Armenia’s Velvet Revolution takes Azerbaijan out of comfort zone –Chatham House  

11:00 • 01.06.18

By Laurence Broers

Associate Fellow, Russia and Eurasia Programme


Armenia’s new prime minister, Nikol Pashinyan, sensibly avoided foreign policy issues during his protest campaign. As his new government takes office, this will be a harder balancing act, nowhere more so than with the part-foreign, part-domestic issue of Karabakh. He is right to be wary: in the 1990s the conflict in Karabakh was the undoing of several leaders on both sides of the divide.

Recent history has seen surges of public euphoria on both sides. Azerbaijan’s army, in the ‘four-day war’ of 2–5 April 2016, reclaimed occupied territory for the first time since 1994. Armenia’s Velvet Revolution has fired up Armenians to believe that anything is possible. But expectations need to be tempered.

Credibility and institutional memory

Pashinyan has a number of short-term challenges. National security has traditionally been seen as the liberal opposition’s Achilles’ heel in Armenia. This explains his prioritization of a visit – his first ‘international’ trip as leader – to the disputed territory on his first day as prime minister on 9 May.

Just as important as buffing up security credentials is managing handover. Since the late 1990s the Armenian-Azerbaijani talks have narrowed to a tight huddle involving only presidents and foreign ministers. Without teams of negotiators, envoys or backchannels, a large amount of highly sensitive institutional memory is concentrated in just a few individuals. When these change, the process is vulnerable. 

Baku is likely to want to move quickly, perhaps with a view to resetting parameters before Pashinyan’s team have had time to cover their brief. The current peace proposal, known as the Madrid Principles, has already been updated a number of times. When, as a former senior negotiator puts it, the negotiations are not about substance but ‘which document should be the basis of our talks’, institutional memory is a crucial resource. Yerevan is consequently likely to want to take its time.   


The end of the 'Karabakh clan'?

Armenia’s Velvet Revolution also takes Azerbaijan out of its comfort zone. This is because for the first time in 20 years, Armenia has a leader who is not a native of Karabakh.


The idea that Armenia has been chafing under the rule of a hardline faction from Karabakh has been a mainstay of Azerbaijani analysis for two decades. The “Karabakh clan” entered the analytical orthodoxy about the conflict after former Karabakh Armenian leader Robert Kocharian became Armenia’s president in 1998.


The idea lived on in references to former president Serzh Sargsyan as the ‘last of the Mohicans’: the last member of a ruling elite born in the crucible of the Karabakh war. Sargsyan’s resignation was hailed by the Azerbaijani Ministry of Foreign Affairs, who announced on 24 April that they were looking forward to negotiating with “sensible political forces”.

The “Karabakh clan” is an attractive notion when looking for easy answers to the impasse of the last 20 years. Remove the clan, so this thinking goes, and unblock the negotiations. Tempting as this may sound, it is wishful thinking.  

Karabakh Armenians, living near the frontline, have unsurprisingly always held more hardline views against territorial concessions as part of a peace package. But Armenia has been catching up.

In the mid-2000s, around two-thirds of Armenia’s population was willing to consider the return of occupied territories as part of an overall deal. But after 2016’s four-day war that had dropped to less than 10 per cent in 2017. Rather than the last of the Mohicans, Baku confronts an attitude more akin to “we are all Mohicans now”. Public opinion on Karabakh has always mattered, even to authoritarian leaders. But it will even harder to ignore for a democratic leadership in Armenia.

Reconciling compliant and augmented Armenias

Pashinyan’s key long-term challenge is reconciling two different visions of Armenia that have vied with one another since independence.

The first is ‘compliant Armenia’, the internationally recognized state that seeks integration into the wider world and to fulfil the country’s early democratic promise. The other is the ‘augmented Armenia’ that grew out of the unification movement with Karabakh, and which includes not only Karabakh but also – as on almost any map you see in Armenia today – the territories occupied in 1992–94.    


Over the last 20 years, the formal politics of a compliant Armenia consistently conceded to the informal politics of augmented Armenia. The argument that only they could provide for the latter’s security embedded and protected a former veteran elite and their clients among Armenia’s oligarchs. Their claims to provide for augmented Armenia’s security were hit hard by the violence of April 2016. Today there is a significant opportunity to redefine the meaning of security in Armenia, from strongmen to strong institutions.

Strongmen have benefited – indeed encouraged – a narrow peace process that they can control. One step towards managing the contradictions between compliant and augmented Armenias would be for Karabakh Armenians to speak for themselves in the Minsk Group talks. This is hardly new: Armenians – and the Azerbaijani minority displaced from Karabakh in 1992 – participated in the talks as interested parties in the mid-1990s.

Baku – fearful of tacit recognition – bristles at any suggestion of dialogue with the de facto authorities in the disputed territory, just as the latter bristle at any suggestion of dialogue with Azerbaijanis displaced from the lands under their control. One may not be possible without the other.

Yet the inclusion of these voices in the negotiations is essential for Nikol Pashinyan, or any Armenian leader following him, to define the borders of the political community to whom they are ultimately accountable. And that, ultimately, is also in Azerbaijan’s interest.



LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:12 • 20/11

Turkey discusses Khashoggi murder with UN's Guterres

17:47 • 20/11

Intensively developing cooperation with Iran in Armenia’s interests – Nikol Pashinyan  

17:12 • 20/11

Martin Scorsese reunites with Robert De Niro, Leonardo DiCaprio, Harvey Keitel and Jonah Hill at Moma gala  

17:01 • 20/11

Real Madrid offer to sanction Juventus transfer for Navas

16:56 • 20/11

Wrong Google Map directions leave young woman stranded in Arizona desert 

16:46 • 20/11

PNG police officers attack parliament in APEC pay dispute

16:23 • 20/11

Ombudsman’s representatives visit soldiers in central military clinic

16:00 • 20/11

Belgium's King Philippe and Queen Mathilde host lavish state banquet for French President and wife 

15:48 • 20/11

106-year-old grandmother is beaten to death while sleeping inside her humble Brazilian home  

14:24 • 20/11

Post-revolutionary period boosted job creation in Armenia, says acting PM

13:12 • 20/11

New generation currency series to go into circulation on Nov. 22 (photos)

12:08 • 20/11

Pre-electoral processes ‘centered around one single person’ in Armenia  

11:15 • 20/11

Iran ‘will thrive’ despite US sanctions  

10:55 • 20/11

Apple suppliers suffer with uncertainty around iPhone demand

10:47 • 20/11

After Khashoggi murder, some Saudi royals ‘turn against’ king’s favorite son

10:38 • 20/11

Deadly explosion hits residential building in Azerbaijani town

10:30 • 20/11

Top Armenian national security official to attend CIS summit in Moscow

10:01 • 20/11

Armenian organizations in Western US call for generous contribution to All Armenian Fund

09:33 • 20/11

Chicago hospital shooting: 4 reported killed, including police officer

09:17 • 20/11

Saudi crown prince ‘to attend G20 summit’ in Argentina

17:53 • 19/11

Khashoggi murder: Saudi journalist ‘was forced’ to send message to son

17:39 • 19/11

New wasteland development project ‘under implementation’ in Yerevan

17:07 • 19/11

Amazing simulation gives viewers virtual tour of the violent black hole at the centre of galaxy

16:26 • 19/11

Increase in tax burden ‘ruled out’ without public consent

15:45 • 19/11

Amber Heard leaves little to imagination in glittering mini dress with very risqué cut-out at Aquaman photocall in Beijing

15:31 • 19/11

Hollywood confirms Ghostbusters 3 project ‘is on the way’

15:20 • 19/11

Wenger: Managers will be robots and social media will make decisions

14:50 • 19/11

Pashinyan calls for organizing proper waste management in Armenia 'after clearing off political garbage’

14:36 • 19/11

Ucom lowers prices for Samsung smartphones

13:49 • 19/11

Acting minister of agriculture to attend EEU forum in Moscow

13:31 • 19/11

Poe Francis lunches with the poor (photos)

13:23 • 19/11

Turkish FM to Mike Pompeo in Washington

12:06 • 19/11

Armenia's central bank to launch new generation currency bills

11:17 • 19/11

The Prophets, Angels, & Churches of ‘Armenia!’ – New York Times review

10:35 • 19/11

Toll in California wildfire rises to 80

10:27 • 19/11

Mexican drug leader Hector Beltran Leyva dead at 56

10:14 • 19/11

France's Macron urges Europe to ban ‘global chaos’

10:04 • 19/11

Baku to protest Artsakh leader’s visit to Washington  

09:42 • 19/11

Turkish, Russian leaders to attend TurkStream sea portion completion ceremony

09:36 • 19/11

Migrant crisis: Mexican city protest thousands-strong caravan’s arrival

09:13 • 19/11

Israeli PM Netanyahu names himself defense minister to ‘rule out politics’ from security

14:51 • 17/11

China takes aim at US protectionism  

14:05 • 17/11

Security of people should not be isolated from right to territorial integrity, says Nagorno-Karabakh official

12:57 • 17/11

Colorado doctors wrongly remove healthy patient’s kidneys

12:37 • 17/11

Israel heading for early elections  

12:24 • 17/11

Mars InSight coming in for landing soon on the Red Planet

11:58 • 17/11

Missing Argentine submarine found deep in the Atlantic a year after its disappearance  

11:52 • 17/11

Trump questions Mike Pence’s loyalty despite recent endorsement

11:34 • 17/11

Sasna Tsrer party conducting automobile race to Artsakh

11:07 • 17/11

California wildfires: 71 reported killed.  more than 1,000 still missing

10:54 • 17/11

Nations League: Armenia beat Gibraltar 6-2 (videos)  

10:26 • 17/11

Saudi crown prince suspected of ordering Jamal Khashoggi’s assassination

18:30 • 16/11

UN to fund human security enhancement projects in Armenia  

17:30 • 16/11

Pashinyan holds telephone conversation with Russian leader

17:23 • 16/11

Lewis Hamilton: India could have built more schools instead of hosting Formula 1

16:59 • 16/11

Zohrab Mnatsakanyan: CSTO secretary general’s post should be entrusted to Armenia

16:21 • 16/11

National Assembly reforms aim to foster legislators' constitutional authority and functions, says parliamnent official

15:51 • 16/11

Monica Lewinsky reveals she exposed her thong to get Bill Clinton's attention before their first White House hook-up

15:03 • 16/11

Armenian ombudsman presents report on military aggression against border villages

14:09 • 16/11

Turkey, EU step up dialogue for meetings

13:27 • 16/11

US studying Turkey’s demands to extradite Gülen  

13:18 • 16/11

2020 Toyota Corolla hybrid to debut at LA auto show

12:09 • 16/11

Emergency Ministry warns of heavy-going motorways in Armenia

11:49 • 16/11

Apple signs deal with Oscar-winning production company to make original movies  

11:29 • 16/11

Russian intervention in Karabakh conflict will be inevitable in case of Azerbaijani threats to Armenia, says expert

10:42 • 16/11

New tests can predict IVF embryos’ risk of having low IQ

10:21 • 16/11

Botswana named Africa’s best Safari country 2018

10:04 • 16/11

US-led coalition strikes kill two dozen Syrian civilians

09:52 • 16/11

Khmer Rouge leaders found guilty of genocide

09:36 • 16/11

ServiceTitan, start-up co-founded by US-Armenians, secures $165m in venture funding

09:21 • 16/11

US optimistic about prosecuting Assange

17:42 • 15/11

Armenian defense delegation conducts official visit to Bulgaria

17:23 • 15/11

Florida election recount nears deadline as Trump stirs pot with baseless claim

17:11 • 15/11

Pound Sterling crashes amid Brexit reports

16:55 • 15/11

Turkey seeks extradition of 452 people in 83 countries for FETÖ cases

16:43 • 15/11

Khashoggi case: Saudi prosecutor seeks death penalty for journalist’s murder

16:24 • 15/11

Artsakh's international recognition 'key foreign policy priority', says foreign minister

15:38 • 15/11

Ancient city of Tenea uncovered in Greece

14:48 • 15/11

Gazprom-Armenia director slams attempts to spot company’s ‘good image’

14:06 • 15/11

Wimbledon finalist retires from tennis at 29

14:00 • 15/11

Dostoevsky novel among hundreds of book banned in Kuwait

13:52 • 15/11

California fire town needs ‘total rebuild’

13:40 • 15/11

'He's a Duchy Original!' Buckingham Palace celebrates Prince Charles’ 70 birthday  

13:28 • 15/11

Brexit: EU Barnier warns of 'long road ahead'

13:07 • 15/11

Armenian cabinet considers procedures for open-door meetings

11:40 • 15/11

168 Zham: Europe ‘closely following’ developments in pre-electoral Armenia

11:05 • 15/11

Turkey calls for international probe into Khashoggi murder

10:44 • 15/11

Ardshinbank named winner of Eikon Award 2018 by Thomson Reuters

10:35 • 15/11

Archaeologists unearth small warrior statues found from 2100-year-old pit in China

09:59 • 15/11

Aznavour son to release post-humus album dedicated to singer

09:43 • 15/11

Trump aide forced out of office after showdown with first lady

09:13 • 15/11

Toxic year: Oxford dictionaries name word of 2018

17:58 • 14/11

Hollywood Red Carpet cancelled after wildfires

17:47 • 14/11

Apple designers unveil dazzling one-of-a-kind ring 'cut entirely out of one single diamond'

17:24 • 14/11

Israel's defense chief resigns, slamming Netanyahu for 'surrendering to Hamas terror'

17:01 • 14/11

Armenia’s acting social and labor minister steps down ‘to join parliamentary campaign’

16:21 • 14/11

Parliamentary election 2018: Pro-Pashinyan bloc unveils candidates' list

15:55 • 14/11

Russian-Armenian military alliance ‘powerful restraint’ against Turkish-Azerbaijani aggression

15:31 • 14/11

Georgia to facilitate imports to Armenia

14:49 • 14/11

Prince Charles' 70th birthday marked with family photo release