Resolution as a contribution to reconciliation between Turks and Armenians - Tessa Hofmann (Part II)

15:37 • 10.06.16



Continued

 

Presently, there are a lot of discussions about possible problems between Turkey and Germany. The Turkish authorities are now very aggressive. They also recalled their  ambassador from Germany. What kind of process do you think we should expect from Turkey? Will that be a real problem in the Turkish-German relations?


Already two days after the issuance it becomes obvious that very soon we shall be back to routine business with Turkey. As the Chancellor mentioned, German-Turkish relations are too numerous and complex (to be disturbed by a resolution on memory and history politics). Recalling ambassadors has also become a routine in the history of now 26 recognitions by national legislators, and as a rule the diplomatic representatives are very soon back to their offices. As you know, the head of government, i.e. the Chancellor, her deputy Gabriel and the FO Minister Steinmeier were absent during the debate and voting. This was certainly done with the intention to indirectly help Erdoğan to preserve his reputation as Turkey’s strongman. As a sign of undeclared gratitude Turkey’s new PM has already announced that the EU-Turkey agreement on refugees will not be damaged by the resolution – and this risk of damage has certainly Angela Merkel’s biggest concern.


The German Bundestag admits its share of responsibility for the Armenian Genocide. Can we such an admission serve as grounds for asking compensation from Germany too?


Already in the 2005 resolution the Bundestag has acknowledged the involvement of Imperial Germany for the ‘massacres’ and ‘expulsion’ of the Ottoman Armenians. Please do not overestimate such concessions, for they are constructs that help Germany to comment on the historical guilt of another country. The German legislators then and today found themselves in the difficult situation that it would not be convincing if Germany blames Turkey for genocide, whereas during the 20th century Germany was twice the only author of serial genocides: in Namibia against the Herero, Nama and other indigenous people during 1904-1908 (albeit the first genocide of the 20th century) and during WW2 against European Jews and the Sinti/Roma people. Therefore the German lawmakers already in 2005 decided to emphasize German involvement in the WW1 genocide against the Armenians and other indigenous Christians of Asia Minor and Mesopotamia and by this way to remind Turkey that it is necessary for countries and societies with genocidal pasts to pro-actively address this past. If you wish, the mention of German involvement constitutes a tactical approach for officially commemorating the Armenian genocide. In its official response to a parliamentary enquiry by an oppositional Socialist fraction, the Federal Government declared in 2011 that it recoils from the term ‘genocide’ as long as juridical cases on Armenian compensation claims against German banks   are pending in the USA.


As you are certainly also aware, such cases are ongoing since more than ten years.


In the given context we have also to determine what precisely would be a German co-responsibility for the Armenian genocide? Ottoman Turkey was a sovereign state, and the ruling war regime of Ittihatist nationalists did not need German inspiration to commit genocide. Since the mid-1960s, scholars of history agree that under the given circumstances and political morals of the period, the German pursuit of national interests was not extraordinary. The view of these scholars – and in my view also – the responsibility lies in the fact that the German government, despite all its firsthand knowledge on the scope and the speed of the destruction of Ottoman Christians stayed more or less indolent, for fear of risking a relevant military alliance. In addition, the (meanwhile bankrupt) German firm Philipp Holzmann, which has been charged with the construction of the Baghdad railways, benefited from Armenian slave labor in 1915/6. Thirdly, Armenians and other Ottoman Christians had immense deposits at German and other foreign banks. Where heirs of the murdered Christians remained, these deposits are the subject of the above mentioned court cases in the USA and other countries. A parliamentary resolution may be helpful, but is not mandatory for such legal proceedings.


As far as the current parliamentary resolution is concerned, the financial commitment will be in the field of historical research, genocide awareness education and cross-community projects that serve reconciliation.

 

 





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

14:33 • 20/02

Trump baffles Sweden with crime comment, says it was based on TV report

14:20 • 20/02

Constitutional reforms aimed to guarantee Nagorno-Karabakh's development – Bako Sahakyan

13:39 • 20/02

Jolie opens up for first time about break up with Pitt as she premieres movie in Cambodia  

13:23 • 20/02

Belgian delegates visit Nagorno-Karabakh parliament

12:43 • 20/02

'Hitler's personal telephone' auctioned off for £195,000

12:33 • 20/02

New Constitution to improve Nagorno-Karabakh’s preparedness to meet challenges – Ashot Ghulyan

12:21 • 20/02

Two mgn 5.3 earthquakes rock Turkey

12:00 • 20/02

Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations

11:41 • 20/02

Nagorno-Karabakh president extends congratulations on Artsakh Revival Day

11:30 • 20/02

Zaruhi Postanjyan leaves Heritage party

11:12 • 20/02

'Moonlight', 'Arrival' writers win top Writers Guild of America awards

11:01 • 20/02

Armenia parliamentary elections: Transparency International anti-corruption center expects hundreds of observers

10:21 • 20/02

Constitutional referendum starts in Nagorno-Karabakh

09:33 • 20/02

Ice-locked ship to drift over North Pole

09:20 • 20/02

East Ukraine ceasefire due to take effect

08:59 • 20/02

SpaceX successfully launches rocket after Saturday setback

08:46 • 20/02

North Korea Kim Jong-nam killing: Malaysia recalls Pyongyang envoy

15:22 • 19/02

Calls for peace through mutual concessions sound strange – Artak Zakaryan

14:04 • 19/02

Price rise has nothing in common with forthcoming elections in Armenia – activist

13:53 • 19/02

Vehicle crashes into restaurant, 11 wounded in Turkey’s Bursa

12:49 • 19/02

Atom Egoyan named Companion of the Order of Canada

12:17 • 19/02

California 'bombogenesis' storm pushes north

11:40 • 19/02

Malaysia searching for four more North Korean suspects in Kim Jong Nam death

11:12 • 19/02

Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations

10:42 • 19/02

Former Wallaby Daniel Vickerman dies aged 37 leaving behind a wife and two children

10:08 • 19/02

Iraq announces offensive against IS in western Mosul

18:32 • 18/02

Minsk Group de-facto recognizes Karabakh – Russian expert

17:54 • 18/02

China to suspend all imports from North Korea

17:34 • 18/02

Armenia at the threshold of serious transformations  – Serzh Sargsyan

17:23 • 18/02

Salmonella 'can kill cancer', scientists find

17:08 • 18/02

Russia wants pragmatic relations with US, says foreign minister

16:49 • 18/02

Armenian, Bahraini FMs agree on closer cooperation  

16:14 • 18/02

Neil Gaiman announces Neverwhere sequel

16:00 • 18/02

Scientists discover key gene that stops Parkinson’s disease

15:43 • 18/02

Armenian private fatally wounded in Nagorno-Karabakh

15:36 • 18/02

Mourinho not to throw away FA cup

15:20 • 18/02

Armenian FM meets with OSCE chief in Munich

15:03 • 18/02

Zhoghovurd: Minister of culture to urge support for Republican Party?

14:46 • 18/02

Hitler’s phone to be auctioned in US

14:36 • 18/02

Founding editor of HyeTert dies in Turkey

14:19 • 18/02

Armenia sends more humanitarian aid to Syria

13:49 • 18/02

US pledges support to NATO, Europe

13:41 • 18/02

2.8 mgn quake strikes Aremnia’s north-east

13:25 • 18/02

Pictures that really did make splash: The mesmerising winners of the Underwater Photographer of the Year awards revealed

13:17 • 18/02

Iranian FM slams Trump’s executive order

13:06 • 18/02

Nagorno-Karabakh reports more Azerbaijani ceasefire violations

12:52 • 18/02

Ex Armenian minister’s son, relative detained over kidnapping, battery

12:15 • 18/02

Mexicans form 'human wall' along US border, protesting Trump

19:57 • 17/02

Republican has most competitive team to run for election – parliament official

19:17 • 17/02

Genocide issue gaining urgency in Turkey – Armenian journalist

18:41 • 17/02

Armenian defense officials to attend Munich Security Conference

18:31 • 17/02

Samsung Galaxy S8 could use Sony batteries – CNET

18:20 • 17/02

LA-bound Armenian Christians held up in Iran as travel ban effects linger - KPCC

18:09 • 17/02

Genocide recognition should not be key priority for Armenia - expert

17:58 • 17/02

Emotional attitude to Armenian Cause in Turkey – scholar

17:40 • 17/02

N Sync to reunite later in 2017

17:23 • 17/02

Genocide reparation should be key effort in nationwide campaign – French-Armenian lawyer

16:16 • 17/02

Best way to face up to history is to speak about it – French ambassador to Armenia

15:58 • 17/02

90 observers to monitor referendum in Nagorno-Karabakh – CEC chairperson

15:23 • 17/02

OSCE conducts monitoring on Armenian-Azerbaijani border

14:58 • 17/02

Security priority for Ohanyan-Hovannisian-Oskanian bloc

14:47 • 17/02

Armenian private reported killed of gas poisoning in Nagorno-Karabakh

14:26 • 17/02

New parliament to have more professional team – lawmaker

14:00 • 17/02

Khloe Kardashian ends transformation of Brittany McCalipp due to lack of progress on E!

13:39 • 17/02

Mediators affirm that constitutional referendum is part of state building process in Nagorno-Karabakh - official

12:49 • 17/02

Zero tolerance for terrorism everywhere, Turkish FM says in Cologne

12:38 • 17/02

CEC presents information on voter registration devices (updated)

12:18 • 17/02

Donald Trump’s pick for top adviser turns down job

11:54 • 17/02

Haykakan Zhamanak: Foreboding of war in Armenia, Artsakh

11:30 • 17/02

Zhoghovurd: Heritage party leader 11th on list

10:57 • 17/02

Azerbaijan continues ceasefire violations

10:35 • 17/02

Armenian authorities’ decision to return Azerbaijani serviceman’s body humanitarian gesture - OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs

10:24 • 17/02

Federal Constitutional Court of Germany rules Armenian Genocide resolution constitutional

09:21 • 17/02

Zuckerberg: my Facebook manifesto to re-boot globalisation

09:04 • 17/02

Samsung heir Lee Jae-yong arrested in South Korea

19:48 • 16/02

Armenia’s ruling party releases list of candidates in 2017 parliamentary elections

19:27 • 16/02

Microsoft bumps up Surface prices in UK

19:01 • 16/02

Putin says Russian, U.S. intelligence agencies should restore ties

18:31 • 16/02

Pavement lights guide 'smartphone zombies'

18:18 • 16/02

Armenia 33rd in 2017 Index of Economic Freedom

17:24 • 16/02

Armenian clergymen visit Christian regions liberated from ISIS

17:17 • 16/02

Austria to sue Airbus over Eurofighter contract

17:00 • 16/02

World Cup 2018: Fifa president Gianni Infantino 'not concerned' about hooligan threat at Russia World Cup

16:45 • 16/02

Churchill's views on aliens revealed in lost essay

16:35 • 16/02

Karabakh not sole foreign policy concern for Russia – expert

16:16 • 16/02

George Clooney 'excited but nervous' about having twins

15:56 • 16/02

Mercedes-Maybach unveils G650 Landaulet, ultra luxury limited edition off roader

15:53 • 16/02

The 'Airport Jacket' that has enough pockets to hold 15kg of items

15:42 • 16/02

Most of Nagorno-Karabakh population for presidential government – Aharon Adibekyan

15:20 • 16/02

Football: Arsenal manager’s decision at the end of season

15:03 • 16/02

OSCE has mission to promote democracy – Armenian analyst

14:27 • 16/02

Election 2017: Armenian Renaissance leader unveils candidates’ list

14:23 • 16/02

Political scientist on ‘rebranding’ of Armenia’s ruling party

14:04 • 16/02

West influences electoral processes in Armenia – analyst

13:48 • 16/02

Kanye West debuts Yeezy Season 5 collection with Adidas

13:36 • 16/02

ICRC reps visit Azerbaijani soldier in Nagorno-Karabakh

13:11 • 16/02

KitKat maker Nestle misses forecasts as profit falls

12:56 • 16/02

Government embarks on Clean Armenia project

12:48 • 16/02

Catholic Church paid A$276m to abuse victims in Australia

12:23 • 16/02

Turkish-Armenian photographer to open 2017 Nuremberg festival