 21/04

Algerian woman denied French citizenship for refusing to shake man’s hand

15:30 • 21/04

Bako Sahakyan issues 'call for unity' amid opposition protests in Armenia

15:21 • 21/04

‘Smallville’ actress arrested in self-help guru's NY sex traffic case

14:49 • 21/04

Serj Tankian: This movement is authentic and completely yours (video)

13:10 • 21/04

Serzh Sargsyan calls for urgent political dialogue 'to avoid irreversible losses’

12:41 • 21/04

Armenian opposition leader’s calls ‘unconstitutional’ – Russian analyst

11:24 • 21/04

Opposition rally: Day 9 (updated)

11:02 • 21/04

Saakashvili issues call for ‘urgent dialogue’ between Armenian authorities and oppositon

10:24 • 21/04

EU leaders issue congratulations to Serzh Sargsyan

10:00 • 21/04

US Democrats sue Trump, Russia and Wikileaks

09:37 • 21/04

North Korea 'halts missile and nuclear tests', says Kim Jong-un

09:26 • 21/04

North Korea 'halts missile and nuclear tests', says Kim Jong-un

18:11 • 20/04

Paylan calls on Turkish government to recognize Genocide  

17:19 • 20/04

Armenian president re-appoints more ministers

17:00 • 20/04

Bentley launches official representation in Armenia

16:12 • 20/04

This is a ‘revolution of technologies’ - Alexander Iskandaryan  

15:38 • 20/04

Budget 6.1-inch LCD iPhone lineup could start at $550

15:13 • 20/04

Ratification of EU-Armenia deal ‘unrelated to domestic political developments ’ – parliament official

13:34 • 20/04

US concerned about Turkey’s ability to hold transparent election

12:56 • 20/04

Ariana Grande unveils 'emotional single'

12:31 • 20/04

More protesters arrested as opposition rally continues

11:56 • 20/04

Police issue fresh warnings to participants of opposition rally

11:39 • 20/04

Turkish parliament committee ratifies election bill

11:23 • 20/04

Yerevan protests: Police continue arresting activists

10:39 • 20/04

Opposition rally: Day 8 (updated, photos)

10:29 • 20/04

OSCE/ODIHR Director urges Armenian authorities to protect and ensure right to freedom of peaceful assembly

10:09 • 20/04

Zhoghovurd: Foreign leaders do not make haste to issue congratulations to Armenian premier

09:35 • 20/04

Syria returns Assad award to France

09:15 • 20/04

Berlin set for mass evacuation as WW2 bomb is defused

17:55 • 19/04

Couple’s wedding reception goes up in flames when fireworks set the ceiling display alight and 300 guests have to flee the burning building

17:41 • 19/04

Young Armenian sambo athletes win 11 medals in European championship (photos)

17:04 • 19/04

Trump delivers Tribute to Barbara Bush in press conference speech

16:47 • 19/04

Robots master task of assembling Ikea chair  

16:12 • 19/04

Armenian president re-appoints three cabinet ministers

15:51 • 19/04

Medvedev congratulates Serzh Sargsyan on being appointed prime minister

14:56 • 19/04

Hollywood Studio chiefs hail opening of Saudi Arabia's first cinema

13:43 • 19/04

Latvian parliament ratifies EU-Armenia agreement

12:54 • 19/04

Syria crisis: Unexploded missiles ‘handed over to Russia’

12:46 • 19/04

Magnitude 5.9 earthquake strikes Bushehr Province 

12:14 • 19/04

Yerevan protests: Police urge journalists 'to keep reasonable distance’

11:55 • 19/04

2017 was unique year ‘without public protests’ in Armenia – Serzh Sargsyan

11:00 • 19/04

Glendale City Council approves Armenian American Museum project

10:49 • 19/04

2 killed, over 300 buildings damaged in Indonesia earthquake

10:05 • 19/04

Armenian opposition continues rally against prime minister (updated)

09:20 • 19/04

Top Japan official resigns over sex scandal

18:05 • 18/04

Russia vows ‘painful response’ to US sanctions

17:57 • 18/04

Turkey: Erdogan calls snap elections

17:36 • 18/04

Karen Karapetyan appointed Vice Premier

17:07 • 18/04

Azerbaijan not to use Russian missile system sold to Turkey – expert

16:34 • 18/04

Russia Today to face investigations over spy poisoning case

16:12 • 18/04

Iceland's Bitcoin heist suspect 'flees on PM's plane'

15:57 • 18/04

Run-away Dubai princes ‘brought back home’