EU Court rejects Christian Louboutin's bid to trademark red soles

16:14 • 07.02.18



The French shoe designer Christian Louboutin — known for sky-high stiletto shoes with scarlet soles that can sell for upward of $1,000 — has been trying to do so for years.

Mr Louboutin first grabbed his assistant’s red nail polish and applied it to the outsoles of a shoe a quarter-century ago. Since then, he has frequently declared the design element to be his recognizable signature, and argued it merits legal protection.


On Tuesday, the European Union’s highest court dealt a blow to that effort, the New York Times reports.

Mr Louboutin had filed a lawsuit in 2012 against Van Haren, a Dutch company whose retail outlets were selling affordably priced high-heeled women’s shoes with red soles. Lawyers for Mr. Louboutin claimed that the shoes sold by Van Haren, part of its Fifth Avenue by Halle Berry line, infringed on his brand’s trademark for footwear. That trademark, registered in Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg, referred to “the color red (Pantone 18 1663TP) applied to the sole of a shoe.”


Van Haren had to temporarily stop making and selling the line of shoes, but the company’s lawyers fought back and the case eventually made its way to the European Court of Justice.


They have now won something of a reprieve. Maciej Szpunar, an advocate general for the court, said on Tuesday that Mr. Louboutin’s red soles were not a separate entity from the shape of his high-heeled shoes, and shapes typically cannot be trademarked under European Union law.


In effect, he argued in a legal opinion, Mr. Louboutin’s red soles could be refused trademark protection, sending the case back to Dutch courts to consider. Judges in national courts typically, though not always, follow advice from the European Court of Justice’s advocates general.


The case highlights one of the most difficult questions in fashion: In a world where designers often have distinct styles, and attract admirers based on those styles, what can, and cannot, be trademarked?


Major luxury conglomerates like LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton and Kering have historically been the most litigious, often using the courts to battle the counterfeiting that has long been a headache in the fashion industry. More recently, however, smaller brands and designers have also started to pursue legal action, particularly against larger luxury or fast-fashion companies that they claim use their designs without acknowledgment or permission.


Last week, the Indian designer Orijit Sen and his New Delhi-based studio and store People Tree accused Christian Dior of plagiarizing a block print of a man doing yoga poses. Mr. Sen argued that he had formulated the design in 2000, and complained when it was used for a red dress worn by the Bollywood actress Sonam Kapoor on the cover of Elle’s Indian edition last month. He posted his complaints on Facebook under the title “Unchristian Dior.”


And in 2016, the fast-fashion chain Zara was accused by at least 20 independent artists of plagiarizing designs, while one of the most powerful voices to emerge in the online fashion world in recent months is Diet Prada, an Instagram account dedicated to calling out copying in the industry.


Indeed, illustrating the complexity of the issue, Mr. Louboutin himself previously won a battle against the rival luxury fashion house Yves Saint Laurent in a United States federal appeals court, allowing him to protect his red soles as a source-identifying trademark.


But Mr Szpunar’s opinion for the European Court of Justice “could mean that Louboutin would not be able to stop its competitors, including haute couture fashion houses, from offering shoes with red soles,” said Sanjay Kapur, a partner at the British law firm Potter Clarkson and a specialist in trademark law.


Trying to persuade courts to grant such protection to designs like Mr. Louboutin’s “may well be an insurmountable hurdle,” Mr. Kapur said. “The red sole could therefore become ubiquitous, which would seriously reduce the cachet associated with the Louboutin brand.”





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:59 • 23/02

Private wounded in Armenia's north-east

17:43 • 23/02

Grand Holding named leader of Armenian economy

17:29 • 23/02

Ryan Boatright leaves Armenian basketball team

16:57 • 23/02

Hot summer awaits Syria terrorists – Erdogan

16:43 • 23/02

Ruling coalition officially endorses Armen Sargsyan for presidency

16:07 • 23/02

Beyonce and Jay-Z fan spread joint tour rumors

15:53 • 23/02

Azerbaijan not ready for full-scale war – Artsakh parliament speaker  

15:07 • 23/02

Kylie Jenner tweet hammers snapchat shares

14:45 • 23/02

Bride almost misses her own wedding reception after getting stuck in lift

14:01 • 23/02

Armen Sargsyan meets with Republican, ARF-D lawmakers

13:36 • 23/02

Artsakh president congratulates Armenians on Motherland Defender’s Day

13:28 • 23/02

New video shows Airbus' one-seater Vahana drone take to the skies ahead of 2020 commercial launch

12:46 • 23/02

Artsakh ‘very close’ to international recognition – Russian bloggers

11:05 • 23/02

Chorrord Ishkanutyun: European tourist ‘held hostage’ by Russians in Armenian village

10:48 • 23/02

Australian deputy PM resigns over affair scandal

10:32 • 23/02

Zhamanak: Russia creates breeding ground for war over Karabakh

09:32 • 23/02

Congressional Armenian Caucus leaders mark 30th anniversary of Artsakh movement

09:12 • 23/02

Trump has law on his side in call for higher gun-sale age limit

17:58 • 22/02

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry get ‘racist’ letter containing white powder

17:31 • 22/02

Armenophobia ‘part and parcel of Azerbaijan’s foreign policy’ – Armenian official

16:23 • 22/02

Trump uses a cue-card to remind himself to be sympathetic as he meets survivors of Florida school massacre 

16:06 • 22/02

Nagorno-Karabakh soldier wounded in Azerbaijani gunfire

15:54 • 22/02

Gigi and Bella Hadid model retro wigs and floor-sweeping gowns for Moschino show at Milan Fashion Week

15:26 • 22/02

Armenia hails Lebanon's stance on Karabakh peace – Edward Nalbandian

14:33 • 22/02

Armenia key destination for Russian emigrants from Omsk

14:05 • 22/02

Armenian Alpine skier ranks 42nd in  Pyeongchang Olympics

13:50 • 22/02

Ed Sheeran named winner of Brit Awards

13:38 • 22/02

Sumgait pogroms revealed Azerbaijan's genocidal intent 'still awaiting proper evaluation' - parliament speaker

13:02 • 22/02

Artsakh people peace-loving ‘but also very attentive’ – Russian blogger

11:54 • 22/02

Aravot: Political forces have consensus over Armen Sargsyan’s presidency, says analyst

11:28 • 22/02

Iran warns of war threatening Syria neigbors

11:10 • 22/02

Zhamanak: Alternative to peace deal: Armenia from the inside out  

10:21 • 22/02

Oil prices drop on firmer US dollar

10:09 • 22/02

Republican to nominate Armen Sargsyan for presidency at special parliament session - spokesperson

09:46 • 22/02

US radio presenter gives birth on air

09:22 • 22/02

Explosion reported at US embassy in Montenegro  

09:11 • 22/02

Zhamanak: Armenian parliament speaker, health minister mull new business project  

08:59 • 22/02

Apple in talks to buy cobalt directly from miners

08:48 • 22/02

Venezuela's Maduro wants 'mega-election' amid opposition boycott

18:49 • 21/02

Smithsonian Festival ‘good opportunity to raise international awareness’ of Armenia, say organizers

17:50 • 21/02

Armenian-Israeli parliamentary cooperation discussed in Knesset

17:20 • 21/02

Parliament committee rejects bill condemning 2008 post-electoral turmoil  

17:01 • 21/02

France’s Macron plans tighter asylum rules

16:49 • 21/02

Serena Williams shares life-threatening experience of giving birth

16:19 • 21/02

Armenian parliament speaker, Brazilian ambassador discuss regional peace

15:44 • 21/02

Japanese farmers invent edible banana skin

15:21 • 21/02

Syria's Ghouta residents 'wait to die' amid heavy bombing

13:32 • 21/02

Venezuela says launch of cryptocurrency raised $735 million

13:20 • 21/02

Sheer madness! Angela Sarafyan's amazingly bold appearance at Esquire Hollywood bash

13:05 • 21/02

Christopher Nolan says he 'won’t be the man' to direct the next James Bond movie

12:05 • 21/02

France reaffirms support to Karabakh peace

11:40 • 21/02

Erdogan: Pro-regime groups in Afrin issue ‘closed’

11:23 • 21/02

North Korea backed out of secret meeting with Pence, says US

10:53 • 21/02

Armenian authorities 'aware of shadow businesses' - economist  

10:15 • 21/02

Trump pushes for ban on gun 'bump stocks'

09:52 • 21/02

Hraparak: Republican, opposition MPs to attend EU-Armenia summit in Berlin

09:15 • 21/02

Iranian Police Arrest 300 rioters in capital after five security forces killed

17:59 • 20/02

Edward Nalbandian to conduct official visit to Burssels

17:41 • 20/02

Seaside Startup Summit India.Goa gains governmental support  

17:12 • 20/02

Armenia creating 'institute of autocratic prime minister’ – human rights advocate  

16:30 • 20/02

KFC shuts down more stores amid chicken delivery fiasco

16:10 • 20/02

Canada’s Trudeau and family pass time by visiting Gandhi’s home while wearing traditional Indian dress as Modi ‘snubs’ him on official visit

15:55 • 20/02

Jennifer Lawrence is not taking a year off from acting

15:45 • 20/02

Shocking moment woman balances precariously on a tiny ledge five floors above ground to clean outside apartment windows

15:37 • 20/02

Mahmoud Abbas to urge alternative to US as peace mediator in UN speech

15:28 • 20/02

Nagorno-Karabakh developing steadily for 30 years after shaking off Azerbaijani yoke – Serzh Sargsyan

15:09 • 20/02

President Sargsyan’s attendance at the Munich Security Conference ‘had strategic significance’ – Richard Giragosian

14:48 • 20/02

NASA’s Opportunity rover surpasses 5,000 Martian days on the Red Planet

14:41 • 20/02

Last British-Armenian hotel sold in Calcutta

14:31 • 20/02

Canadian couple breaks short dance record in Pyeongchang

14:14 • 20/02

Armenia launching milk quality improvement project  

13:16 • 20/02

At least 17 killed in Mozambique capital as pile of garbage collapses

12:31 • 20/02

‘I'm still punching!' Sylvester Stallone dismisses bizarre hoax claiming he has died of cancer

12:18 • 20/02

Bitcoin breaks through $11,000 for the first time since January  

12:06 • 20/02

European Parliament to mark 30th anniversary of Nagorno-Karabakh movement in special event

11:51 • 20/02

European Parliamentarians ask Federica Mogherini why EU officials do not visit Nagorno-Karabakh

11:38 • 20/02

Three Iranian police killed in clashes with Sufi protesters

11:29 • 20/02

Turkish, Russian, Iranian presidents to meet in Turkey in April

11:08 • 20/02

Serj Tankian, Creative Armenia announce ‘7 Notes Music Challenge’ winners

10:59 • 20/02

Hraparak: Knesset speaker’s visit to Armenia ‘still questionable’

10:41 • 20/02

Football: Chelsea's Hazard dismisses comparisons to Messi and Ronaldo

10:28 • 20/02

Ocean plastic tide 'violates international law'

10:00 • 20/02

US students stage White House protest as Trump gives nod to background bill

09:31 • 20/02

Volcano Mount Sinabung  erupts in Indonesia

09:13 • 20/02

Saudi Arabia set to build 16 nuclear reactors with Russian help

15:23 • 19/02

Nagorno-Karabakh expands international cooperation

13:29 • 19/02

Armenian marksman qualifies for youth Olympics

12:55 • 19/02

Turkey, US to form a three-way mechanism to tackle festering bilateral issues

12:06 • 19/02

ISIL claims responsibility for Russian church shooting in which five women were killed

11:51 • 19/02

National Security Service chief hosts Russian counterpart to discuss cooperation

10:59 • 19/02

Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri enjoys a triumphant night at the BAFTAs as it becomes the big winner of the night with five prizes  

10:29 • 19/02

Asia shares extend global recovery, volatility subsides  

10:08 • 19/02

Winter Olympics 2018: Russian suspected of failed doping test

09:28 • 19/02

Mystery as shark falls from sky and lands in man’s back garden in Kent

09:14 • 19/02

Canada prime minister starts visit to India with Taj Mahal trip  

15:10 • 17/02

International community 'sees our campaign for justice' – Artsakh lawmaker  

14:51 • 17/02

Turkey, Germany pledge closer dialogue

14:42 • 17/02

Aravot: Genocide should not be underlying issue behind Armenian-Israeli relations

14:16 • 17/02

Japanese figure skater earns 1,000th Winter Olympics gold medal

14:06 • 17/02

Aliyev's belligerent rhetoric 'sign of solidarity with Turkey' – former defense minister