Confrontational Erdogan stuns Greek hosts on Athens visit – The Guardian

13:26 • 08.12.17



What had been billed a groundbreaking visit to Greece, the first by a Turkish president in 65 years, turned into a verbal theatre of war as Recep Tayyip Erdogan, flouting the niceties of diplomacy, crossed an array of red lines.


Within an hour of stepping off his plane, the pugilistic politician was sparring with the Greek head of state, Prokopis Pavlopoulos. Athens, he said imperiously, would never have entered Nato had it not been for Ankara’s support. As an ally, it should seek to improve the religious rights of the Muslim minority in Thracewhich were enshrined in the Lausanne treaty, he insisted, sitting stony-faced in the inner sanctum of the presidential palace. “It needs to be modernised,” he said of the treaty, which has long governed Greek-Turkish relations and is seen as a cornerstone of regional peace.


A visibly stunned Pavlopoulos hit back, calling the treaty non-negotiable.


“The Treaty of Lausanne defines the territory and the sovereignty of Greece, and of the European Union, and this treaty is non-negotiable. It has no flaws, it does not need to be reviewed, or updated.”


With tensions running high between the two long-time Nato rivals and neighbours, Athens had hoped the 48-hour sojourn would put fraught bilateral relations on a new footing. International condemnation of Erdoğan’s crackdownon democratic institutions, following a foiled coup against him last year, has strained relations with Europe and the US and meant that the Turkish leader has made fewer trips to the west. Greek officials thought he would use the visit to strike a conciliatory note. The red carpet was duly rolled out with military bands and Greece’s ornately dressed presidential guard doing the honours.

 

In what will be remembered as one of the biggest security operations in living memory – with 2,800 police deployed around the capital, snipers posted on rooftops, and commandos, sniffer dogs, bomb disposal experts and bodyguards drafted in – the visit brought Athens to a standstill.


But the 63-year-old Turkish leader, while thanking his hosts for the welcome, continued to ratchet up the rhetoric.


In subsequent talks with the prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, he chastised the Greeks for failing to look after Ottoman sites and provide a proper place of worship for Muslims. Cyprus, he argued, had not been reunified because Greek Cypriots kept turning down a “just and sustainable” settlement. He also attacked the “economic chasm” between Greeks, who earned on average €15,000 a year, and the Turkish-speaking Muslim minority in northern Thrace who earned around €2,200 a year.


Athens, he continued, should also return the eight Turkish officers who had escaped to Greece as the coup unfolded even if the country’s judicial system had blocked their repatriation on the grounds that they would not be given a fair trial. “It is possible to return them to Turkey, which is a country that has abolished the death penalty and is not a country of torture,” he told a press conference in the prime minister’s office.


Looking on in dismay – Greek ministers exchanging knowing smiles around him – Tsipras repeated that as the birthplace of democracy, where executive power was separate from the law, Greece respected decisions made by the country’s justice system.


Earlier, the 43-year-old had attempted to ameliorate the frosty atmosphere, telling his guest that respect for international law was the basis of solid ties between the two neighbours.


“Differences have always existed and [they exist] today,” the leftist leader said. “It is important … that we express our disagreements in a constructive way, without being provocative.”


The visit follows the arrests in Athens of nine Turkish nationals charged last week with being members of DHKP-C, a militant Marxist group that has claimed responsibility for suicide bombings in Turkey.


“The visit comes at an especially delicate time, diplomatically, given mounting criticism of his crackdown on perceived and real participants in the coup and other domestic opponents,” said Hubert Faustmann, professor of history and political science at the University of Nicosia.


Relations between Turkey and Greece have long been strained. Hostility can be traced back to the subjugation of Greeks under Ottoman rule before a bloody war of independence initiated in 1821 led to the creation of the modern Greek state in 1830.


Successive conflicts followed, most notably in 1922 when the Greek army suffered a disastrous defeat in Asia Minor, prompting a massive exchange of populations – widely seen as the first experiment in ethnic cleansing – and the establishment of the Republic of Turkey.


The two countries came close to war again in 1996 over a pair of uninhabited isles in the Aegean Sea. Most recently, tensions have resurfaced over Greece’s frontier role in the refugee crisis, failed talks to reunify Cyprus and, according to officials in Athens, Turkey’s repeated violations of Greek air and naval space in the Aegean.


The defence ministry claims more than 3,000 airspace violations have occurred this year, more than at any other time since 2003. Erdoğan’s open questioning of the peace treaty that forged the boundaries of the two states has exacerbated friction even further.


The Greeks are also acutely aware that geography means they must coexist with Turkey and stand to benefit most if Ankara remains anchored to Europe.






LATEST NEWSAll Today news

18:38 • 23/01

Karen Karapetyan meets with heads of major intn'l companies in Davos

17:37 • 23/01

Fake iPhone battery explodes in Chinese customer's mouth  

17:23 • 23/01

Bulgarian museum to honor Garegin Nzhdeh by erecting special statue  

16:45 • 23/01

Two more Armenians named Putin proxies in 2018 presidential race

16:12 • 23/01

Garo Paylan nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

15:43 • 23/01

Peruvian mother throws baby out of window onto waiting blanket as fire tears through building

15:37 • 23/01

Mkhitaryan to donate ManUtd T-shirt to young Armenian cancer patients

15:01 • 23/01

'Angel of death' nurse accused of killing 99 patients in two German hospitals

14:50 • 23/01

82% of wealth generated in 2017 goes to 1% of world population

14:35 • 23/01

Drones targeting Artsakh defense positions similar to ISIS aerial vehicles – Russian expert

12:42 • 23/01

Education key value for boosting investments in Armenia - economist

12:01 • 23/01

US Congress passes bill to end shutdown

11:29 • 23/01

Aravot: We need new agenda on Karabakh, says former minister

10:57 • 23/01

Neil Diamond retires over Parkinson's diagnosis

10:21 • 23/01

Hollywood’s oldest actress, Connie Sawyer, dies at 105 

10:05 • 23/01

Zhoghovurd: Serzh Sargsyan will be Armenia’s premier starting from April, says Russian analyst  

09:25 • 23/01

Turkey warns US over Kurdish militia group

09:09 • 23/01

Mkhitaryan completes move to Arsenal

18:13 • 22/01

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle not to invite Obama to wedding to ‘avoid diplomatic row’

17:58 • 22/01

Erdogan: Turkey will not take a step back from Afrin operations

17:49 • 22/01

Princess Eugenie announces engagement to long-term boyfriend

17:11 • 22/01

PACE elects Michele Nicoletti its new president

16:53 • 22/01

It is now 'best time' for doing business in Armenia – Karen Karapetyan's interview with RIA Novosti  

16:05 • 22/01

Google CEO compares impact of AI to electricity and fire

15:33 • 22/01

Turkey obtained US and Russia’s 'silent consent' over Syria – Armenian Turkologist

14:20 • 22/01

Naomi Campbell ‘secretly dating’ rapper Skepta

13:51 • 22/01

US Embassy in Yerevan to continue visa issuance to registered applicants

13:32 • 22/01

US seeks further military actions in Turkey after Syria – Armenian diplomat

12:32 • 22/01

Lavrov warns of increased Russiaphobia threats

12:13 • 22/01

US sanctions curb Microsoft sales to Russian firms

10:59 • 22/01

Kurds reportedly destroy five tanks in Syria’s Arfin

10:50 • 22/01

Ronaldo checks facial injury on pitch

10:23 • 22/01

Amazon opens a supermarket with no checkouts

10:01 • 22/01

176 girls get papillomavirus vaccination in Armenia

09:25 • 22/01

Teenage girls shoot in crowd near Orlando school

09:13 • 22/01

British army chief warns of Russian threat

15:02 • 20/01

Australian Open: Kerber beats Sharapova in straight sets

14:47 • 20/01

French porn star calls on parents to ‘teach children about sex’

14:40 • 20/01

US Supreme Court to rule on Trump travel ban

13:56 • 20/01

Our public pressure is successful – opposition MP on campaign against price hikes

12:54 • 20/01

Coca Cola unveils 'ambitious' global recycling plan by 2030

12:46 • 20/01

Azerbaijan gets new supply of military equipment from Russia

12:25 • 20/01

Lavrov denies withdrawal of Russian troops from Syria's Afrin

11:40 • 20/01

Zhamanak: Karen Karapetyan's team 'offering deal' to government critics

11:15 • 20/01

Top Obama aides ‘sorry’ for failure to recognize Armenian Genocide

10:46 • 20/01

International community 'positively disposed' to Karabakh peace – parliament official

09:58 • 20/01

Zuckerberg vows to ‘boost’ trustworthy news on Facebook

09:13 • 20/01

US Senate fails to agree on new budget

17:52 • 19/01

Armenian opposition group starts protest against price hikes

17:02 • 19/01

Istanbul hosts Hrant Dink commemoration march

16:30 • 19/01

Nagorno-Karabakh 'no playing card' in Turkey-Armenia relations - Turkologist

15:37 • 19/01

Armen Sargsyan 'best candidate for presidency now' – Republican MP

15:05 • 19/01

Paddington 2 beats Rotten Tomatoes' record as best film of all times

14:52 • 19/01

UK's Johnson calls for bridge over Channel

14:33 • 19/01

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle dolls are the stuff of nightmares

14:16 • 19/01

US urges Turkey to avoid taking action in Syria's Afrin

14:05 • 19/01

'I need time to think over presidency offer' – Arnen Sargsyan's response to president

13:34 • 19/01

Uber co-founder billionaire after $9.3bn investment deal

13:16 • 19/01

Serzh Sargsyan proposes candidate for fourth president of Armenia

12:41 • 19/01

Trump orders CNN journalist out of Oval Office

12:04 • 19/01

Armenian ambassador to Romania submits credentials to Pres. Iohannis

11:44 • 19/01

Turkey extends state of emergency for three more months

11:10 • 19/01

Ratification of EU-Armenia agreement top issue of our diplomacy this year – parliament official

09:45 • 19/01

Karabakh peace mediators planning regional trip in February - MFA

09:25 • 19/01

US House sends funding bill to Senate

09:12 • 19/01

New Zealand PM reveals pregnancy news

17:48 • 18/01

Press Officer to William, Kate and Harry most-viewed job ad on LinkedIn in 2017

17:29 • 18/01

World’s first bitcoin billionaires lose $350 million

16:45 • 18/01

Nalbandian, Mammadyarov start meeting in Krakow

16:34 • 18/01

Armenia's energy minister hands in resignation

16:24 • 18/01

Armenian officer-lawyers start two-day assembly in Yerevan

15:45 • 18/01

Jailed Turkish journalist applies to Turkey’s Constitutional Court for execution of release ruling

15:25 • 18/01

Trump's view on Mexico wall 'changed'

15:13 • 18/01

Football transfer news: Alexis and Mkhitaryan deal close to completion

14:49 • 18/01

British boy, 8, leaves mother stunned by scrawling horror-style messages in bedroom

14:13 • 18/01

Armenian cabinet backs temporary ban on import of RHD cars

13:46 • 18/01

'Fire and Fury': Controversial novel about Trump to become TV series  

13:22 • 18/01

Premier calls for steps to eliminate red tape in development sector

12:20 • 18/01

$850,000 gene therapy injection ‘the most expensive one-time dose medicine ever made’

12:12 • 18/01

Apple to pay $38 billion on foreign cash pile

12:06 • 18/01

Zhamanak: Armenia's former finance minister planning return to office

11:56 • 18/01

US Congressman Pallone  calls for unrestricted travel and communication between US and Artsakh

11:52 • 18/01

Over 50 people killed after bus catches fire in Kazakhstan

11:31 • 18/01

Soldier wounded in Azerbaijani gunfire in Armenia’s Tavush

11:06 • 18/01

Germany's Merkel defends EU-Turkey refugee deal

10:56 • 18/01

Serzh Sargsyan to address PACE Winter Session on Jan 24

10:24 • 18/01

Armenia committed to future progress in Karabakh talks – Nalbandian

09:32 • 18/01

Iran to register Armenian cathedral as UNESCO world heritage site

09:13 • 18/01

Catalan lawmakers elect separatist speaker

17:58 • 17/01

Parliament oversight to ensure more effective implementation of intn’l treaties - Ashotyan

17:08 • 17/01

Erdogan eyes meeting with Pope as ‘gateway to reconciliation with Armenia’ – REGNUM

16:41 • 17/01

Mkhitaryan reveals he is Arsenal fan as Manchester Utd ace closes in on move

16:33 • 17/01

Smartphone app used to end abduction in Belgium

16:27 • 17/01

Ex-CIA officer held for helping China

16:13 • 17/01

World’s biggest underwater cave discovered in Mexico

15:46 • 17/01

Nagorno-Karabakh listed among UN's top concerns for 2018

15:17 • 17/01

Home and Away actress Jessica Falkholt dies

14:56 • 17/01

New bid proposes splitting California into two states

14:25 • 17/01

Russian flight from Mexico postponed due to 'order to deport four Armenians'  

14:00 • 17/01

Converse Bank launches mobile service