Resolution as a contribution to reconciliation between Turks and Armenians - Tessa Hofmann (Part II)

15:37 • 10.06.16



Continued

 

Presently, there are a lot of discussions about possible problems between Turkey and Germany. The Turkish authorities are now very aggressive. They also recalled their  ambassador from Germany. What kind of process do you think we should expect from Turkey? Will that be a real problem in the Turkish-German relations?


Already two days after the issuance it becomes obvious that very soon we shall be back to routine business with Turkey. As the Chancellor mentioned, German-Turkish relations are too numerous and complex (to be disturbed by a resolution on memory and history politics). Recalling ambassadors has also become a routine in the history of now 26 recognitions by national legislators, and as a rule the diplomatic representatives are very soon back to their offices. As you know, the head of government, i.e. the Chancellor, her deputy Gabriel and the FO Minister Steinmeier were absent during the debate and voting. This was certainly done with the intention to indirectly help Erdoğan to preserve his reputation as Turkey’s strongman. As a sign of undeclared gratitude Turkey’s new PM has already announced that the EU-Turkey agreement on refugees will not be damaged by the resolution – and this risk of damage has certainly Angela Merkel’s biggest concern.


The German Bundestag admits its share of responsibility for the Armenian Genocide. Can we such an admission serve as grounds for asking compensation from Germany too?


Already in the 2005 resolution the Bundestag has acknowledged the involvement of Imperial Germany for the ‘massacres’ and ‘expulsion’ of the Ottoman Armenians. Please do not overestimate such concessions, for they are constructs that help Germany to comment on the historical guilt of another country. The German legislators then and today found themselves in the difficult situation that it would not be convincing if Germany blames Turkey for genocide, whereas during the 20th century Germany was twice the only author of serial genocides: in Namibia against the Herero, Nama and other indigenous people during 1904-1908 (albeit the first genocide of the 20th century) and during WW2 against European Jews and the Sinti/Roma people. Therefore the German lawmakers already in 2005 decided to emphasize German involvement in the WW1 genocide against the Armenians and other indigenous Christians of Asia Minor and Mesopotamia and by this way to remind Turkey that it is necessary for countries and societies with genocidal pasts to pro-actively address this past. If you wish, the mention of German involvement constitutes a tactical approach for officially commemorating the Armenian genocide. In its official response to a parliamentary enquiry by an oppositional Socialist fraction, the Federal Government declared in 2011 that it recoils from the term ‘genocide’ as long as juridical cases on Armenian compensation claims against German banks   are pending in the USA.


As you are certainly also aware, such cases are ongoing since more than ten years.


In the given context we have also to determine what precisely would be a German co-responsibility for the Armenian genocide? Ottoman Turkey was a sovereign state, and the ruling war regime of Ittihatist nationalists did not need German inspiration to commit genocide. Since the mid-1960s, scholars of history agree that under the given circumstances and political morals of the period, the German pursuit of national interests was not extraordinary. The view of these scholars – and in my view also – the responsibility lies in the fact that the German government, despite all its firsthand knowledge on the scope and the speed of the destruction of Ottoman Christians stayed more or less indolent, for fear of risking a relevant military alliance. In addition, the (meanwhile bankrupt) German firm Philipp Holzmann, which has been charged with the construction of the Baghdad railways, benefited from Armenian slave labor in 1915/6. Thirdly, Armenians and other Ottoman Christians had immense deposits at German and other foreign banks. Where heirs of the murdered Christians remained, these deposits are the subject of the above mentioned court cases in the USA and other countries. A parliamentary resolution may be helpful, but is not mandatory for such legal proceedings.


As far as the current parliamentary resolution is concerned, the financial commitment will be in the field of historical research, genocide awareness education and cross-community projects that serve reconciliation.

 

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:53 • 18/12

Law banning right-handed cars not to have retroactive effect

17:17 • 18/12

Armenian gets private island in Russia’s Far East

16:45 • 18/12

Fitch revises Armenia's outlook to positive, affirming at 'B+'

16:29 • 18/12

Yerevan State University rector 'takes neutral stand' on student protests

15:49 • 18/12

Inter Milan set their sights on Mkhitaryan as they eye a January move

15:26 • 18/12

NATO official reiterates support territorial integrity, self-determination

14:39 • 18/12

Armenian student activists 'renewing hunger-strike' to demand army deferment

13:57 • 18/12

Turkey to complete wall along Syria border by spring

13:32 • 18/12

BBC to make Weinstein documentary

13:16 • 18/12

Armenia to increase natural gas imports from Iran

12:32 • 18/12

Cooperation agreement with EU offers Armenia additional guarantees over Karabakh – MP

11:16 • 18/12

French-Armenoian cartoonist famed as author of top magazines' cover page images

10:30 • 18/12

Elderly couple in Ireland plans marriage to avoid inheritance tax

10:13 • 18/12

Palestine protesters set Mike Pencer pictures on fire

10:06 • 18/12

Toyota to make over 10 battery EV models globally in early 2020s

09:59 • 18/12

Bitcoin trading starts on the huge CME exchange

09:54 • 18/12

Macron appeals to French exceptionalism as 40th birthday looms

09:30 • 18/12

Lebanon launches probe into UK embassy employee’s death

09:13 • 18/12

Cause of Canada billionaire suspicious death revealed

15:19 • 16/12

Ankara persistently links Turkey-Armenia process to Nagorno-Karabakh – Foreign Ministry

14:39 • 16/12

Luxury 200ft super yacht with its own helipad is modelled on a 17th century pirate ship (photos)

14:24 • 16/12

US to return stolen relics to Lebanon

14:14 • 16/12

Armenian biker wins silver in intn'l tournament

13:53 • 16/12

Canada billionaire and wife found dead in New York home

13:41 • 16/12

Armenian endorsed for US Congress

13:21 • 16/12

Nagorno-Karabakh reports 200 Azerbaijani ceasefire violations

13:12 • 16/12

US citizens and illegal aliens charged in marriage fraud ring

12:51 • 16/12

Zhoghovurd: Armenia to ban right-handed cars

11:44 • 16/12

Israel needs more time and effort to recognize Genocide – former member of Knesset

10:13 • 16/12

Bitcoin tops US$18,000 in debut on major bourse

09:51 • 16/12

Sky News faces uncertain future after Disney-Fox deal

09:33 • 16/12

US ready for military solution to N Korea conflict

18:38 • 15/12

Three twins born in Yerevan medical center

17:22 • 15/12

Armenian stone to be used for building Google HQ in London

17:12 • 15/12

EU leaders agree to move talks to next stage

17:06 • 15/12

Sumatran rhino 'hanging on by thread'

16:50 • 15/12

Free economic zone opens in Armenia's Syunik

16:04 • 15/12

'Organic Agricultural Development' program names 2017-2018 winners

15:51 • 15/12

Cribby: Armenian software developers unveil smart cradle (photos)

14:21 • 15/12

Trump's Jerusalem move may pave way to Genocide recognition – diplomat

13:54 • 15/12

French bus cut in two in deadly rail crash

13:44 • 15/12

Visiting cultural sites important for preserving Armenian heritage in Turkey – expert

12:35 • 15/12

Armenia's NATO envoy submits credentials to Stoltenberg

12:12 • 15/12

Armenian president rules out EEU exit plan

11:45 • 15/12

Berlin should resolve problems with Ankara – says Merkel aide  

11:18 • 15/12

Zhamanak: Russian border guards close frontier posts on Armenia-Turkey border

11:07 • 15/12

First Wildlife Rescue Center opens in Armenia

10:51 • 15/12

Ardshinbank signs $25m trade finance facility agreement with Citi and ADB  

10:36 • 15/12

EU-Armenia agreement marks victory of sound logic – Serzh Sargsyan

09:13 • 15/12

Dubai opens $10 million camel hospital

18:02 • 14/12

Football news: Man Utd's Bailly may need anke surgery

17:44 • 14/12

Nalbandian hosts European Friends of Armenia director

17:27 • 14/12

Walt Disney buys Murdoch's Fox for $52.4bn  

17:09 • 14/12

British man has fingers and thumb replaced with his toes after horrific accident with industrial food blender

17:00 • 14/12

Reconciliation with Turkey was mistake, says Israeli politician

16:17 • 14/12

Armenia continues cooperation with Greek, Cypriot Diasporas

15:18 • 14/12

Putin: Trump’s Russia scandal harms US

14:46 • 14/12

Baby girl survives with heart outside her body at birth in UK  

14:36 • 14/12

Surgeon carves initials on the livers of two transplant patients in first assault case

14:18 • 14/12

Turkey-Armenia protocols ‘dead’ in essence – expert

13:30 • 14/12

Armenian opposition bloc names presidential candidate

13:04 • 14/12

Man jumps off huge waterfall in the Grand Canyon to honour deceased friend

12:54 • 14/12

Dwayne Johnson receives star on Hollywood Walk of Fame

12:40 • 14/12

‘Ambitious anti-corruption strategy’ requires new monitoring methods – premier

12:22 • 14/12

Netenyahu ‘not impressed’ by Muslim leaders’ statement on recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital

12:09 • 14/12

Record high 262 journalists imprisoned in 2017 - CPJ

11:52 • 14/12

US citizen wanted in Armenia over terror plot - National Security Service

10:56 • 14/12

Aznavour: I hope to be on stage until I am 100

10:14 • 14/12

Glendale City Council approves framework featuring Armenian American Museum

09:54 • 14/12

US Federal Reserve raises interest rates

09:35 • 14/12

Plane crashes in Canada; all passengers ‘accounted for’

09:14 • 14/12

Rohingya crisis: Thousands reported killed in months 

18:57 • 13/12

2017 marked serious progress in Armenia-NATO relations – debate

18:04 • 13/12

Amal and George Clooney 'hand out personalised headphones and notes' to fellow plane passengers on flight with twins

17:34 • 13/12

FBI agent removed from Russia investigation calls Trump an 'idiot'

17:08 • 13/12

Opposition MP says political team 'considers alternative candidate' for prime minister

16:19 • 13/12

European Central Bank could use Steinhoff mess to improve QE

16:01 • 13/12

Princes William and Harry inspect  Star Wars troops in London premiere

15:46 • 13/12

Palestinians will not accept any US role in peace process 'from now on', says Mahmoud Abbas

15:29 • 13/12

Erdogan calls on Jerusalem to be recognized as Palestinian capital 

15:15 • 13/12

No challenges to NATO-Armenia relations - liason officer

14:20 • 13/12

Australian Greens recognize Nagorno-Karabakh Republic

13:14 • 13/12

US ready for North Korea talks, says Tillerson

13:07 • 13/12

6.2 quake hits south-eastern Iran

12:52 • 13/12

Armenian parliament passes anti-domestic violence law

12:34 • 13/12

Fossil hunters find bones of human-sized penguin on New Zealand beach

12:22 • 13/12

Nalbandian: Azerbaijan's disrespect for peace over Karabakh questions their credibility in negotiations  

11:57 • 13/12

Disney set to seal $60bn 21st Century Fox takeover

11:44 • 13/12

Armenia free to develop balanced dialogue with EU and Russia –  European expert

09:35 • 13/12

US Democrat wins seat in Alabama in blow to Trump

09:12 • 13/12

Hamas announces beginning of third 'Intifada' against US decision on Jerusalem

18:06 • 12/12

Armenian biker to join international race in Portugal

17:51 • 12/12

Terrifying footage shows newlywed bride attacked by shark during Caribbean honeymoon swim

17:40 • 12/12

France proposes ban for mobile phones in schools from September

17:16 • 12/12

European court orders Azerbaijan to pay €35,000 in compensation to displaced Armenian family  

16:31 • 12/12

Musician who lost arm can play piano again with 'insanely cool prosthetic' (video)

16:06 • 12/12

Armenia can build EEU’s bridge with Europe in case of securing safe hub for businesses – French Ambassador  

15:12 • 12/12

Canadian lawmaker speaks of April war in Artsakh in parliament address (video)

14:33 • 12/12

Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson and Lauren Hashian can't hide delight as she debuts blossoming baby bump at Jumanji 2 premiere in LA... hours after revealing pregnancy news

14:24 • 12/12

Private arrested over reported fatality in Nagorno-Karabakh army