Why Turkey’s human rights violations won’t end up in court – Washinton Post

16:00 • 12.06.18



By Filiz Kahraman


Turkey recently called snap elections to be held June 24, even as it extended the state of emergency for a seventh time since a failed coup attempt in 2016. And in the wake of a 2017 constitutional referendum that vested extraordinary powers in President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, observers warn that Turkey is on the fast track to authoritarianism.

While not part of the European Union, Turkey is member of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). The court retains the force of law over contracting states and has previously ruled on contentious issues from prisoners’ right to vote to the treatment of terrorism suspects in custody. However, since the coup attempt, it rejected several applications regarding systemic human rights abuses and the undemocratic process in the 2017 Turkish referendum. Why the change?


Research on the court illustrates how avoiding this political crisis could affect the future of democracy and protection of human rights in Turkey and beyond.


Why the April 2017 referendum results were contested


International observers and domestic opposition groups raised serious concerns about the April 2017 referendum. Erdogan, running up against term limits, introduced a system in which he could serve three consecutive five-year terms. The result was an unparalleled presidential system, granting sweeping executive powers over the parliament and judiciary. The Venice Commission of the Council of Europe observed that the amendments represent “a dangerous step backwards in the constitutional democratic tradition of Turkey.”

The vote itself raised several red flags. The referendum was conducted under the state of emergency. Many journalists and members of parliament were jailed in the weeks before the vote, and the media increasingly controlled by Erdogan gave little voice to the remaining opposition. And, on the day of the referendum, the election board lifted a requirement that the ballot envelopes be double-stamped. The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe pointed out that this curious last-minute decision “undermined an important safeguard against fraud” and concluded that the referendum took place on an “unlevel playing field.”

The small margin (51 percent) by which the “yes” vote won further raised suspicions about the possible impact of the unstamped votes. Soon after the elections, the main opposition party, the Republican People’s Party cried foul.

 

Why the court rejected Turkey’s referendum case

The ECtHR’s convention refers to member states’ obligations to “hold free elections at reasonable intervals.” The court, however, contrived to dismiss the case: A referendum, it contended, is a different matter than an election.


The court’s reasoning is consistent with its previous case law, including a recent ruling regarding a Scottish independence referendum. The judges turned down the opportunity to reconsider their stance on referendums, despite other organizations’ questioning the Turkish referendum’s legitimacy.


In June’s snap elections, Turkish voters will again be casting their ballots during a state of emergency. A leading presidential candidate, Selahattin Demirtaş, is in jail. Unstamped envelopes will still be accepted as valid.

 

A changing approach to human rights violations in Turkey

The referendum is not the only Turkish claim on which the court has passed. Since the July 2016 coup attempt, 150,000 public service workers have been banned from their jobs by executive decrees. Under pressure from the Council of Europe, Turkey created an ad hoc commission that began to review applications related to the state of emergency in July 2017. The ECtHR dismissed the applications regarding the purges and directed them to the ad hoc commission. The special commission, however, is directly under executive control and is unlikely to adjudicate impartially. Legal scholars estimate that it may take as many as 10 years for an applicant to exhaust domestic remedies — a requirement before seeking justice at the ECtHR.

 

The ECtHR has not always been reticent in the face of systemic human rights violations. Throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, the court adjudicated on thousands of grave human rights violations committed against the Kurdish population in southeast Turkey, including forced disappearances and village burnings.


In a landmark 1996 case, the court lifted the exhaustion of domestic remedies requirement in light of the state’s condoning of or complicity in the crimes committed against the applicants. Had it applied the same logic to the post-coup-attempt cases, tens of thousands of cases could have been tried.


Why might the ECtHR be avoiding hot issues?

Recent research shows that the ECtHR’s retrenchment on Turkey is part of a larger trend. The court is less inclined to hold states responsible for new forms of human rights violations for two important reasons.


First, the court’s case law has grown exponentially in the past few decades. To reduce its caseload, the ECtHR has undergone several structural changes and encouraged states to address systemic violations themselves. However, the number of cases from Turkey repeatedly ranked one of the highest and Turkey remained a top violator. In 2016, cases from Turkey ranked second-highest, accounting for 16 percent of the court’s docket, with some 12,600 cases.


The court’s efforts to manage its docket may be coming at the expense of human rights. Reports by the European Union, Council of Europe institutions and international human rights organizations indicate that human rights violations have been occurring at an alarming rate during the state of emergency, that elections are not taking place in a democratic environment and that the recent purges and reforms have undermined judicial independence. Any presumption that human rights issues may be adjudicated in Turkey by independent tribunals within a reasonable time clearly contradicts these reports.

Second, the ECtHR is under mounting political pressure. Alongside outright noncompliance and public outcries from increasingly authoritarian countries such as Turkey, Russia and Hungary, the ECtHR has been under fire by liberal democracies as well. The United Kingdom, in particular, has been an avid critic of the court, with threats to leave it altogether. The court started to receive negative coverage in the British mediaand threats from politicians in response to the 2005 ruling on prisoners’ right to vote. And, indeed, the ECtHR is now showing more deference to liberal democracies, especially Britain, to appease backlash against its decisions. Its response to the recent case law from Turkey indicates that threats by authoritarian and populist leaders may have a similar effect on the court.


With the rise of right-wing populism across Europe, such changes in the court could undermine the international human rights system built in the aftermath of World War II. Refusing to adjudicate can carry as much weight as a ruling itself.

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:22 • 23/10

Converse Bank opens “Malatya” branch in Yerevan

17:53 • 23/10

US Dollar 'toxic currency' in Armenian-Russian trade turnover

17:16 • 23/10

Armenian fashion designer presents Genocide-themed collection in Moscow

16:36 • 23/10

Ucom Launches uFleet, innovative solution for car fleet management

15:29 • 23/10

National Assembly to hold fresh debates over electoral reforms

15:11 • 23/10

Mystery of the massive mile wide 'monolith' iceberg: NASA spots strange rectangular berg in Antarctica

15:01 • 23/10

Trump vows to send as many troops to the border ‘as necessary’ to stop caravan

14:52 • 23/10

Erdogan reveals details of Saudi Khashoggi's murder

14:39 • 23/10

YELQ lawmakers endorse Pashinyan for PM

14:25 • 23/10

Domestic political changes in Armenia ‘no impediment to EEU’  

14:16 • 23/10

Azerbaijani FM ‘silent’ over CSTO membership plan

13:52 • 23/10

Armenia re-establishes role of leading IT manufacturer

13:45 • 23/10

Dyson chooses Singapore for new electric car plant

13:13 • 23/10

Eleven refugees and at-risk youth receive Aurora Gratitude Scholarships to study at United World Colleges

12:57 • 23/10

168 Zham: Dushanbe meeting paves way to future progress over Karabakh

12:34 • 23/10

CIA director Haspel travels to Turkey for Khashoggi case

12:16 • 23/10

Hraparak: Armenian authorities mull cabinet optimization plan

11:58 • 23/10

Khashoggi murder a ‘monstrosity’, no arms exports to Riyadh until incident cleared up, says Germany’s Merkel

11:32 • 23/10

Armenian official blames Azerbaijan over stalemate in Karabakh peace talks

11:09 • 23/10

Ardshinbank and the Black Sea Trade and Development bank sign USD15m loan agreement

09:55 • 23/10

Explosive found in mailbox at George Soros’s Westchester county home

09:33 • 23/10

Mexico issues warning over 'extremely dangerous' storm

09:17 • 23/10

Trump calls Khashoggi's death 'a plot gone awry'

22:03 • 22/10

Ucom Management in Ucom Service Centers

17:53 • 22/10

Zohrab Mnatsakanyan hosts OSCE official to discuss regional developments

16:55 • 22/10

Bradley Cooper and Irina Shayk brave a chilly day in Manhattan with little girl Lea to the park

16:37 • 22/10

Electoral reforms key effort towards ruling out 'monolith parliament'

16:01 • 22/10

US scrapping INF to make world more dangerous, force Russia to ‘restore balance’

15:37 • 22/10

World's longest sea-crossing bridge opens to connect Hong Kong and China

15:27 • 22/10

ARF-D to run for parliament ‘as opposition party’

14:56 • 22/10

OSCE to assist in effective anti-corruption investigations in Armenia

14:10 • 22/10

Caravan of migrants swells to 7,000 and stretches more than a mile long as they continue marching towards the US border

13:33 • 22/10

Khashoggi 'given police protection' in Turkey

13:25 • 22/10

Budapest 2018: Armenian wrestler celebrates victory in opening match

13:05 • 22/10

Actor Selma Blair reveals she has multiple sclerosis

12:56 • 22/10

Syria describes US-led coalition’s actions as genocide

12:46 • 22/10

Armenian parliament vice speaker conducts working trip to St Petersburg

12:17 • 22/10

Catholicos Garegin II in Italy for working visit

11:30 • 22/10

Stephen Hawking’s wheelchair, thesis for sale

11:13 • 22/10

Saudi official provides another version of Khashoggi death

10:33 • 22/10

New chief architect of Yerevan appointed

09:47 • 22/10

Trump, Erdogan discuss Saudi journalist's murder in phone call

09:42 • 22/10

Gorbachev warns of Trump nuclear treaty plan

09:12 • 22/10

Egypt extends emergency for three months  

15:05 • 20/10

Nikol Pashinyan in Lebanon for two-day working visit  

14:44 • 20/10

Armenian writer wins Golden Knight literary award in Russia

14:22 • 20/10

Bako Sahakyan congratulates Catholicos Aram I on 50th anniversary of ordination

13:40 • 20/10

Doctors pluck 11 live worms from a five-month-old's eyeball

11:18 • 20/10

Macedonia votes to start name change process

10:41 • 20/10

Trump advisor Rudy Giuliani 'planning trip to Armenia'

09:19 • 20/10

Afghanistan holds parliamentary election amid threats of violence

09:10 • 20/10

Khashoggi case: Saudi TV says missin g journalist 'died after fight'

18:12 • 19/10

Kocharyan lawyers to file appeal with European court

17:10 • 19/10

No prison overcrowding in Armenia, says acting minister

16:21 • 19/10

Australian family's terror as bull shark jumps into tinny during fishing trip

16:07 • 19/10

Aliyev travels to Turkey for working visit  

15:35 • 19/10

Turkish violin virtuoso plays Komitas to commemorate Ara Guler (video)

15:07 • 19/10

eBay revenues up to take on Auto Trader in car ads

15:03 • 19/10

Azerbaijan rescues Iranian sailors 'poisoned by chemicals'

14:38 • 19/10

October 24 marks National Assembly's latest date to elect prime minister  

13:46 • 19/10

Facebook sued over video viewing figures

13:02 • 19/10

Russian animators producing screen version of Saroyan’s 'The Summer of Beautiful White Horse'

12:07 • 19/10

Park dedicated to 2,800th jubilee of Yerevan to open in spring  

11:42 • 19/10

Customs beagle sniffs out pig head in luggage

11:30 • 19/10

Republican Party’s Executive Board discusses electoral reform

11:15 • 19/10

Jenna Bush Hager convinced the White House is haunted

10:43 • 19/10

Forthcoming elections will be the most important in the history of modern Armenia, says international expert

10:16 • 19/10

US-led coalition strikes civilian homes in Deir ez-Zor 

10:11 • 19/10

Apple announces iPad Pro and Mac event for October 30

09:38 • 19/10

Mexico sends police to southern border

09:15 • 19/10

ISIS take 700 hostages including US and European nationals and will 'execute 10 people a day', Putin says

18:04 • 18/10

UK minister steps out of Saudi summit

17:52 • 18/10

Hamilton says chasing Schumacher's record was never the plan

17:33 • 18/10

Republican politician 'confident' about party's future success

17:02 • 18/10

100-year-old woman in wheelchair gets married to 74-year-old man 

16:46 • 18/10

ECHR fines Armenia over procedural violations in March 1, 2008 criminal cases

16:04 • 18/10

Washington Post publishes Saudi journalist's final column

15:22 • 18/10

Kocharyan vows to create political party after 'comeback'

12:22 • 18/10

ADB to offer $50m worth budgetary assistance to Armenia

12:06 • 18/10

168 Zham: EU and Russia have different political expectations from Armenia

11:10 • 18/10

Hraparak: Koharyan stepping aside

09:52 • 18/10

Elon Musk ‘planning to buy’ $20 million of Tesla stock

09:22 • 18/10

Venezuela arrests military officers over Maduor assassination attempt

09:12 • 18/10

World-renowned Turkish-Armenian photographer Ara Guler passes away

09:02 • 18/10

Norway issues apologies to WW2 'German girls'

17:54 • 17/10

Google unshackles Android-device firms

17:06 • 17/10

Ariana Grande takes social media break

16:36 • 17/10

Armenia improves positions on Global Competitiveness Index

16:29 • 17/10

Huawei Mate 20 Pro launches with in-screen fingerprint sensor

16:09 • 17/10

Crimea terrorist attack: 13 killed, dozens injured in Kerch college explosion

15:34 • 17/10

Turkey closed border with Armenia for Azerbaijan, says former envoy

15:10 • 17/10

World stocks extend rise after blockbuster US earnings

14:37 • 17/10

Pashinyan introduces new acting minister of economic development and investments

14:09 • 17/10

Fabregas in Guinness World Records for reaching 100 PL assists

13:50 • 17/10

Turkey ‘hopes to enter Saudi consul's residence’ on Wednesday  

13:29 • 17/10

Chinese woman kills herself and two kids after husband fakes death

12:43 • 17/10

Armenia's position on Karabakh 'clearly enshrined' in government program – Foreign Ministry

12:15 • 17/10

Kourtney Kardashian jumps with joy as she ignores sister Kim’s most exciting comment

11:33 • 17/10

Hraparak: Anti-Armenian status for Karabakh 'unnegotiable'

11:01 • 17/10

Man who illegally crossed Armenia- Turkey border 'identified as ethnic Kurd'