Torture returns to Turkey – The Economist

11:28 • 09.09.17



The crackdown gets brutal


The masked special-ops officers barged into their apartment in Diyarbakir, in Turkey’s south-east, in the dead of a December night, says Tulay Yer-Celik. For the next two hours Mrs Yer-Celik, her month-old son and her mother-in-law listened as the agents beat her husband, Omer, in the next room. The violence ended only when the police arrived. Mr Celik, a journalist for the pro-Kurdish Dicle Haber Agency, one of over 150 news outlets shut down since last year’s bloody, abortive coup, was detained in Diyarbakir for two weeks. He was then transferred to a maximum-security prison near Istanbul, where he remains. His crime, according to an indictment that appeared only in late June, was to have published news stories based on the hacked e-mails of Turkey’s energy minister. He faces a sentence of 16 years.


Turkey’s government, led by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, proclaimed a policy of “zero tolerance” for torture in the early 2000s. But amid the fallout from last year’s coup and a continuing crackdown against Kurdish militants, tolerance is back. Human-rights groups have cited instances of beatings and torture, including rape and threats of rape, in Turkish detention centres. A UN official who visited Turkey late last year called such abuse “widespread”.


Human Rights Watch, a pressure group, has urged the government to investigate the kidnappings of four people accused of links to the Gulen movement, an Islamist sect believed to have inspired the coup. (The men are among the 110,000 civil servants purged from their jobs since last summer). One of the four resurfaced in police custody after six weeks. He has since accused security personnel of torturing him. Turkish officials rebuff questions about such cases. “There is no torture in detention centres,” says one.


Similar outrages have come to light in the country’s south-east, where at least 3,000 people have died in clashes between the army and Kurdish militants, and in a string of terrorist attacks, in the past two years. On August 5th security forces responded to the killing of a policeman near Sapatan, a Kurdish village, by forcing dozens of residents out of their homes and beating them in the local square. Of the 36 people detained, many were assaulted with hoses and metal rods at the local police station, according to Kurdish politicians who visited the area days later.


A police officer was later suspended, but investigations into such abuses remain rare. Officials involved in counter-terrorism operations were granted immunity from prosecution last year. Berat Albayrak, the energy minister and the president’s son-in-law, remarked last week that he was tempted to strangle Gulenists whenever he saw them. Only a few years ago, the ruling Justice and Development party could plausibly claim to have done away with torture, notes Andrew Gardner of Amnesty International. “Since 2015 this success has been turned on its head,” he says.


The international response to all this has been feeble. Nine months ago, following a fact-finding mission, the Council of Europe’s Committee for the Prevention of Torture gave Mr Erdogan’s government a detailed report on ill-treatment in Turkish prisons. Turkey has not allowed its findings to be made public. EU politicians, including Angela Merkel, have talked about cancelling accession talks with Turkey, but it has not happened.

 

Increasingly, the people who are trying to expose the abuses have themselves come under threat. Eight human-rights activists, including Amnesty International’s Turkey director and two European nationals, have been behind bars since July on outlandish conspiracy charges. Journalists face similar pressure. When photos of some of the Sapatan villagers appeared on social media, their backs covered with bruises, the local governor’s office insisted that the men had not been tortured. Reports to the contrary, it added, bore the mark of “terrorist propaganda”.





LATEST NEWSAll Today news

14:55 • 23/09

Armenia, Nauru launch diplomatic relations  

14:31 • 23/09

PwC Armenia celebrates 10th anniversary

14:20 • 23/09

Nalbandian meets with ICG members in New York

13:49 • 23/09

Russian hackers targeted in 21 states over 2016 presidential race

13:12 • 23/09

Turkish, Iranian, Iraqi top soldiers to have talks over regional developments

12:42 • 23/09

Azerbaijan's 'Iron Dome plan' no threat to Iskander – Armenian expert

11:20 • 23/09

Azerbaijani anti-corruption activists given warning ahead of rally

10:58 • 23/09

Armenian FM discusses Karabakh peace with Minsk Group mediators

10:41 • 23/09

Armenia, Liberia ink deal to establish diplomatic relations

10:06 • 23/09

Azerbaijan blacklists three US lawmakers over visit to Nagorno-Karabakh

09:30 • 23/09

Miss Turkey stripped of crown over controversial tweet

09:15 • 23/09

Toll in Mexico quake rises to 295

18:14 • 22/09

Iran unveils new long-range ballistic missile

18:08 • 22/09

Philippines’ Duterte says son will be killed ‘if he is involved in drugs’

17:58 • 22/09

Eurozone sees burst of activity in third quarter

17:33 • 22/09

Confidence-building key to future progress in Karabakh peace - Ashotyan

17:03 • 22/09

Mississippi inmates break out of jail, rob a store and then break BACK in to sell their loot of cigarettes, lighters and phones

16:51 • 22/09

Bugatti might replace Chiron with a four-door with electric powertrain

16:32 • 22/09

EU seeks more active presence in Armenia – Piotr Switalski

15:52 • 22/09

Vatican celebrates Armenia’s independence, 25th anniversary of diplomatic relations  

14:52 • 22/09

Garo Paylan: We must open the path to dialogue on 1915 in Turkey

13:29 • 22/09

Spain reports new arrest in Barcelona attacks probe

13:21 • 22/09

How Azerbaijani laundromat has affected EU policy on Nagorno-Karabakh

13:08 • 22/09

Irates: Azerbaijan angered by developing Armenian-Israeli relations

12:47 • 22/09

Armenian PM calls for government efforts to boost agriculture

12:19 • 22/09

Armenian FM says statement on return of regions 'misinterpreted'

11:45 • 22/09

Trump, Erdogan reject Iraqi- Kurdish independence vote

10:17 • 22/09

White House denies Trump apologized to erdogan over Attack on DC protesters  

10:00 • 22/09

Tillerson thanks Armenia’s dedication to regional stability and international peacekeeping

09:50 • 22/09

Hurricane Maria 'leaves 15 dead’ in Dominca; 20 reported missing

09:24 • 22/09

Armenia-bound plane makes emergency landing in Russian town

13:58 • 21/09

Putin, Erdogan to discuss Syria peace plan next week

13:49 • 21/09

Chelsea, Man City face FIFA investigation over youth signing

13:35 • 21/09

Zhoghovurd: Government lavishes funds on Armenia-Diaspora conference

13:21 • 21/09

Justin Trudeau sports Chewbacca socks for meeting with IMF chief Christine Lagarde 

13:08 • 21/09

Brussels to offer help border regions

12:53 • 21/09

Game of Thrones' star to open up 'closed shop' film industry

12:41 • 21/09

The $147bn team photo: Warren Buffett takes to the stage with fellow billionaires and Diddy for Forbes' 100th birthday party

12:24 • 21/09

Putin congratulates Armenian president on independence anniversary

12:15 • 21/09

Apple concedes new smartwatch has connectivity glitch  

12:07 • 21/09

Turkey hosts NATO naval drills amid tensions

11:45 • 21/09

Artsakh war heroes remembered on independence anniversary

11:20 • 21/09

Iraqi Kurdistan referendum poses challenge for Turkey – Financial Times

10:44 • 21/09

September 21 carries invaluable message for Armenians - opinions

09:38 • 21/09

Flourishing and prosperous country is the dream of all Armenians – Bako Sahakyan

09:24 • 21/09

Mexico quake: Race to find survivors under collapsed school  

18:01 • 20/09

Azerbaijan imparting religious context to Karabakh conflict - official  

17:15 • 20/09

Barcelona condemn Spanish crackdown on Catalan independence vote

16:55 • 20/09

Serzh Sargsyan affirmed Armenia's position on Karabakh from UN podium – politician

16:13 • 20/09

US State Department tightens visa rules

16:05 • 20/09

‘Architects of Denial’ screening to open 2017 ANCA-WR grassroots conference

15:51 • 20/09

Porsche officially launches $16m hybrid yacht (ohotos)

15:30 • 20/09

Armenian president’s UN speech strong message to back Nagorno-Karabakh’s self-determination - official  

14:18 • 20/09

US congressmen strengthen solidarity with Artsakh during working visit to Shushi and Stepanakert

13:05 • 20/09

Armenian official blasts Azerbaijan over stalemate in Karabakh peace talks

12:10 • 20/09

Serzh Sargsyan says Armenia will be 'consistent in promoting UN goals'

11:55 • 20/09

British woman, 47, gives birth to healthy baby seven years after menopause

11:35 • 20/09

Azerbaijan Laundromat: Merkel ally 'received cash from regime' – The Guardian  

11:22 • 20/09

Armenian American orphans Christmas telethon strives to be most successful one yet – LA Times Jeff Landa

10:50 • 20/09

Nalbandian to meet with OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs in NYC

10:22 • 20/09

Nagorno-Karabakh president meets with US congress members in Yerevan

10:01 • 20/09

Erdogan reiterates call on Kurds to cancel independence referendum

09:53 • 20/09

Serzh Sargsyan meets with President of Poland in New York

09:35 • 20/09

Trump slams Maduro at UN, calling him Hitler

09:16 • 20/09

Right to self-determination vital element in Karabakh peace – Serzh Sargsyan

18:08 • 19/09

Armenia needs active Diaspora investments  -  economist  

17:01 • 19/09

Russian arms supplies to Abkhazia, Tskhinvali pose regional hazards - Georgian ambassador

16:43 • 19/09

Ardshinbank offers mortgages with lower interest rates

15:33 • 19/09

Armenian figure skaters to join Olympic Qualifier in Germany

14:54 • 19/09

Armenian delegates hamper passage of pro-Azerbaijani report by PACE committee

14:22 • 19/09

Only democratic Turkey can recognize Armenian Genocide – Garo Paylan

13:36 • 19/09

World’s first all-electric yacht unveiled (photos)

13:11 • 19/09

Hayk Kotanjian: The importance of engaging renowned Diaspora Armenians in the cause of the establishment of Cyber Resources Management System in the RA

12:46 • 19/09

Conjoined twins born to US parents who already have five children

12:16 • 19/09

Erdogan, Stoltenberg discuss S-400 deal with Russia, KRG referendum

12:01 • 19/09

Idea to build effectively developing modern state inspiring for all Armenians – Karen Karapetyan

11:24 • 19/09

US ‘shocked’ by Russian-Turkish missile system deal  – Armenian analyst

10:16 • 19/09

US Senate passes $700bn defense policy bill

09:52 • 19/09

Zhamanak: Georgia backs new Armenian ambassador's appointment

09:32 • 19/09

US withdraws proposed arms sale to Erdogan’s security detail

09:13 • 19/09

Hurricane Maria lashes Dominica

14:11 • 18/09

Nagorno-Karabakh’s exclusion from peace talks accounts for Azerbaijani aggression - Karen Mirzoyan

13:35 • 18/09

Emmys: Diversity reigns over Trump as ‘Big Little Lies,’ ‘Handmaid’s Tale,’ ‘SNL’ dominate

13:20 • 18/09

President: Just and developing country lays firm groundwork to preserve Armenian identity  

12:44 • 18/09

Rolling Stone magazine up for sale

12:18 • 18/09

Our key objective is to increase Armenia’s population to 4 million by 2040 – Serzh Sargsyan

11:24 • 18/09

Automated police station opens in Dubai (photos)

11:12 • 18/09

Armenia-Diaspora conference good platform to unite over common concerns - Manoyan

10:47 • 18/09

China, Russia launch naval drills in North Korea  

10:35 • 18/09

I am very happy to be in Armenia – Garo Paylan

10:14 • 18/09

Eight killed in powerful storm in Romania

09:57 • 18/09

Turkey summons German ambassador over pro-PKK rally in Cologne

09:40 • 18/09

Sixth Armenia-Diaspora conference opens in Yerevan

09:10 • 18/09

Man Utd 4-0 Everton: Martial and Mkhitaryan stats highlight contrast with last season

21:58 • 16/09

Public and private sector cooperation is vital for AI development in Armenia: PicsArt co-founder H. Avoyan

14:58 • 16/09

Former CNN employee received $2.6m through ‘Azerbaijani laundromat’

14:32 • 16/09

Millions of world’s children lack birth certificate

14:12 • 16/09

Francis Bacon painting hidden away for almost 50 years set to sell for a record price at auction

14:01 • 16/09

Rosatom plans to start building Turkish nuclear plant in early 2018

13:40 • 16/09

Chance of 'catastrophic' climate change completely wiping out humanity by 2100 is now 1-in-20