Why didn’t Putin interfere in Armenia’s Velvet Revolution? – Foreign Affairs

12:33 • 18.05.18



His Support for Authoritarianism Abroad Has Limits


By Lucan Ahmad Way


This April, Serzh Sargsyan, the pro-Russian autocratic leader of Armenia, confronted massive opposition protests reminiscent of the wave of “color revolutions” that took place in eastern Europe in the first decade of this century. Like past political revolutions in Serbia in 2000, Georgia in 2003, and Ukraine in 2004, the protests in Armenia shut down the capital and drew heavily on disenchanted youth as well as humor to challenge entrenched autocratic elites.


Led by the former journalist and political prisoner Nikol Pashinyan, demonstrators sought to unseat Sargsyan and his Republican Party of Armenia (RPA), which have dominated Armenian politics for nearly two decades. Sargsyan was first elected president in 2008, succeeding Robert Kocharian, who came to power in 1998. To sidestep Sargsyan’s impending term limit, the RPA orchestrated a transition from a presidential to a parliamentary system with the intention of selecting Sargsyan as prime minister. Sargsyan’s election to the position on April 17, however, sparked tens of thousands of people to take to the streets against his rule.


Such protests seemingly presented a fundamental challenge to Russian President Vladimir Putin. Putin is terrified by the potential diffusion of mass anti-dictatorial movements to his own country and has long been obsessed by the threat of “color revolutions” in the region. Partly as a result, he has a history of interfering to protect autocrats in Russia’s neighborhood. Putin backed the dictatorial Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych, who faced protests in Ukraine in 2013–14 and intervened in a wide range of elections throughout the region, including presidential elections in Belarus in 2006 and in Ukraine in 2004 and 2014. (And of course, Putin has also recently sought to disrupt the democratic process in the United States and Western Europe.)


Several Russian commentators worried that the Armenian protests were part of a Western conspiracy to foment student revolution at Russia’s doorstep and that the opposition might turn Armenia against Russia. Sargsyan has been a constant ally of Russia. In 2015, giving into Russian pressure, he brought Armenia into the Russian-dominated Eurasian Economic Union. Russia in turn has long supported the Armenian government, providing subsidized natural gas as well as critical military assistance to Armenia in its three-decades-long conflict with Azerbaijan over the Nagorno Karabakh territory. Russia has 5,000 troops stationed in Armenia and helps to patrol the country’s border with Turkey. Given Russia’s stake in the regime and history of intervention in the region, one might have expected Putin to throw his full support behind Sargsyan and the RPA. Indeed, after Sargsyan was forced to resign in the face of protests on April 23, Russia initially worked behind the scenes to orchestrate a transfer of power to Karen Karapetyan, the former head of Russian-controlled Gazprom in Armenia. Russian-controlled media outlets began to label the protests “another maidan” directed by the West.


But when the RPA was unable to impose Karapetyan in the face of mass unrest, Putin was unexpectedly silent. Russian media halted its efforts to discredit Pashinyan, and Russian authorities did not try to pressure the Armenian authorities to use force against the opposition as they did in Ukraine in early 2014. After Pashinyan was elected prime minister on May 7 with the support of 13 defecting RPA deputies, Putin was among the first to congratulate him, even though, as a former political prisoner and protest leader, Pashinyan is pretty much the opposite of the kind of leader Putin typically likes to work with. What explains Russia’s apparent acceptance of the latest Eurasian revolution?


PUTIN'S PRIORITIES

 

To understand Putin’s behavior, it is important to correct several partial misconceptions about Russian foreign policy and its impact in the region. First, despite his reputation for autocracy promotion, Putin cares much more about the geopolitical balance of power than he does about whether countries outside of Russia are democratic or authoritarian. As a result, Putin has been extremely inconsistent in his support for autocrats outside Russia’s borders. (Within Russia is obviously another story.)


Russia has sought to undermine democracy in countries such as Ukraine that are dominated by anti-Russian forces. Putin has supported pro-Russian dictators confronting anti-Russian challengers, such as Ukraine’s Leonid Kuchma in 2004, Yanukovych in 2013–14, and Moldova’s Vladimir Voronin in 2009. But he has been equally happy to support competitive elections and even protests when such measures undermine anti-Russian governments. After Kyrgyzstan’s autocratic President Kurmanbek Bakiyev reneged on a promise in 2009 to deny the United States access to the Manas air base, the Russian government began airing negative stories about Bakiyev in Russian media in Kyrgyzstan and increased fuel prices—moves that helped spark protests that overthrew Bakiyev in April 2010. The Kremlin threw its support behind the much more democratic Presidents Roza Otunbayeva and Almazbek Atambayev. Similarly, Putin did nearly everything to undermine Georgia’s autocratic and anti-Russian President Mikheil Saakashvili and welcomed the democratic transfer of power from Saakashvili to Giorgi Margvelashvili in 2013. Putin is obviously no democracy promoter and, given the choice, would no doubt prefer to deal with other dictatorships. But there is little evidence that he is willing to make any serious effort to foster authoritarian rule for its own sake.


In Armenia, Putin’s acquiescence to Pashinyan was almost certainly facilitated by the fact that Pashinyan, in stark contrast to opposition in Ukraine in 2013–14, made a point of committing to maintain the geopolitical status quo. (This despite the fact that his small election bloc Yelq had earlier called for closer relations to Europe.) The protests saw no European Union flags or other signs indicating that the new forces would challenge the Russia’s regional dominance. Furthermore, Armenia’s vulnerable international position and dependence on Russian military support make it extremely costly for any Armenian leader to leave Russia’s orbit—a fact that likely contributed to Russia’s calm during the protests. Remittances from Armenians working in Russia account for a significant portion of Armenia’s gross domestic product. Russian companies control virtually all of the country’s energy supply. In a possible effort to highlight costs of altering Armenia’s orientation, Russian authorities recently warned that they could at any moment ban the import of Armenian fruits and vegetables.

 

Understanding the Kremlin’s behavior also requires correcting another common misconception about Russian foreign policy: that Putin is a grandmaster of external politics able to control political outcomes both in Russia’s neighborhood as well as in more powerful countries such as the United States. In fact, Putin may have acquiesced to Pashinyan because he felt that any attempt to save the RPA government would fail. Russian interventions, after all, have a relatively poor rate of success in the post Soviet region. In fact, the Kremlin’s favored candidate has lost in seven of the 11 documented cases of electoral interference since the collapse of the Soviet Union. In 2005, for example, Russia unsuccessfully attempted to prevent the reelection of the Communist Party in Moldova. And after Russia changed its mind and chose to support the communists in 2009, the party fell in the face of protests.


More significant, in 2004 in Ukraine, Putin invested enormous resources and his own prestige to support Ukrainian then Prime Minister Yanukovych’s presidential campaign. His actions, however, created a backlash and helped to spark the Orange Revolution, which led to Yanukovych’s downfall. A decade later, extensive Russian intervention was unable to prevent the rise to power of a stridently anti-Russian government in Ukraine. Although Putin has gained control over Crimea, Russia’s actions have permanently doomed any prospect of Ukrainian integration into Russia’s orbit and severely marginalized pro-Russian parties that used to dominate Ukrainian political life. Ukrainian support for the Eurasian Economic Union has dramatically declined since 2014. After Russia’s experience in Ukraine, Putin may have worried that openly backing an unpopular regime in Armenia would generate a similar popular backlash.

 

DEMOCRACY UNDER RUSSIAN HEGEMONY

 

Could recent events augur an emerging model of democratization under Russian external hegemony? By avoiding open challenges against Russian external policies, even small and dependent countries such as Armenia may be able to democratize without fear of interference. The relatively democratic and pro-Russian Kyrgyzstan, which saw a peaceful and competitive transfer of power in elections in late 2017, may represent another example. Such a model of course deprives countries of their rightful ability to choose external allies. But it is still preferable to a situation in which countries lack both external autonomy and internal democracy.


Ultimately, the fate of democracy in Armenia will hinge much more on domestic factors than on actions by Russia. Indeed, the failure of democracy in Russian-dominated countries has had far more to do with domestic factors in these countries than anything Russia has done. It is still unclear whether Pashinyan will move Armenia closer to democracy or continue the autocratic practices of the old ruling party. At the same time, there are several positive signs. First, Pashinyan, a former opposition journalist, is one of the few real outsiders to take power in the post-Soviet region where opposition leaders have typically emerged as defectors from the old autocratic regime. Furthermore, Pashinyan has almost no party organization to speak of and thus is likely to have trouble monopolizing control even if he wanted to. Finally, and perhaps most important, the old ruling RPA has promised to cede control of the government and to go into opposition. It is still not clear whether the party will remain intact or eventually be coopted by the new leadership. But Armenian democracy would be well served by a coherent and oppositional Republican Party that can present a check on the power of the new government.


There is overall little that Armenia or its post-Soviet neighbors can do to get rid of Putin or reduce Russia’s military and economic dominance in the region. But none of this prevents these countries from becoming democracies within their own borders.





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:12 • 19/10

Kocharyan lawyers to file appeal with European court

17:10 • 19/10

No prison overcrowding in Armenia, says acting minister

16:21 • 19/10

Australian family's terror as bull shark jumps into tinny during fishing trip

16:07 • 19/10

Aliyev travels to Turkey for working visit  

15:35 • 19/10

Turkish violin virtuoso plays Komitas to commemorate Ara Guler (video)

15:07 • 19/10

eBay revenues up to take on Auto Trader in car ads

15:03 • 19/10

Azerbaijan rescues Iranian sailors 'poisoned by chemicals'

14:38 • 19/10

October 24 marks National Assembly's latest date to elect prime minister  

13:46 • 19/10

Facebook sued over video viewing figures

13:02 • 19/10

Russian animators producing screen version of Saroyan’s 'The Summer of Beautiful White Horse'

12:07 • 19/10

Park dedicated to 2,800th jubilee of Yerevan to open in spring  

11:42 • 19/10

Customs beagle sniffs out pig head in luggage

11:30 • 19/10

Republican Party’s Executive Board discusses electoral reform

11:15 • 19/10

Jenna Bush Hager convinced the White House is haunted

10:43 • 19/10

Forthcoming elections will be the most important in the history of modern Armenia, says international expert

10:16 • 19/10

US-led coalition strikes civilian homes in Deir ez-Zor 

10:11 • 19/10

Apple announces iPad Pro and Mac event for October 30

09:38 • 19/10

Mexico sends police to southern border

09:15 • 19/10

ISIS take 700 hostages including US and European nationals and will 'execute 10 people a day', Putin says

18:04 • 18/10

UK minister steps out of Saudi summit

17:52 • 18/10

Hamilton says chasing Schumacher's record was never the plan

17:33 • 18/10

Republican politician 'confident' about party's future success

17:02 • 18/10

100-year-old woman in wheelchair gets married to 74-year-old man 

16:46 • 18/10

ECHR fines Armenia over procedural violations in March 1, 2008 criminal cases

16:04 • 18/10

Washington Post publishes Saudi journalist's final column

15:22 • 18/10

Kocharyan vows to create political party after 'comeback'

12:22 • 18/10

ADB to offer $50m worth budgetary assistance to Armenia

12:06 • 18/10

168 Zham: EU and Russia have different political expectations from Armenia

11:10 • 18/10

Hraparak: Koharyan stepping aside

09:52 • 18/10

Elon Musk ‘planning to buy’ $20 million of Tesla stock

09:22 • 18/10

Venezuela arrests military officers over Maduor assassination attempt

09:12 • 18/10

World-renowned Turkish-Armenian photographer Ara Guler passes away

09:02 • 18/10

Norway issues apologies to WW2 'German girls'

17:54 • 17/10

Google unshackles Android-device firms

17:06 • 17/10

Ariana Grande takes social media break

16:36 • 17/10

Armenia improves positions on Global Competitiveness Index

16:29 • 17/10

Huawei Mate 20 Pro launches with in-screen fingerprint sensor

16:09 • 17/10

Crimea terrorist attack: 13 killed, dozens injured in Kerch college explosion

15:34 • 17/10

Turkey closed border with Armenia for Azerbaijan, says former envoy

15:10 • 17/10

World stocks extend rise after blockbuster US earnings

14:37 • 17/10

Pashinyan introduces new acting minister of economic development and investments

14:09 • 17/10

Fabregas in Guinness World Records for reaching 100 PL assists

13:50 • 17/10

Turkey ‘hopes to enter Saudi consul's residence’ on Wednesday  

13:29 • 17/10

Chinese woman kills herself and two kids after husband fakes death

12:43 • 17/10

Armenia's position on Karabakh 'clearly enshrined' in government program – Foreign Ministry

12:15 • 17/10

Kourtney Kardashian jumps with joy as she ignores sister Kim’s most exciting comment

11:33 • 17/10

Hraparak: Anti-Armenian status for Karabakh 'unnegotiable'

11:01 • 17/10

Man who illegally crossed Armenia- Turkey border 'identified as ethnic Kurd'

10:48 • 17/10

Nations League: Armenia beat Macedonia 4-0

10:15 • 17/10

Kocharyan critical about plan to hold snap elections

09:42 • 17/10

Pashinyan tenders resignation to pave way to snap elections

09:32 • 17/10

At least 30 killed by hurricane Michael

09:12 • 17/10

Canada legalizes marijuana and cannabis

18:09 • 16/10

Thirty years in a metal container damaged by enemy firings

17:41 • 16/10

Moody’s assigns B1 rating to Inecobank

17:26 • 16/10

Russian expert slams Moscow’s weapons trading with Azerbaijan  

16:59 • 16/10

All Ucom TV Subscribers to Enjoy 4 Most Demanded TV-Series’ Channels

16:29 • 16/10

ARF-D not 'not planning to nominate' prime ministerial candidate

15:57 • 16/10

Outgoing US ambassador to Armenia speaks of 'occupied terrritories' surrounding Karabakh

15:34 • 16/10

Google pulls out of Saudi investor conference

14:49 • 16/10

Turkey gets representation in IMF executive directorate

14:44 • 16/10

Bulgaria not to join Eurovision 2019 Song Contest

13:23 • 16/10

Armenian president signs decrees to appoint new cabinet ministers

13:03 • 16/10

Armenian arm wrestling athlete named world champion in Turkey

12:40 • 16/10

Armenia: Three new regional governors appointed

12:04 • 16/10

2018 marked period of unique democratic reforms in Armenia, Zohrab Mnatsakanyan says at EaP ministerial summit

11:08 • 16/10

Mike Pompeo to meet Saudi Arabia's king

10:47 • 16/10

CSTO Parliamentary Assembly 'to conduct session in Moscow' instead of Yerevan

10:09 • 16/10

Hraparak: European institutions 'against' early elections in Armenia

09:44 • 16/10

Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen dies at 65

09:31 • 16/10

Australia to recognize Jerusalem as Israeli capital by moving embassy from Tel-Aviv

09:13 • 16/10

Facebook to ban misinformation on voting in upcoming US elections

18:18 • 15/10

New sports minister pledges 'systemic reforms'

17:45 • 15/10

Beatles’ ‘Sgt. Pepper’ named top album in UK

15:36 • 15/10

Trump called for plan to remove all US diplomats from Turkey in frustration over detention of American pastor

15:12 • 15/10

Bloodhound 1,000mph car goes into administration

14:29 • 15/10

Pashinyan 'not to tender resignation' on Oct. 15, press secretary confirms

13:33 • 15/10

Aznavour family shocked by mocking cartoon portraying late singer

13:08 • 15/10

Rouhani accuses US of seeking “regime change” in Iran

13:02 • 15/10

Alec Baldwin urges ‘overthrow’ of Trump government via voting

12:54 • 15/10

Russian border guards apprehend trespasser on Armenia-Turkey border

12:41 • 15/10

Harry and Meghan announce they are expecting their first child together next spring

11:29 • 15/10

1 dead, 1 unjured after shots fired outside Banquet Hall in Glendale

11:19 • 15/10

Plane crashes into crowd in Germany, several people killed

10:43 • 15/10

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle arrive in Sydney for 16-day tour

10:20 • 15/10

Magnitude 2.5 earthquake strikes Armenia’s south

09:47 • 15/10

Oil prices rise as Saudi Arabia vows to hit back against sanctions

09:17 • 15/10

Trump: Climate change scientists have agenda

15:29 • 13/10

We must rule out theft from Yerevan city funds – Nikol Pashinyan

14:32 • 13/10

Armenian president ‘conducted trip to Moscow recently’, Russian paper claims

13:50 • 13/10

New mayor of Yerevan sworn into office

12:49 • 13/10

Pashinyan hails positively developing Armenian-Canadian relations

11:44 • 13/10

Donald Trump hails American pastor Brunson’s release by Turkey

11:10 • 13/10

Amy Winehouse's father reveals late singer is to return to the stage as a hologram

10:53 • 13/10

Late US President Ronald Reagan 'comes back to life' in a $1.5Million 3D hologram exhibit

10:30 • 13/10

US pastor at center of spat leaves Turkey after release

10:07 • 13/10

Canadian prime minister pays respect to Armenian Genocide victims (photos)

09:30 • 13/10

Hurricane Michael ‘like mother of all bombs’

09:12 • 13/10

Saudi Arabia calls journalist's murder claims lies

18:15 • 12/10

Zohrab Mnatsakanyan: Armenia is committed to francophone values