Torture returns to Turkey – The Economist

11:28 • 09.09.17



The crackdown gets brutal


The masked special-ops officers barged into their apartment in Diyarbakir, in Turkey’s south-east, in the dead of a December night, says Tulay Yer-Celik. For the next two hours Mrs Yer-Celik, her month-old son and her mother-in-law listened as the agents beat her husband, Omer, in the next room. The violence ended only when the police arrived. Mr Celik, a journalist for the pro-Kurdish Dicle Haber Agency, one of over 150 news outlets shut down since last year’s bloody, abortive coup, was detained in Diyarbakir for two weeks. He was then transferred to a maximum-security prison near Istanbul, where he remains. His crime, according to an indictment that appeared only in late June, was to have published news stories based on the hacked e-mails of Turkey’s energy minister. He faces a sentence of 16 years.


Turkey’s government, led by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, proclaimed a policy of “zero tolerance” for torture in the early 2000s. But amid the fallout from last year’s coup and a continuing crackdown against Kurdish militants, tolerance is back. Human-rights groups have cited instances of beatings and torture, including rape and threats of rape, in Turkish detention centres. A UN official who visited Turkey late last year called such abuse “widespread”.


Human Rights Watch, a pressure group, has urged the government to investigate the kidnappings of four people accused of links to the Gulen movement, an Islamist sect believed to have inspired the coup. (The men are among the 110,000 civil servants purged from their jobs since last summer). One of the four resurfaced in police custody after six weeks. He has since accused security personnel of torturing him. Turkish officials rebuff questions about such cases. “There is no torture in detention centres,” says one.


Similar outrages have come to light in the country’s south-east, where at least 3,000 people have died in clashes between the army and Kurdish militants, and in a string of terrorist attacks, in the past two years. On August 5th security forces responded to the killing of a policeman near Sapatan, a Kurdish village, by forcing dozens of residents out of their homes and beating them in the local square. Of the 36 people detained, many were assaulted with hoses and metal rods at the local police station, according to Kurdish politicians who visited the area days later.


A police officer was later suspended, but investigations into such abuses remain rare. Officials involved in counter-terrorism operations were granted immunity from prosecution last year. Berat Albayrak, the energy minister and the president’s son-in-law, remarked last week that he was tempted to strangle Gulenists whenever he saw them. Only a few years ago, the ruling Justice and Development party could plausibly claim to have done away with torture, notes Andrew Gardner of Amnesty International. “Since 2015 this success has been turned on its head,” he says.


The international response to all this has been feeble. Nine months ago, following a fact-finding mission, the Council of Europe’s Committee for the Prevention of Torture gave Mr Erdogan’s government a detailed report on ill-treatment in Turkish prisons. Turkey has not allowed its findings to be made public. EU politicians, including Angela Merkel, have talked about cancelling accession talks with Turkey, but it has not happened.

 

Increasingly, the people who are trying to expose the abuses have themselves come under threat. Eight human-rights activists, including Amnesty International’s Turkey director and two European nationals, have been behind bars since July on outlandish conspiracy charges. Journalists face similar pressure. When photos of some of the Sapatan villagers appeared on social media, their backs covered with bruises, the local governor’s office insisted that the men had not been tortured. Reports to the contrary, it added, bore the mark of “terrorist propaganda”.





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:09 • 23/11

EU-Armenia agreement offers vast guarantees for state sovereignty  - opinion

16:16 • 23/11

Saudi elite facing torture by US mercenaries

16:04 • 23/11

Azerbaijani army captain found dead close to Armenia’s state border

15:46 • 23/11

NATO warns against escalations in Karabakh  

15:14 • 23/11

Turkey sends extradition demands for Gulen to US

15:08 • 23/11

Deal signed to return Rohingya to Muslims

15:02 • 23/11

We will hail Azerbaijan’s EEU accession if commitments respected - official

14:34 • 23/11

Kim Kardashian's new fragrance line sells out in 6 DAYS raking in $14 million

14:12 • 23/11

Coordinated approach to Karabakh key element in EU-Armenia agreement - analyst

13:24 • 23/11

Stunning 'Farewell to Saturn' mosaic created from Cassini's final views of the planet

12:48 • 23/11

Armenian premier orders specific steps to develop digital agenda

12:13 • 23/11

Putin, Rouhani and Erdogan discuss Syria in Sochi

12:00 • 23/11

George Avakian, jazz producer and scholar, dead at 98

11:37 • 23/11

Turkey, Azerbaijan still unlikely to accept Armenia’s plan to use regional rail link – Georgian expert

10:41 • 23/11

Zhoghovurd: EU, Armenia may call off partnership agreement

10:29 • 23/11

Samsung Electronics to launch AI research center

10:15 • 23/11

EU: Press Azerbaijan on Rights at Summit – Human Rights Watch

09:56 • 23/11

Zhamanak: EU-Armenia agreement not yet ratified by eight countries

09:37 • 23/11

Paris police use tear gas to combat education plan protest

09:23 • 23/11

Four killed in Georgia terror siege

18:02 • 22/11

House that takes 6 hours to build and costs just $33K

17:48 • 22/11

Boeing jets auctioned online for $48m

17:34 • 22/11

Britain's most notorious prisoner refused parole or chance to move to an open jail just days after wedding

17:23 • 22/11

Hot lips: Eyes and a smiling mouth spotted in Ethiopian volcano

17:11 • 22/11

Georgia says suspected militant captured in ongoing counterterrorism operation

16:53 • 22/11

Only Russia can resolve Karabakh conflict – Erdogan

16:21 • 22/11

US prosecutors charge Iranian in 'Game of Thrones' hack

15:59 • 22/11

3-year-old pays whopping $2.64M for car license plate in Abu Dhabi

15:51 • 22/11

US Navy plane crashes in Philippine Sea; 3 missing

15:47 • 22/11

Mladic jailed for life over Bosnia war genocide

15:34 • 22/11

Lebanon: Hariri says to hold off resignation as PM

15:21 • 22/11

No serious changes expected in Karabakh peace talks – political analyst

14:38 • 22/11

More details released in fatal incident at Artsakh military post

14:12 • 22/11

Mugabe successor due back to Zimbabwe from exile

13:22 • 22/11

Lavrov underlined parity principle with Armenia, Azerbaijan - analyst

12:33 • 22/11

Skype removed from China app stores

12:24 • 22/11

Sevilla coach reveals cancer during draw with Liverpool

12:11 • 22/11

Karabakh should be axiomatic priority in EaP Summit Declaration – Armenian parliamentarian

11:36 • 22/11

Uber paid hackers for massive data breach cover-up

11:30 • 22/11

Ivanka and Tiffany Trump join National Thanksgiving Turkey Presentation

11:20 • 22/11

Hariri back in Lebanon for first time since resignation

11:07 • 22/11

'Partridge Family' heartthrob David Cassidy dies at 77

10:56 • 22/11

Armenian youth actively joins European HIV-Hepatitis testing week

10:16 • 22/11

Turkey: Zaman journalist sentenced to 7.5 years in prison

10:01 • 22/11

Zhoghovurd: No technical obstacles to EU-Armenia agreement - Switalski

09:40 • 22/11

Three Armenian soldiers die in mine explosion in Nagorno-Karabakh

09:25 • 22/11

Zimbabwe celebrates end of Mugabe era

09:12 • 22/11

Trump, Putin hold hour-long phone call on foreign affairs

18:19 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s EEU integration impossible without Armenia’s consent – Russian analyst

17:16 • 21/11

Converse Bank launches special product for customers receiving foreign transfers

16:29 • 21/11

Armenia to receive 1.3m NATO assistance

15:47 • 21/11

UEFA release team of 21st century

15:40 • 21/11

US ending temporary permits for almost 60,000 Haitians

15:32 • 21/11

Barron Trump towers over Melania - aged just 11 - as the pair greet the official White House Christmas tree

15:19 • 21/11

Egyptian singer held for ‘suggestive video’

14:52 • 21/11

VEON Ltd conducts leadership meeting in Armenia  

14:40 • 21/11

Merkel hints fresh elections after coalition defeat

14:24 • 21/11

Kim Kardashian's pregnant surrogate shows off baby bump while running errands (photos)

14:10 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s statements run counter to practical steps – Nalbandian

13:40 • 21/11

Iran’s Rouhani declares end of Islamic State

13:15 • 21/11

All elements to resolve Karabakh conflict 'in place' – Sergey Lavrov

12:40 • 21/11

168 Zham: EU-Armenia agreement 'no threat to Russia and Eurasian Union' – analyst

12:13 • 21/11

NASA reveals bizarre shape of interstellar asteroid

11:50 • 21/11

Zhamanak: Lavrov gave Azerbaijan clear message on Karabakh, says Russian expert

10:45 • 21/11

US approves $75m sale of Javelin anti-tank missiles to Georgia

10:27 • 21/11

Azerbaijan’s EEU membership 'not acceptable now' - Armenian economist

10:03 • 21/11

Syria military operations nearing end; Putin and Assad meet in Sochi

09:43 • 21/11

Game of Thrones operator Mark Milsome dies in Ghana

09:28 • 21/11

Trump declares N Korea ‘sponsor of terror’

09:13 • 21/11

Zimbabwe crisis: Mugabe could lose presidency in days

17:51 • 20/11

Germany: Merkel suffers blow as coalition plan fails

17:38 • 20/11

Honest intentions key to future peace over Karabakh – Thomas Greminger

16:55 • 20/11

Iraqi Federal Court rules Kurdish referendum unconstitutional  

16:44 • 20/11

‘Visible steps’ to reach Karabakh breakthrough - Mammadyarov

16:27 • 20/11

Former Wimbledon champion Jana Novotna dies at 49

16:16 • 20/11

Germany bans smartwatches for kids

16:09 • 20/11

Atom Egoyan to be honored with Lifetime Achievement Award at IFFI 2017

15:37 • 20/11

Turkey-Armenia rapprochement 'left for different spring' – Taner Akcam

14:52 • 20/11

Armenia may be unaffected by Turkey-Russia thaw, says expert

14:20 • 20/11

Lavrov highlights progress in Karabakh peace  

13:59 • 20/11

Saakashvili tells Kiev protesters he is ready to become Ukraine's prime minister

13:49 • 20/11

Russia would hail Azerbaijan’s EEU accession – Lavrov

13:01 • 20/11

Gold leaf from Napoleon’s crown fetches $735,000 in Paris

12:55 • 20/11

US bans alcohol for troops in Japan

12:43 • 20/11

Amended referendum law to take effect after new President’s inauguration – CEC chairman

12:02 • 20/11

Selana Gomez unveils a sassy new style as she and pop princess Demi Lovato turn heads in bold black numbers at the American Music Awards

11:53 • 20/11

National Defense Research University ends intra-agency executive education pilot course

11:42 • 20/11

Turkey unaffected by EU's trim of funding

11:27 • 20/11

Armenian politician declares hunger-strike against 'anti-constitutional' order

11:03 • 20/11

Chales Manson whose followers killed 83 people dies at 83

10:46 • 20/11

Artsakh president starts working visit to France (photos)

10:17 • 20/11

Armenian Genocide monument raises Turks’ anger in Cologne  

09:51 • 20/11

German coalition plan fails after deadlock on migration, energy

09:42 • 20/11

FIDE Grand Prix 2017: Aronian wins Anish Giri  

09:27 • 20/11

Syria army liberates Abu Kamal from ISIS militants

09:08 • 20/11

Mugabe stuns Zimbabwe by defying pressure to resign

15:06 • 18/11

6.9 magnitude quake hits southern China

14:51 • 18/11

Iraqi forces recapture last Islamic State-held town

14:38 • 18/11

Conte to grow beard until Chelsea’s next defeat

14:28 • 18/11

NATO reiterates apology to Turkey over Ataturk, Erdogan reports