EU Court rejects Christian Louboutin's bid to trademark red soles

16:14 • 07.02.18



The French shoe designer Christian Louboutin — known for sky-high stiletto shoes with scarlet soles that can sell for upward of $1,000 — has been trying to do so for years.

Mr Louboutin first grabbed his assistant’s red nail polish and applied it to the outsoles of a shoe a quarter-century ago. Since then, he has frequently declared the design element to be his recognizable signature, and argued it merits legal protection.


On Tuesday, the European Union’s highest court dealt a blow to that effort, the New York Times reports.

Mr Louboutin had filed a lawsuit in 2012 against Van Haren, a Dutch company whose retail outlets were selling affordably priced high-heeled women’s shoes with red soles. Lawyers for Mr. Louboutin claimed that the shoes sold by Van Haren, part of its Fifth Avenue by Halle Berry line, infringed on his brand’s trademark for footwear. That trademark, registered in Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg, referred to “the color red (Pantone 18 1663TP) applied to the sole of a shoe.”


Van Haren had to temporarily stop making and selling the line of shoes, but the company’s lawyers fought back and the case eventually made its way to the European Court of Justice.


They have now won something of a reprieve. Maciej Szpunar, an advocate general for the court, said on Tuesday that Mr. Louboutin’s red soles were not a separate entity from the shape of his high-heeled shoes, and shapes typically cannot be trademarked under European Union law.


In effect, he argued in a legal opinion, Mr. Louboutin’s red soles could be refused trademark protection, sending the case back to Dutch courts to consider. Judges in national courts typically, though not always, follow advice from the European Court of Justice’s advocates general.


The case highlights one of the most difficult questions in fashion: In a world where designers often have distinct styles, and attract admirers based on those styles, what can, and cannot, be trademarked?


Major luxury conglomerates like LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton and Kering have historically been the most litigious, often using the courts to battle the counterfeiting that has long been a headache in the fashion industry. More recently, however, smaller brands and designers have also started to pursue legal action, particularly against larger luxury or fast-fashion companies that they claim use their designs without acknowledgment or permission.


Last week, the Indian designer Orijit Sen and his New Delhi-based studio and store People Tree accused Christian Dior of plagiarizing a block print of a man doing yoga poses. Mr. Sen argued that he had formulated the design in 2000, and complained when it was used for a red dress worn by the Bollywood actress Sonam Kapoor on the cover of Elle’s Indian edition last month. He posted his complaints on Facebook under the title “Unchristian Dior.”


And in 2016, the fast-fashion chain Zara was accused by at least 20 independent artists of plagiarizing designs, while one of the most powerful voices to emerge in the online fashion world in recent months is Diet Prada, an Instagram account dedicated to calling out copying in the industry.


Indeed, illustrating the complexity of the issue, Mr. Louboutin himself previously won a battle against the rival luxury fashion house Yves Saint Laurent in a United States federal appeals court, allowing him to protect his red soles as a source-identifying trademark.


But Mr Szpunar’s opinion for the European Court of Justice “could mean that Louboutin would not be able to stop its competitors, including haute couture fashion houses, from offering shoes with red soles,” said Sanjay Kapur, a partner at the British law firm Potter Clarkson and a specialist in trademark law.


Trying to persuade courts to grant such protection to designs like Mr. Louboutin’s “may well be an insurmountable hurdle,” Mr. Kapur said. “The red sole could therefore become ubiquitous, which would seriously reduce the cachet associated with the Louboutin brand.”





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

15:57 • 26/05

Armenia launches special education platform for new generation reforms

14:32 • 26/05

Nagorno-Karabakh reports relative calm on frontline

14:17 • 26/05

US, Turkey agree on road map over Syrian region

13:33 • 26/05

Prime Minister Pashinyan hosts Armenian school-leavers in special ceremony

12:35 • 26/05

EBRD pledges increased assistance to Armenia  

12:16 • 26/05

UK backs the decision to hold Russia liable for the downing of flight MH17

11:35 • 26/05

168 Zham: Russian analyst optimistic about US-mediated Pashinyan-Aliyev talks  

10:58 • 26/05

Armen Sarkissian meets with former Georgian prime minister in Tbilisi  

10:30 • 26/05

UN circulates Nagorno-Karabakh Foreign Ministry memorandum

09:56 • 26/05

Fiat Chrysler recalling 4.8 million US cars

09:40 • 26/05

Irish back abortion reform

09:33 • 26/05

Deadly cyclone hits southern Oman

09:16 • 26/05

Harvey Weinstein released on $1m bail 

18:05 • 25/05

New privacy law forces US media offline in Europe

17:43 • 25/05

US marines prepare for helicopter evacuation of Hawaii's Big Island residents as a third lava flow from the Kilauea volcano streams into ocean

17:02 • 25/05

We want new cultural perceptions in Armenia – Nikol Pashinyan  

16:16 • 25/05

Harvey Weinstein arrested

15:56 • 25/05

Ex-Armenian envoy charged in Rolls-Royce bribery case in China

15:37 • 25/05

Electoral reforms should focus on participatory processes in Armenia - lawmaker

15:13 • 25/05

NBA champion on brink of NBA elimination with loss to Houston Rocket

13:58 • 25/05

Meghan Markle reportedly taking duchess lessons to please the queen

13:50 • 25/05

Russia liable for downing MH17 airliner

13:37 • 25/05

Popular YouTube star dies aged 33

13:28 • 25/05

Around 190 undocumented migrants captured in Turkey’s west

13:11 • 25/05

UK’s Johnson gets pranked by Russian callers pretending to be Armenian prime minister

12:43 • 25/05

Armenian premier calls for rapid steps ‘to halt wave of migration’

11:55 • 25/05

Pompeo: US, Turkey should avoid any clashes in northern Syria

11:41 • 25/05

North Korea says still open to talks after cancelation of Trump-Kim summit

11:28 • 25/05

Samsung ordered to pay Apple nearly $539m in damages in longstanding patent dispute

11:13 • 25/05

Asia’s first Armenian museum opens in Singapore

10:44 • 25/05

2018 will be ‘historic year’ for Armenia, says president

09:59 • 25/05

Harvey Weinstein to surrender to police

09:27 • 25/05

Morgan Freeman accused of sexual harassment

09:16 • 25/05

Putin, Macron discuss Iran’s withdrawal from nuclear deal

15:09 • 24/05

Russia demonstrated cautious stance on 'velvet revolution' in Armenia - analyst

14:41 • 24/05

Flags of Yerevan, Armenia sent to International Space Station  

13:11 • 24/05

Richard Gere confirmed for first major TV role in BBC drama

12:53 • 24/05

Israeli Knesset backs motion to recognize Armenian Genocide

12:39 • 24/05

US Sanator Portantino continues to champion Armenian community with important budget proposals

12:19 • 24/05

Hraparak: Armenia's political elite 'preparing for constitutional reforms'

11:52 • 24/05

168 Zham: Impact of EU-Armenia agreement to be fully tangible 'after complete ratification'

11:22 • 24/05

'Start Your Impossible': Toyota launches global campaign

11:03 • 24/05

Ucom subscribers to benefit from special roaming rate of 15 AMD/MB in 43 countries

10:41 • 24/05

Italian president names new cabinet leader

10:27 • 24/05

Iran nuclear deal: Khamenei lists demands for European countries

09:31 • 24/05

US expels Venezuelan diplomats amid escalating election raw

09:18 • 24/05

North Korea calls US Vice-President Mike Pence 'stupid'

17:44 • 23/05

Nikol Pashinyan hosts AGBU Central Board members

17:11 • 23/05

Pompeo might have pulled the plug on Armenian-Iranian trade - Eurasia Future

16:26 • 23/05

Pashinyan: IT sector 'key priority' for Armenian government

15:40 • 23/05

Arsenal names former PSG boss as successor to Wenger

15:26 • 23/05

Israeli Security Cabinet convening in underground bunker

15:14 • 23/05

British presenter dives to catch loose horse at Chepstow

15:00 • 23/05

Statistics reveals twofold increase in Armenian employment migrants' number in Russia

14:38 • 23/05

US to ease crisis-era banking rules

14:02 • 23/05

Armenian employee of Scottsdale takes $250K from jeweler before trip to homeland

13:47 • 23/05

Thomas de Waal: Karabakh peace process needs shaking up - but not too much  

12:06 • 23/05

Hraparak: Armenia's neighbors 'not content' with new National Security Council chief

11:35 • 23/05

Facebook apologizes for failure to 'prevent misuse'

11:17 • 23/05

Airstrikes neutralize PKK militants in Eastern Turkey

11:04 • 23/05

Soldier found dead in Armenian military post  

10:50 • 23/05

Iran says ‘will not seek’ permission from any power to develop weapons

10:38 • 23/05

Heatwave in Pakistan kills 65 people and leaves dozens passing out in the street

09:59 • 23/05

Philip Roth dies at 85

09:33 • 23/05

US Secretary of State Pompeo shares ANCA’s Enthusiasm about Armenia’s peaceful political Transition

09:10 • 23/05

Trump says summit with North Korea's leader may be delayed

17:51 • 22/05

Pope Francis extends support to gay men

17:43 • 22/05

Turkey to review ties with Israel

17:25 • 22/05

Armenian cabinet conducts special meeting  

16:57 • 22/05

US and Israel should recognize the Armenian Genocide - Bloomberg

16:34 • 22/05

Film on Syrian-Armenian refugees wins top prize in Sevastopol festival  

15:50 • 22/05

Serj Tankian warns against speculations over Armenian Genocide  

15:21 • 22/05

Armenian boxers win four medals in intn’l tournament

14:42 • 22/05

Artsakh’s participation in negotiations crucial for future peace – MFA spokesperson

13:51 • 22/05

Charlize Theron to star as Megyn Kelly in film about Fox News

13:44 • 22/05

Study into malaria genetics shows how disease became deadly

13:32 • 22/05

Meghan Markle's father is seen for first time since missing her wedding 

13:17 • 22/05

Trump goes rogue on phone security

13:08 • 22/05

Iran condemns US sanctions

13:00 • 22/05

UK turns blind eye to 'dirty Russian money'

12:32 • 22/05

No serious foreign policy changes should be expected in Armenia - Richard Giragosian

10:36 • 22/05

Zhoghovurd: Slowdown in Armenia’s economy ‘officially reported’ after 'velvet revolution'  

09:37 • 22/05

Turkish court to jail 104 ex-military for life in coup trial

09:28 • 22/05

Masked gunmen in Marseille open fire with automatic rifles

09:08 • 22/05

Japanese mountain climber dies on eighth attempt on Everest

18:05 • 21/05

No plans for ‘freezing credits’ discussed with government – Central Bank president

17:02 • 21/05

Ucom drops prices for more than 60 smartphones and launches iPhone 8 red sales

16:49 • 21/05

Explosion kills at least 2 in Azerbaijani capital

15:04 • 21/05

Taxation policies not profitable for mine exploiters in Armenia – environmentalist

13:41 • 21/05

Hillary Clinton trolls Trump with Russian hat during Yale commencement speech 

12:45 • 21/05

Georgia 'agrees to negotiate' Armenia-Russia trade corridor plan with Moscow  

12:10 • 21/05

Jenna Dewan rocks Chin-Length Bob at Billboard Music Awards after chopping off hair

11:58 • 21/05

Iran uses nuclear pact as bargaining chip with EU over US sanctions

11:13 • 21/05

Thessaloniki mayor beaten up

11:00 • 21/05

Former civic activist to head State Control Service

10:40 • 21/05

Man Utd 'can fight for Premier League & Champions League with right signings'

10:11 • 21/05

Beyoncé 'buys her own church' in New Orleans 

09:25 • 21/05

US Department of Justice to probe Trump campaign 'infiltration'

09:13 • 21/05

Venezuela: Maduro wins second term in controversial presidential election

19:38 • 19/05

“Renaissance” Foundation organized an event dedicated to well-known Armenian-American writer William Saroyan