Women surgeons have lower death rates than men, study finds

13:44 • 11.10.17



Female surgeons were thought to be more skilled, better at following guidelines and superior at communicating with other staff, researchers said.

They found patients operated on by women were 12 per cent less likely to die. 


The study compared outcomes for patients undergoing one of 25 surgical procedures by a female surgeon with those having the same operation from a man.


A total of 104,630 patients and 3,314 surgeons were involved and it took place at a hospital in Ontario, Canada, between 2007 and 2015. 


The results showed women surgeons had slightly lower death rates than men, with their patients 12 per cent less likely to die.


This difference was very small – with only one extra death for every 230 procedures at the hands of male surgeons compared with women.


And patients treated by men were no more likely to suffer further complications or need to be admitted back to hospital.


Nonetheless, the findings do back up previous studies which had found women doctors were far less likely to be struck off than male colleagues. 


The authors from the University of Toronto speculated that the care of female surgeons was more “patient centred”, in line with guidelines' and involves “superior communication”.

There is also evidence that they take fewer risks than men and are more inclined to ask for help from colleagues if things go wrong. 


Professor Clare Marx, the former president of the Royal College of Surgeons and Professor Derek Alderson, the current president, said the findings would help dispel 'an unconscious bias' among patients – and staff – against women doctors. 


“This study helps to combat these lingering biases by confirming the safety, skill, and expertise of women surgeons relative to their male colleagues,” they wrote in an editorial accompanying the study in the BMJ.


But they urged patients not to worry about the sex of their surgeon. They added they were not “convinced that the sex of the surgeon will emerge as an important determinant of a good outcome for patients having surgery”.


Research in 2015 found that female doctors were two and a half times less likely to be struck off or sued for negligence than men. 


Experts have speculated that women doctors work harder because they feel obliged to prove themselves.

The study claims women are less likely to take risks and their care is more 'patient-centred', but researchers stress the difference in fatality rates are very small and patients shouldn't worry about the sex of their surgeon 





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:50 • 17/07

Government to submit ‘specific proposals’ to EU, says prime minister’s spokesperson

17:15 • 17/07

Spain captain Ramos proposes to girlfriend

16:58 • 17/07

Armenia’s ‘velvet revolution’ featured in museum exhibits

16:16 • 17/07

George Clooney made $322 million last year to become highest-earning actor in world

15:55 • 17/07

Rolls-Royce building future-style flying taxi 

15:25 • 17/07

President: We have positive outlook on Armenia’s great future

14:27 • 17/07

Pashinyan, Ter-Petrosyan discuss developments in Karabakh peace

13:57 • 17/07

Trump praises Turkey’s Erdogan for ‘doing things the right way’ in defense spending

13:45 • 17/07

Brent crude oil recovers in Asia trade after slumping to 3-month lows

13:28 • 17/07

Russia to ease citizenship rules for Armenians

12:46 • 17/07

Zhamanak: Fight against corruption ‘wasted effort’ to resolve past crimes

11:48 • 17/07

‘Don’t hold US-Russia ties hostage to internal politics’, Putin says after meeting with Trump

11:29 • 17/07

Henry Morgenthau III passes away  

11:19 • 17/07

Judges becoming ‘increasingly independent’ in Armenia, says president of Supreme Judicial Council

09:57 • 17/07

From a 35-arch ancient aqueduct to an eye-popping 20-mile road crossing: World's most incredible bridges revealed

09:29 • 17/07

Flying volcano injures 23 in Hawaii

09:20 • 17/07

Trump under fire after Putin summit

17:59 • 16/07

Trump sits down with Putin after denouncing past US policy on Russia

17:49 • 16/07

How Israel, in dark of night, torched its way to Iran’s nuclear secrets – The New York Times

17:17 • 16/07

Mission: Impossible-Fallout: Critics praise dangerous stunts performed by Tom Cruise who injured his ankle on set

16:53 • 16/07

Pashinyan 'politically inclined to peer-to-peer dialogue’ – diplomat  

16:07 • 16/07

French President Macron meets plenty of fans at World Cup final

15:55 • 16/07

Amazon Prime Day deals ‘deceptive’

15:14 • 16/07

No Armenian-Azerbaijani ministerial talks agreed in Brussels – MFA spokesperson

14:31 • 16/07

Ucom offers more Viasat Family channels to subscribers

14:05 • 16/07

Switalski: EU needs Armenia's 'specific proposals' to revise mutual agenda

12:46 • 16/07

Yerevan city council fails to secure quorom to elect new mayor

12:10 • 16/07

Erdogan: Turkish citizens ‘saved dignity of democracy’ during 2016 coup attempt

10:39 • 16/07

Two fans die as France's World Cup celebrations are marred by police violence

10:33 • 16/07

Italy to allow migrants to land in Sicily

10:05 • 16/07

Iran nuclear deal: US rejects EU plea for lifting sanctions

09:34 • 16/07

Trump calls EU 'foe' of the United States

09:18 • 16/07

France named 2018 FIFA World Cup winner

15:48 • 14/07

Facebook, Twitter, Alphabet to testify at US House hearing

15:15 • 14/07

Armenian parliament vice speaker thanks Poland for support to Genocide recognition efforts

14:25 • 14/07

11 Armenian companies named conscientious taxpayers  

13:50 • 14/07

Nancy Sinatra, Frank Sinatra's first wife, dies at 101

13:16 • 14/07

Two suspects released in Hrant Dink murder case

13:08 • 14/07

Armen Sarkissian issues congratulations to Emmanuel Macron on French national holiday

12:51 • 14/07

Armenian man killed in gang attack in Tbilisi

12:30 • 14/07

Congressman Sherman continues pressure to secure new US-Armenia tax treaty

12:14 • 14/07

168 Zham: Will Pashinyan meet Europe’s expectations?

11:06 • 14/07

Ronaldo back to Madrid

10:59 • 14/07

Elegant Melania Trump meets with Elizabeth II

10:38 • 14/07

Hraparak: Armenian authorities agree on timeframes of snap parliamentary election

09:53 • 14/07

Donald Trump arrives in Scotland amid protests

09:45 • 14/07

Trump opposes congressional restrictions on F-35 sale to Turkey

09:13 • 14/07

Trump-Putin summit 'is on' despite hacking indictment, says White House

18:26 • 13/07

Armenia, Russia send batches of food in humanitarian aid to Syria

18:13 • 13/07

Armenian president heads to Russia to watch FIFA 2018 World Cup finals

17:55 • 13/07

Protesters hold mass anti-Trump rallies in London

17:28 • 13/07

'New Armenia' is on the right foreign policy track, says politician

15:49 • 13/07

Supermoon Solar Eclipse reported this Friday the 13th for the first Time in 43 years 

15:27 • 13/07

Antonio Conte sacked as Chelsea manager

14:49 • 13/07

Euronews: Armenian PM urges NATO to send message to Azerbaijan

14:30 • 13/07

Armenian president visits French Embassy (photos)

14:16 • 13/07

Azerbaijan 'shells' Armenian border village                                  

14:00 • 13/07

Armenian-Belarusian parliamentary cooperation discussed in Warsaw

13:42 • 13/07

Time names Nikol Pashinyan 'crusader of world democracy'

12:59 • 13/07

Armenia's state revenues 'climbed 15.6%' in first quarter

12:01 • 13/07

Zhamanak: Armenia's ambassador in Prague to be sacked over ties with illegally enriched officials

11:39 • 13/07

Trump reveals giant baby blimp protest put him off London which 'he used to love as a city'... as the 20ft balloon now plans to follow him across the UK

10:54 • 13/07

Trump praises Boris Johnson 'as  future Prime Minister '

10:19 • 13/07

Game of Thrones leads with 22 Emmy nominations

09:53 • 13/07

Johnson & Johnson to pay $4.7bn damages in talc cancer case to US women

09:30 • 13/07

EU's Juncker filmed stumbling at NATO event

09:12 • 13/07

Trump issues Brexit warning

19:02 • 12/07

Fiat workers strike over Ronaldo signing

18:47 • 12/07

Developing relations with NATO to offer ‘good security alternatives’ to Armenia

18:06 • 12/07

French government ‘completed’ ratification of EU-Armenia agreement

17:29 • 12/07

US adult film star Stormy Daniels arrested in Ohio

17:11 • 12/07

Donald Tusk pledges EU's support to future reforms in Armenia

16:48 • 12/07

Attacks in Azerbaijan raise accusations of Islamist extremism, government skullduggery

16:37 • 12/07

Ameriabank wins Euromoney Award for Excellence 2018 as the Best Bank of the Year in Armenia

16:13 • 12/07

Whalers accused of killing rare blue whale off of Iceland - the first of its kind to be harpooned in more than 50 years

15:57 • 12/07

Rocket launch that made the sky ripple: NASA explains bizarre 'smashed sundog' phenomenon

15:39 • 12/07

Pashinyan meets with top EU officials in Brussels

15:20 • 12/07

Killing rats could save coral reefs

14:34 • 12/07

Armenia’s democratic revolution ‘stirs aggression’ in Azerbaijan - Pashinyan  

14:12 • 12/07

New prosecutor of Yerevan appointed

13:30 • 12/07

NATO insists Georgia will join alliance ‘despite separatist ambitions’

13:10 • 12/07

France 'committed' to banning weapons supply to Azerbaijan

12:26 • 12/07

Zhamanak: Minister unveils ‘extremely low’ economic activity index in Armenia

12:01 • 12/07

Yerevan City Council to elect new mayor on July 16

11:37 • 12/07

NATO vows to protect Turkey's southern border against threats

11:13 • 12/07

EU extends support to new electoral processes in Armenia

11:00 • 12/07

Armenian soldier killed in fight against terrorists in Syria  

10:39 • 12/07

Pashinyan attends special dinner event honoring NATO partner countries’ leaders

10:04 • 12/07

Trump urges EU members to double military funding

09:39 • 12/07

Armenian, Azerbaijani foreign ministers discuss future steps in Karabakh peace

09:07 • 12/07

NATO leaders to focus on Afghan conflict

15:28 • 11/07

Irrigation system launched in the borderland village of Dovegh

13:26 • 11/07

Special Offer from Ucom: Xiaomi Smartphone and Smart Band in a package

11:46 • 11/07

Ardshinbank partners with international investment bank to support trade finance in Armenia

16:32 • 10/07

The IFC Names Ameriabank Best Issuing Bank Partner in the Caucasus and Central Asia 2017

10:28 • 03/07

If the cooperation between Azerbaijan and “Rheinmetall” materializes, German produced arms might be used against Armenians both in Artsakh and the Republic of Armenia. Tessa Hofmann

19:06 • 29/06

EU leaders agree on plan to secure migrant centers

18:48 • 29/06

Luxembourg ratifes EU-Armenia agreement

18:27 • 29/06

Artsakkh president receives guests from American University of Armenia  

17:51 • 29/06

Libyan coastguard says 100 migrants may have drowned near Tripoli