Resolution as a contribution to reconciliation between Turks and Armenians - Tessa Hofmann (Part II)

15:37 • 10.06.16



Continued

 

Presently, there are a lot of discussions about possible problems between Turkey and Germany. The Turkish authorities are now very aggressive. They also recalled their  ambassador from Germany. What kind of process do you think we should expect from Turkey? Will that be a real problem in the Turkish-German relations?


Already two days after the issuance it becomes obvious that very soon we shall be back to routine business with Turkey. As the Chancellor mentioned, German-Turkish relations are too numerous and complex (to be disturbed by a resolution on memory and history politics). Recalling ambassadors has also become a routine in the history of now 26 recognitions by national legislators, and as a rule the diplomatic representatives are very soon back to their offices. As you know, the head of government, i.e. the Chancellor, her deputy Gabriel and the FO Minister Steinmeier were absent during the debate and voting. This was certainly done with the intention to indirectly help Erdoğan to preserve his reputation as Turkey’s strongman. As a sign of undeclared gratitude Turkey’s new PM has already announced that the EU-Turkey agreement on refugees will not be damaged by the resolution – and this risk of damage has certainly Angela Merkel’s biggest concern.


The German Bundestag admits its share of responsibility for the Armenian Genocide. Can we such an admission serve as grounds for asking compensation from Germany too?


Already in the 2005 resolution the Bundestag has acknowledged the involvement of Imperial Germany for the ‘massacres’ and ‘expulsion’ of the Ottoman Armenians. Please do not overestimate such concessions, for they are constructs that help Germany to comment on the historical guilt of another country. The German legislators then and today found themselves in the difficult situation that it would not be convincing if Germany blames Turkey for genocide, whereas during the 20th century Germany was twice the only author of serial genocides: in Namibia against the Herero, Nama and other indigenous people during 1904-1908 (albeit the first genocide of the 20th century) and during WW2 against European Jews and the Sinti/Roma people. Therefore the German lawmakers already in 2005 decided to emphasize German involvement in the WW1 genocide against the Armenians and other indigenous Christians of Asia Minor and Mesopotamia and by this way to remind Turkey that it is necessary for countries and societies with genocidal pasts to pro-actively address this past. If you wish, the mention of German involvement constitutes a tactical approach for officially commemorating the Armenian genocide. In its official response to a parliamentary enquiry by an oppositional Socialist fraction, the Federal Government declared in 2011 that it recoils from the term ‘genocide’ as long as juridical cases on Armenian compensation claims against German banks   are pending in the USA.


As you are certainly also aware, such cases are ongoing since more than ten years.


In the given context we have also to determine what precisely would be a German co-responsibility for the Armenian genocide? Ottoman Turkey was a sovereign state, and the ruling war regime of Ittihatist nationalists did not need German inspiration to commit genocide. Since the mid-1960s, scholars of history agree that under the given circumstances and political morals of the period, the German pursuit of national interests was not extraordinary. The view of these scholars – and in my view also – the responsibility lies in the fact that the German government, despite all its firsthand knowledge on the scope and the speed of the destruction of Ottoman Christians stayed more or less indolent, for fear of risking a relevant military alliance. In addition, the (meanwhile bankrupt) German firm Philipp Holzmann, which has been charged with the construction of the Baghdad railways, benefited from Armenian slave labor in 1915/6. Thirdly, Armenians and other Ottoman Christians had immense deposits at German and other foreign banks. Where heirs of the murdered Christians remained, these deposits are the subject of the above mentioned court cases in the USA and other countries. A parliamentary resolution may be helpful, but is not mandatory for such legal proceedings.


As far as the current parliamentary resolution is concerned, the financial commitment will be in the field of historical research, genocide awareness education and cross-community projects that serve reconciliation.

 

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

09:42 • 18/01

Nagorno-Karabakh reports more Azerbaijani ceasefire violations

09:24 • 18/01

Microsoft patent reveals foldable phone that turns into a tablet

09:06 • 18/01

Dink murder was deliberately permitted, says former intelligence chief

08:46 • 18/01

Chevrolet reveals life-sized version of the Batmobile for upcoming movie

08:29 • 18/01

Wikileaks scandal: Obama commutes Manning sentence

08:14 • 18/01

European Parliament elects new president

19:52 • 17/01

No doubts will remain only after Armenia-EU agreement actually signed - Stepan Grigoryan

18:49 • 17/01

Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg due in court over VR 'heist'

18:07 • 17/01

Gene Cernan, last man to walk on Moon, dies aged 82

17:46 • 17/01

Violence against media reps: Armenian lawyer raises problem of impunity

17:04 • 17/01

Armenia’s Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression announces 2016 report

16:53 • 17/01

Serj Tankian: Garo Paylan is a true hero

16:30 • 17/01

Obamas leaving White House

16:11 • 17/01

Nagorno-Karabakh parliament backs constitutional referendum

15:50 • 17/01

Armenia’s premier, EBRD official discuss cooperation priorities

15:39 • 17/01

Tsarukyan vows political comeback

15:03 • 17/01

Massive gator spotted in Polk County

14:50 • 17/01

That really is awesome! Chevrolet reveals life-sized version of the Batmobile made of 340,000 LEGO bricks for upcoming movie

14:35 • 17/01

OSCE ‘concerned’ over Azerbaijan’s attempt to hamper mission’s extension in Yerevan

14:13 • 17/01

'Wrong Ivanka' from UK hits back after Trump tweet

13:51 • 17/01

Sergeant’s wrongful use of weapon left private wounded in Nagorno-Karabakh

13:43 • 17/01

British American Tobacco takes control of Reynolds for $49bn

13:12 • 17/01

Turkish-Armenian MP to face lawsuit over controversial remark

13:11 • 17/01

Armenian scientists capable of accomplishing most serious tasks – Samvel Harutyunyan

12:36 • 17/01

Swiss Private University introduces virtual education in Europe

12:18 • 17/01

Armenian parliamentary delegation to conduct meetings in Israel

11:34 • 17/01

Ex-Man Utd manager retires

10:45 • 17/01

Armenian prime minister to start official trip to Moscow

10:35 • 17/01

Davos 2017: Trump, China and Brexit set to dominate agenda

10:25 • 17/01

Eugene Cernan, the last astronaut to walk on moon, dies

10:07 • 17/01

Haykakan Zhamanak: Armenian government’s expectation great for Russian investments

09:40 • 17/01

Nagorno-Karabakh serviceman wounded in gunfire

09:15 • 17/01

Iran minister says “era of expensive oil” has come

09:04 • 17/01

Swiss watchmaker debuts watch made of Swiss Cheese

08:46 • 17/01

Orlando nightclub gunman’s wife held

08:30 • 17/01

Brexit: UK’s may rejects EU membership

08:18 • 17/01

Turkish police arrest Istanbul club attack suspect

20:04 • 16/01

Theresa May follows Kardashian's lead as she lands American Vogue shoot

19:18 • 16/01

Divided European Parliament prepares to elect new president

18:54 • 16/01

Chinese Super League limits foreign players 

18:32 • 16/01

40,000 engineering jobs until 2025 – Armenian PM briefed on IT development plan

17:55 • 16/01

CSTO Secretariat addresses skirmishes on Armenian-Azerbaijani border

16:44 • 16/01

Iraqi forces push into Mosul in clashes with IS

16:26 • 16/01

NATO worried by Trump’s ‘obsolete’ comment

16:14 • 16/01

Ratings ‘all-time low’ for Sherlock finale

16:02 • 16/01

Armenia’s premier target of both certain pro-government and opposition forces – Armen Badalyan

15:24 • 16/01

Russian envoy’s killer buried in cemetery of nameless in Turkish capital

15:18 • 16/01

Nagorno-Karabakh contract serviceman reported dead

15:13 • 16/01

Ethereal photos capture famous landmarks around the world after the snow has driven tourists away

15:08 • 16/01

Armenia’s justice minister holds meetings in France

15:00 • 16/01

Intn’l actors increase tension over Karabakh instead of reaching peace – Russian expert

14:40 • 16/01

Eurasian Union needs time to be accomplished structure – Russian expert

13:44 • 16/01

‘Armath’ engineering lab students offer more interesting and innovative technological solutions

13:24 • 16/01

Closure of OSCE office in Yerevan not end of the world – Armenian expert

13:13 • 16/01

Kim Kardashian is her old self again as she sits astride a buggy and poses with a falcon on Dubai modelling shoot

12:45 • 16/01

Interesting period to follow April elections - expert

11:12 • 16/01

Beijing will 'take off the gloves', if Trump continues on Taiwan

10:47 • 16/01

Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations, Armenian side retaliates

10:28 • 16/01

Wounded Armenian soldier dies in hospital

09:54 • 16/01

S Korea corruption: Prosecutors to seek arrest warrant

09:31 • 16/01

Facebook to roll out fake news tools in Germany

08:52 • 16/01

Eight billionaires 'as rich as world's poorest half'

08:29 • 16/01

Turkish Airlines cargo plane crashes into Kyrgyzstan homes

15:48 • 15/01

Vote buying not to influence results of Armenia parliamentary elections – sociologist

15:21 • 15/01

Icredible pictures of city-dweller-turned shepherd

14:42 • 15/01

Armenia parliamentary elections: serious political stake expected

14:27 • 15/01

Lufthansa says no evidence of bomb on board Eurowings plane landed in Kuwait

13:30 • 15/01

Ringling Bros circus to close 'Greatest Show on Earth' after 146 years

13:11 • 15/01

Import substitution is impossible in Armenia-like country – economist

12:50 • 15/01

Bahrain executes three Shia men over 2014 police killing

12:25 • 15/01

9 ISIL militants 'neutralized' in northern Syria

11:27 • 15/01

Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations

10:50 • 15/01

Brazil prisoners beheaded in riot at Natal prison

10:33 • 15/01

Israel-Palestinian conflict: France holds world summit

17:51 • 14/01

Fifty Shades of Grey may be turned into a musical (video)

17:31 • 14/01

SpaceX rocket set to return to flight

17:15 • 14/01

Fruitless talks necessitate ‘divorce’ – Armenian politician on Nagorno-Karabakh

16:33 • 14/01

Criminal mindset responsible for genocide, not Turkish people

16:20 • 14/01

Johnny Depp and Amber Heard finalise divorce

16:03 • 14/01

Nagorno-Karabakh never seriously discussed in expert circles – analyst  

15:42 • 14/01

Serena Williams reveals her excitement to plan wedding to fiancé Alexis Ohanian

15:26 • 14/01

OSCE/ODIHR hails electoral reforms in Armenia

15:04 • 14/01

We need to make Gyumri more business-friendly city – prime minister  

14:35 • 14/01

Air raid targeting IS militant kills up to 30 in Iraqi city

14:27 • 14/01

Mkhitaryan offers insight into Liverpool clash

14:13 • 14/01

Jackson daughter 'incredibly offended' by new TV movie's portrayal of her father

14:02 • 14/01

Turkey remands foreigners over Istanbul attack

13:53 • 14/01

Armenian politician considers cooperation plans ahead of election

13:33 • 14/01

Fire erupts at Germany embassy in Yerevan

13:22 • 14/01

Garo Paylan speaks of Armenian Genocide in Turkish Parliament

13:08 • 14/01

Zhamanak: Armenia’s defense minister most favored candidate for future PM  

12:36 • 14/01

Trump open to lifting Russian sanctions if 'we get along'

12:17 • 14/01

Azerbaijan shoots grenade fire on Karabakh frontline

19:32 • 13/01

Cyprus talks: Erdogan dismisses full Turkish troop withdrawal

19:02 • 13/01

Germany invites Russian minister on EU sanctions list to G20 meeting

18:25 • 13/01

Extraordinary images show 'light pillars' dancing above houses after sunshine and snow combine to create rare effect

18:00 • 13/01

‘Any violence simply postpones NK conflict settlement’ - Richard Hoagland

17:15 • 13/01

Atheist man shocked to discover Jesus in Ikea bathroom door

17:04 • 13/01

Numerous reasons for poor 2016 budget performance – premier

16:40 • 13/01

Turkey offers citizenship to foreign property buyers