Richard Giragosian: New EU-Armenia agreement to mark important breakthrough

12:04 • 21.10.17



The EU-Armenia Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement (CEPA), initialed in March 2017, presents a fresh start for the deepening of relations between the two parties in the wake of Armenia’s abortive Association Agreement and related Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Agreement (DCFTA). Despite a difficult and complicated context, both the EU and Armenia have demonstrated the necessary political will to negotiate a new compromise agreement that takes into account Armenia’s commitments and limitations as a member of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU).  

And the agreement keeps a considerable amount of content from the sacrificed Association Agreement, including the areas of political dialogue, justice and freedom, and even security.


The new agreement also includes a substantial amount of legally binding provisions across a range of sectoral areas of cooperation, although the effectiveness of CEPA’s essential degree of conditionality remains an open question. The issues most affected by Armenia’s EAEU membership are core trade policy elements and the consequential loss of any DCFTA. CEPA may be viewed in EU policy terms as an example of ‘differentiation’ and greater flexibility as advocated by the 2015 European Neighborhood Policy review, although this was prompted by Russian force majeure. The ultimate impact of CEPA remains a test of implementation, which still poses undeniable challenges for Armenia.


The new CEPA, initialed in May 2017, is now expected to be signed at by the end of the year.


Despite the original plan to have it ready in time for the EU Eastern Partnership (EaP) summit in Brussels on 24 November 2017, an unexpected delay within the EU institutions, which then triggered a delay in the legal review and translation, has set the timetable back. That delay, despite being unintended, may raise new concerns on Armenia’s part and possibly trigger resentment and frustration that the EU would be well advised to address.


The agreement, once officially adopted, will represent an important breakthrough for both the EU and Armenia, for two reasons. First, although CEPA can be seen more as an Association Agreement lite, it is the first successful example of European engagement in the Eastern Partnership that is based less on wishful thinking and more on a realistic consideration of the specific conditions and constraints that are unique to each EaP state. In Armenia’s case, this refers to the necessity of recognizing the government’s insistence on exercising its ‘sovereign choice’ as a condition for deepening ties to the EU weighed against the limits inherent in the country’s security reliance on Russia. This stance was a result of the May 2015 Riga Summit, when the EU presented its earlier review of the European Neighborhood Policy (ENP), which was completed in November of that year6 to the EaP countries. Both the Summit Declaration and the newly revised ENP strongly advocated for a policy of ‘differentiation’ in the EU’s relations with the neighbors and prudently abandoning a ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach, as demonstrated by the EU-Armenia CEPA. In other words, the degree of policy flexibility demonstrated by the EU underscored the modified policy of differentiation by being more acutely attuned to Russian concerns and Eurasian Economic Union constraints.


A second element of success stems from the fact that the new agreement was able to replace the Partnership and Cooperation Agreement (PCA) of 1999, with a legally binding and politically significant commitment underpinned by an essential degree of conditionality. And although the coming test of the success of CEPA will be in the implementation stage, there is an additional opportunity stemming from a possible move by the EAEU to leverage Armenia as a potential new platform to engage the EU, thereby offering a chance for garnering greater credibility for the EAEU while also elevating the strategic significance of Armenian membership in the EAEU.


Conclusion


After weathering the uncertainty of a period of ‘strategic pause’ in its relations with the European Union, Armenia recently initialed a new EU-Armenia framework agreement. Hailed as a rare second chance to restore relations and regain trust, the agreement, now on track to be signed in November 2017, represents a strategic opportunity for Armenia. The inherent opportunity stems from the agreement’s offer to salvage Armenia’s 2013 decision to sacrifice its earlier Association Agreement and related DCFTA with the EU and, in the wake of Russian pressure, to commit to join the EAEU instead.

Despite inherent constraints, CEPA stand out as an ambitious agreement. It has kept the substance of the Association Agreement in its political dialogue part. The commitments undertaken in the areas of justice, freedom and security and in 23 sectoral cooperation chapters are rather extensive. Many of these charters are kept at ‘approximation’ levels, which the failed Association Agreement included.

 

Despite the shortcomings in the new Armenia-EU agreement, the greatest reflected in selective trade chapters, the outlook for a deepening of relations is both positive and practical. On the one hand, the advantage for the EU lies in the successful elevation of bilateral relations with Armenia above and beyond the now outdated Partnership and Cooperation Agreement (PCA). For Armenia, on the other hand, the benefits stem from restored access to the EU toolbox of technical expertise and financial support. This latter point is especially critical to ensure that the reform effort in Armenia is sustained in the face of more drastic budgetary and political pressures. And for Armenia, this promises to offer more sweeping opportunities in several areas, such as border management, mobility partnerships and democracy-building instruments. At the same time, the new agreement provides a degree of political cover and practical incentives, magnified by the timing of the opportunities with Armenia’s own transformation and transition to a parliamentary form of governance in April 2018.


Another benefit for Armenia was the securing of a set of ‘transitional exemptions’ for a sweeping set of some 800 goods and products, thereby shielding the Armenian economy from the direct impact of the higher traffic regime required by the EAEU. But it was another aspect of timing that was equally encouraging for the normally timid Armenian officials to return to a concerted effort to re-engage the EU. While this motivation obviously stemmed from the twin necessities of the country’s economic fragility and political weakness, nevertheless, it did stand out and stand apart as a rare example of Armenian statesmanship and strategic vision, not to mention an instance of Armenia defending its own independence and pursuing its national interest.


Timing was also helpful for Armenia in another key regard. Whereas in 2013, when Moscow saw Armenia as the sacrificial pawn and leveraged its successful pressuring of Yerevan as a message of strength aimed to deter other Eastern Partnership countries, by 2015 there was no such need, with Russia also sensing little danger of ‘losing’ Armenia to the EU no matter what new agreement was reached, especially since any new agreement would be less than the broader Association Agreement and DCFTA. Thus, Russia provided Armenia with a much greater degree of flexibility, as seen in little real interference and certainly less interference over the negotiations between Armenia and the EU in this second attempt at redefining the relationship.


Amid Russia’s demonstration of such a seemingly more permissive stance, Armenia was also able to leverage a third, related trend that was driven by the downturn in fortunes of the Eurasian Economic Union and defined by Russia’s recognition of the need to garner greater legitimacy and credibility of the EAEU. In this context, Armenia’s argument that its eventual agreement with the EU could actually serve Russian interests by serving as a ‘bridge’ between the EU and the EAEU began to win adherents.64 At the same time, Armenia’s geographic position, despite the lack of land borders with the EAEU itself, was also reinterpreted as an advantage, offering the EAEU alternative avenues to leverage Armenia’s relations with Iran, proximity to the Middle East and even interest in the possible benefits from the possible reopening of its closed border with Turkey.


Yet even with the success to date of CEPA, in terms of both the process and the product, the full realization of the benefits and gains from the agreement are far from assured. As demonstrated by each of the other Eastern Partnership states, and especially in the cases of those with Association Agreements and DCFTAs, the implementation stage is as daunting as the negotiations, and perhaps even more difficult. And, as the implementation of CEPA will require even greater political will and determination to deepen and accelerate reform in several areas simultaneously, which Armenia has failed to do so far, the outlook for EU-Armenian relations still remains an open question. Thus, this is a strategic opportunity for the country, but one that it can no longer squander.

……………………………

Richard Giragosian is the Director of the Regional Studies Center (RSC), an independent “think tank” in Yerevan, Armenia.

 

Hripsime Hovhannisyan





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

15:23 • 19/02

Nagorno-Karabakh expands international cooperation

13:29 • 19/02

Armenian marksman qualifies for youth Olympics

12:55 • 19/02

Turkey, US to form a three-way mechanism to tackle festering bilateral issues

12:06 • 19/02

ISIL claims responsibility for Russian church shooting in which five women were killed

11:51 • 19/02

National Security Service chief hosts Russian counterpart to discuss cooperation

10:59 • 19/02

Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri enjoys a triumphant night at the BAFTAs as it becomes the big winner of the night with five prizes  

10:29 • 19/02

Asia shares extend global recovery, volatility subsides  

10:08 • 19/02

Winter Olympics 2018: Russian suspected of failed doping test

09:28 • 19/02

Mystery as shark falls from sky and lands in man’s back garden in Kent

09:14 • 19/02

Canada prime minister starts visit to India with Taj Mahal trip  

15:10 • 17/02

International community 'sees our campaign for justice' – Artsakh lawmaker  

14:51 • 17/02

Turkey, Germany pledge closer dialogue

14:42 • 17/02

Aravot: Genocide should not be underlying issue behind Armenian-Israeli relations

14:16 • 17/02

Japanese figure skater earns 1,000th Winter Olympics gold medal

14:06 • 17/02

Aliyev's belligerent rhetoric 'sign of solidarity with Turkey' – former defense minister

13:32 • 17/02

Nagorno-Karabakh reports 250 Azerbaijani ceasefire violations

13:13 • 17/02

Vic Darchinyan: I want to fight with Russian champion in Armenia 'before ending my career'

10:33 • 17/02

FBI under fire over Florida school shooting

09:12 • 17/02

Strong quake hits Mexico

17:53 • 16/02

Armenian, Russian emergency ministers discuss cooperation projects

16:51 • 16/02

Armenia-Belarus air transport cooperation discussed in Yerevan  

16:09 • 16/02

Armenian parliament rejects amendments to Tax Code

15:47 • 16/02

Arsenal boss Wenger confident of seeing out contract

15:30 • 16/02

Terrorist suicide bomber detained in Kyrgyzstan

14:53 • 16/02

18-year-old student saves toddler who jumped on tracks at Milan metro

14:39 • 16/02

US official ‘would be surprised' if Russia doesn't face more sanctions

14:31 • 16/02

iOS bug that displays an Indian character can crash iPhones and disable access to iMessages and WhatsApp

14:10 • 16/02

 NATO urges Turkey, Greece to ease tensions

13:15 • 16/02

Aravot: Supoerpowers' tolerance pushes Aliyev to further agression - politician

12:27 • 16/02

Major-General Tigran Parvanyan appointed commander of Russian-Armenian military contingent

11:52 • 16/02

Dutch parliament recognizes Armenian Genocide

11:28 • 16/02

Florida gunman who killed 17 in school shooting suffers from autism

10:50 • 16/02

Russian low-cost airline to launch flights from St Petrsburg to Gyumri

10:18 • 16/02

Aravot: Anti-Armenian propaganda contributed to tension over Karabakh, says official

09:41 • 16/02

Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux SPLIT after just two years of marriage

09:12 • 16/02

Australia PM Barnaby Joyce 'inept', says prime minister

18:18 • 14/02

Armenia named romantic travel destination

17:20 • 14/02

New anti-Russia sanctions ‘unrelated to Armenia’ – analyst

16:02 • 14/02

International community ‘turning blind eye’ to Turkey’s aggression – expert

15:33 • 14/02

Converse Bank offers agricultural loans

15:04 • 14/02

Amazon amid rare corporate layoff

14:18 • 14/02

Garo Paylan: Istanbul-Armenians unable to elect patriarch for 10 years       

13:27 • 14/02

Mammadyarov: EU-Azerbaijan cooperation not to affect Azerbaijan's partnership with Russia

12:54 • 14/02

Second US federal judge bars against Trump administration from ending DACA

12:44 • 14/02

Genes remain active after death

12:24 • 14/02

South Korea to pay North at Winter Olympics Olympics

12:13 • 14/02

Google Doodle celebrates Valentine’s Day 2018, Winter Olympics with two lovebirds skating together

12:03 • 14/02

Rare photos of celebrities back in days captured by one lucky teen photographer

11:46 • 14/02

Turkish citizen apprehended after illegally crossing Armenia’s border

11:15 • 14/02

No serious cooperation between our private sectors - head of Iran-Armenia Chamber of Commerce

09:35 • 14/02

Danish Quee’s husband Prince Henrik Dies at 83

09:15 • 14/02

Russian reported killed in Syria airstrikes

18:38 • 13/02

Planned sale of US fighters to Turkey ‘to be problematic for Armenia’ – Russian expert

17:32 • 13/02

Trump says America won't build more nuclear weapons – if other nations make commitments first

17:13 • 13/02

US planning cuts in economic, military aid to Armenia

16:21 • 13/02

Woman, 21, has abandoned by her husband and called a witch because of 'sweating' blood from eyes

15:57 • 13/02

Armen Sargsyan 'far more suitable candidate for prime minister' – Heritage party rep  

15:47 • 13/02

Ucom launches sales and service center in Armenia’s Agarak

14:56 • 13/02

Touching photo of baby gorilla hugging the man who saved her from being eaten wins wildlife photograph of the year

14:43 • 13/02

Boston Dynamics robots can open door for everyone (video)

14:33 • 13/02

Putin and Trump discuss North Korea by phone

13:42 • 13/02

Iran unveils new homemade nuclear-capable ballistic missiles

12:57 • 13/02

Iran has not proposed cheaper natural gas deal to Armenia, says official

12:31 • 13/02

Rio carnival dancers sparkle at samba parade as 72,000 spectators watch 'greatest show on Earth' 

12:13 • 13/02

Man who saved numerous lives with only one hand: Istanbul-Armenian doctor Hakob Kotoghian dies

11:38 • 13/02

CoE head to visit Turkey on Feb 15

11:06 • 13/02

Obamas' official portraits expand beyond usual format

10:53 • 13/02

Turkish prosecutor demands 10 years for HDP’s new Co-chairperson  

10:38 • 13/02

Winter Olympics: Chloe Kim wins halfpipe gold medal for US

09:57 • 13/02

Saakashvili seized at restaurant in Ukraine and Deported to Poland  

09:46 • 13/02

Trump administration aims to privatize the International Space Station

09:29 • 13/02

Zhamanak: PKK rebels seek asylum in Armenia

09:13 • 13/02

North Korea’s Kim thanks South for 'impressive' effort

18:02 • 12/02

Serzh Sargsyan’s preferred successor says 'final decision due' after next meeting with president

17:00 • 12/02

Iran ready to sell natural gas to Armenia ‘on affordable terms’ - ambassador

16:00 • 12/02

Criminals hide ‘billions’ in crypto cash

15:30 • 12/02

Serzh Sargsyan: Azerbaijan's snap presidential polls 'unrelated to Nagorno-Karabakh'

14:45 • 12/02

Armenian Genocide commemoration to be held in New York Times Square on April 22nd

14:22 • 12/02

Armenian-Austrian agricultural cooperation to be discussed in Vienna

13:30 • 12/02

Ranked voting system 'no reason' to end coalition partnership with Republican - ARF-D member

11:50 • 12/02

Tough weather conditions hamper recovery work at Russian plane-crash site

11:40 • 12/02

London City Airport shut after WW2 bomb found in Thames

11:22 • 12/02

International experts discuss Blockchain advantages in Yerevan

11:19 • 12/02

Russian pilots shoot down conventional 'enemy airdrome' in Armenia

10:38 • 12/02

Mirai Nagasu becomes first American woman to land triple axel at an Olympics

10:25 • 12/02

Reg E Cathey, ‘House of Cards’ and ‘The Wire’ actor, dies

09:51 • 12/02

Germany's Merkel calls for younger ministers in new government

09:45 • 12/02

Michigan town where only Christians are allowed to buy houses

09:27 • 12/02

NY state sues Weinstein Company

09:13 • 12/02

OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs call for fulfilling Vienna, St Petersburg agreements

09:02 • 12/02

71 killed in Russian passenger crash near Moscow

14:59 • 10/02

Aliyev calling snap presidential election ‘to win time’

14:14 • 10/02

Bulgarian president planning state visit to Armenia      

13:56 • 10/02

3,400-year-old mummy is brought back to life with controversial fair skin using 3D scans

13:44 • 10/02

'Rarest white diamond ever' is unveiled at Sotheby's London boutique

13:32 • 10/02

Pyeongchang 2018: Feuz promises 'full-on attack' in men's downhill

13:19 • 10/02

Nagorno-Karabakh reports 300 Azerbaijani ceasefire violations

13:02 • 10/02

Bako Sahakyan hosts OSCE Minsk Group mediators  

12:35 • 10/02

Armenia to criminalize terrorism

12:13 • 10/02

Israeli F-16 jet shot down by Syrian fire, military says