Putin may be starting to win Georgia away from the West – The Washington Post

11:35 • 27.01.16



By Michael Hikari Cecir


Is Georgia on the verge of a Kremlin-inspired political takeover? No. But neither is growing Russian influence a fantasy, as a December post by Dustin Gilbreath in The Monkey Cage appears to suggest.
Gilbreath makes some good points about political tendencies in Georgia. Georgians’ views of Russia are indeed complicated. But pro-Eurasian Union sentiment is growing, and there’s a significant chance that Russian influence is growing as well.


Polling data taken regularly over the last several years shows a clear and steady increase in Georgian support for the Moscow-led Eurasian Economic Union (EEU). That roughly tracks with increasing political support for anti-West and pro-Russia political factions within Georgia.


Why should the West care?


Getting a feel for Georgia’s geopolitical trajectory is too important to get wrong. Georgia is arguably the stablest and most democratic of the post-Soviet republics outside of the Baltics, and plausibly the last hope in a region that has seen years of political stagnation and regression. The United States and Europe have poured billions into promoting democracy and economic development there, and Tbilisi has consistently responded with an enthusiastic embrace of Westernization.


The government in Tbilisi is doing just about everything right. But expansion fatigue in the United States and especially Europe is breeding fatalism in Georgia, and incubating a political environment where pro-Russia factions’ anti-west crusades are gaining traction.


If Georgia turned away from the West, it would not only be a blow to the country’s nascent democracy, but it would also sew up the Eurasian interior for Moscow, give Russia a direct corridor to the Middle East, lop off Western access to Eurasian energy sources and kill off any hope for regional democratization for the foreseeable future.


Under Russian domination, Georgia might fall back into a mirror image of its 1990s past: a failed state and open air market for illicit trade. Racked by civil war and warlordism, it could be a fertile ground for radicalism.


Georgian support for the EEU “hasn’t changed since 2013,” Gilbreath wrote, referring to a 2013 Caucasus Barometer poll.


But his organization’s polls tell a different story. Gilbreath’s Caucasus Research Resource Centers (CRRC) conducted polls for the National Democratic Institute (NDI) in 2013, 2014 and 2015. Those show steady growth in reported pro-EEU sentiment between 2013 and the present — from 11 percent in August 2013 to 20 percent in August 2014 to 31 percent in April 2015. That’s a marked increase.
So why the discrepancy between the 2013 Caucasus Barometer poll and the NDI polls over support for the EEU? In 2013, the EEU was still a glimmer in Putin’s eye, and would not actually be formally launched until January 2015 — so public reactions at that point were to a theoretical organization. In fact, a closer look at the numbers shows that 44 percent in the Caucasus Barometer poll would not (or could not) make a firm determination on the EEU either way.


The remaining 56 percent broke down very interestingly. Only 24 percent opposed the EEU; 17 percent went with “equally support and don’t support”; and 27 percent chose “don’t know” or refused to answer. Under the hood, those 2013 Caucasus Barometer numbers suggest that folks were undecided or even unaware of the EEU.


The ways the questions are posed also matters. For example, the Caucasus Barometer asked the question, “To what extent would you support Georgia’s membership in the Eurasian Economic Community?” That’s quite different from the questions posed by the NDI polls.


In the August 2013 and August 2014 NDI polls, respondents are asked, “Which of the following two statements do you agree with?” They could choose joining the EEU, joining the European Union, agreeing with neither, don’t know, and refusing to respond. Such different questions and answers makes it hard to compare the responses. Similarly, the April 2015 NDI poll that showed 31 percent support for the EEU was yet another twist on the question (“do you approve or disapprove of the following?”), although it’s arguably the most straightforward question of the four polls.


From this point of view, it is hard to say that Georgian support for the EEU —a  vehicle for Russian hegemony — is not trending upwards. But this is not the only sign of creeping Russian influence.
Another way of tracking Georgian attitudes toward Russia is to look at election results. Using election results to measure attitudes have their own problems. Georgia’s three most recent national elections — the 2014 local elections, the 2013 presidential elections, and the 2012 parliamentary elections — don’t tell us as much as we would like, for three reasons. They’re a little dated; they represent the opinions only of those citizens who actually voted; and the election results don’t really tell us much about why a voter chose one slate or another. Nonetheless, in an electoral democracy like Georgia (albeit a rough one), elections are the final arena for gauging political power.


In 2014, several parties that could be fairly described as pro-Russia received approximately 20 percent of the nationwide proportional vote. Ex-Speaker Nino Burjanadze’s “United Opposition” plus the populist Alliance of Patriots drew about 15 percent; another 5 percent voted for several other minor parties with anti-west tendencies. This total does not include other voters who cast ballots for the anti-UNM opposition (and now ruling) Georgian Dream (GD) coalition, which has its own anti-west factions.
That’s a solid bump from the 2013 presidential elections, when anti-West parties got only 13 percent of the vote. And in the 2012 parliamentary elections, the largest non-GD or UNM vote share was the 1.2 percent of the vote that went to the quixotic Labor Party, the vehicle for Georgian political gadfly Shalva Natelashvili.


In other words, over a handful of years, pro-Russia parties have been steadily bringing in more Georgian votes.
 





Загрузка...

LATEST NEWSAll Today news

14:58 • 12/12

Ucom launches x2-gigabyte package as special New Year offer to subscribers

14:43 • 12/12

Grand Holding owner donates AMD 52m worth equipment to child emergency care units in Yerevan hospital (video)

14:29 • 12/12

Former high-ranking Armenian official facing graft charges

14:05 • 12/12

Huawei CEO to be released on bail

13:17 • 12/12

Iran warns citizens against visiting Georgia

12:09 • 12/12

Iran hails parliamentary elections in Armenia

11:26 • 12/12

Putin’s spy ID pass found in Germany

11:07 • 12/12

Power transition in Armenia ‘creating platform’ for renewed dialogue with Turkey, says Turkish-Armenian MP

10:36 • 12/12

Zhamanak: CSTO may call off secretary general’s election until late spring

09:59 • 12/12

The Economist: What happens next in Armenia?

09:34 • 12/12

Trump says people will revolt if he is impeached

09:15 • 12/12

French police raise security level as gunman opens fire in central Strasbourg, killing at least three

18:12 • 11/12

US-Armenian businesswoman unveils plan to fund home construction project for orphanage alumni  

17:18 • 11/12

158 million migrants want to move to the US despite Trump's stricter measures

17:06 • 11/12

Steve Jobs signed Macworld magazine up for auction

16:57 • 11/12

French-Armenian organizations congratulate Pashinyan on election win

16:24 • 11/12

Russia fines Google for failure to comply with research results

16:08 • 11/12

EU’s Johannes Hahn congratulates Pashinyan on election victory

15:33 • 11/12

Khashoggi murder: Turkey in talks with UN for investigation

14:58 • 11/12

NASA’s newly arrived OSIRIS-REx spacecraft already discovers water on asteroid

14:49 • 11/12

Election results ‘obliging success’ for winners, says outgoing parliament’s speaker

14:05 • 11/12

December 9 snap elections 'resulted in no surprise' - opinion

13:09 • 11/12

US urges European nations to exit Nord Stream 2 project

12:51 • 11/12

Armenia’s Conservative Party calls for ending ‘pre-election rhetoric’

11:57 • 11/12

Arabs ‘in talks’ with US for NATO-style security pact

11:52 • 11/12

Queen’s ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’ named most-streamed song from 20th century

11:42 • 11/12

Man Utd not to sell Pogba in winter  

11:04 • 11/12

Russian Tu-160 strategic bombers land in Venezuela after 10,000km transatlantic flight 

10:58 • 11/12

Trump ‘concerned about being impeached’

10:28 • 11/12

Germany's Merkel congratulates Pashinyan on successful conduct of snap elections

10:16 • 11/12

EU reaffirms commitment to Armenia's to democratic and prosperous future

10:10 • 11/12

UK's May postpones Brexit deal vote

09:55 • 11/12

US hails snap parliamentary elections in Armenia

09:25 • 11/12

France protests: Macron promises wage rise

18:24 • 10/12

Armenia’s new parliament to have 132 seats to secure opposition’s presence

17:31 • 10/12

Isha Ambani wedding: Beyoncé and Hillary Clinton jet to India for celebration

17:22 • 10/12

International observers praise free conduct of December 9 snap elections in Armenia

16:36 • 10/12

Russia becomes the second largest arms producer in the Top 100

15:59 • 10/12

December 9 snap election ‘reflected Armenian voters' collective will’, say local observers  

14:58 • 10/12

Catherine Zeta Jones and Cameron Douglas lead tributes to Kirk Douglas as acting legend celebrates 102nd birthday with wife Anne, 99

14:36 • 10/12

Armenian CEC finalizes outcomes of Dec. 9 snap election: Pashinyan’s bloc leads with record- breaking 70.44%

13:14 • 10/12

Pashinyan will face reality check – Armenia’s snap election attracts wide coverage by intn'l media

12:24 • 10/12

Ex-Nissan chief charged with financial misconduct

11:46 • 10/12

Syrian soldier killed in latest attack by jihadist rebels in Aleppo

11:30 • 10/12

Adam Schiff says Trump faces ‘real prospect of jail time’ after leaving office

11:16 • 10/12

Jamal Khashoggi's last words ‘disclosed in transcript’

11:03 • 10/12

Artsakh president issues congratulatory address on Constitution anniversary

10:13 • 10/12

Parliamentary election 2018: Pashinyan’s bloc secures landslide victory

09:31 • 10/12

Venezuela accuses US of plotting against President Maduro

17:48 • 09/12

Avengers: Endgame trailer beats Infinity War's record for most views in 24 hours

17:41 • 09/12

Frank Sinatra auction fetches $9.2m in New York  

17:30 • 09/12

'Just name any Armenian who isn’t concerned over Artsakh,' Ter-Petrosyan says after voting

16:42 • 09/12

California officially becomes the first state in the US to require ALL new homes to be powered by solar energy

15:15 • 09/12

Serj Tankian: Very proud of Armenian brothers and sister going to polls after fighting corrupt regime

14:56 • 09/12

Turkey’s intel chief informs US senators on Khashoggi murder

14:40 • 09/12

Kocharyan’s arrest ‘unrelated to snap election’, says acting premier

13:51 • 09/12

Thousands march against Serbian leader’s autocratic rule

13:39 • 09/12

Our efforts must focus on economic growth and democracy-building, says parliament speaker

13:06 • 09/12

Dog found waiting for owners where house once stood after California wildfires  

12:44 • 09/12

'This is a vote of future', President calls for responsible attitude to Dec. 9 snap election

12:16 • 09/12

Brazil spiritual healer accused of sex abuse

12:10 • 09/12

All eyes on French Presidnet Macron after fresh 'yellow vest' protests hit Paris again

12:00 • 09/12

Ex-Soviet dissident Lyudmila Alexeyeva dies at 91

11:18 • 09/12

Armenia holds snap parliamentary election

10:21 • 09/12

China threatens Canada with 'grave consequences'

18:07 • 07/12

Robert Kocharyan 'will be taken into custody', lawyer says after appellate hearing

16:50 • 07/12

Pashinyan, Aliyev ‘discussed Karabakh peace’ in St Petersburg

16:10 • 07/12

Australia passes ‘world’s first’ data encryption law

15:51 • 07/12

Oscars 2018: Kevin Hart steps down as host amid backlash from past homophobic tweets

15:09 • 07/12

Armenia ‘turned into big disaster zone’ after 1988 earthquake, Nikol Pashinyan says in Gyumri

14:13 • 07/12

Riots sweep Athens on anniversary of teen’s shooting death

13:27 • 07/12

EAEU member states ‘may transition to single currency’

13:03 • 07/12

Hraparak: Republican MP praises colleagues’ 'principled stance'

12:18 • 07/12

Stunning images taken by powerful new alien-hunting telescopes reveal the raw beauty of our skies

11:46 • 07/12

Armenia to declare December 7 ‘remembrance and disaster resistance day’

11:21 • 07/12

'Thank you for making 41's last ride so special': Emotional George W Bush thanks thousands who turned out to pay respects along the route of his father's funeral train

10:58 • 07/12

'Forgotten calamity': Armenia marks 30th anniversary of devastating earthquake

09:38 • 07/12

Turkey identifies Saudi courrier in Khashoggi murder

09:32 • 07/12

France protests: Eiffel tower to close amid riot fears

18:34 • 06/12

EAEU leaders agree on common oil and gas market, says Russia's Putin  

18:15 • 06/12

Ayb School establishes advisory board  

18:02 • 06/12

Pashinyan: Armenian government sets major task to double population in 20 years

16:58 • 06/12

Armenia interested in further Eurasian integration processes, Pashinyan says in St Petersburg

16:46 • 06/12

BBC Radio Shropshire's Vicki Archer's death was suicide

16:05 • 06/12

Missing Armenian contract serviceman found dead in snowslides  

15:41 • 06/12

Hrant Dink foundation to launch Armenian art workshop series

14:57 • 06/12

Eurasian economic summit may consider revised gas supply prices for Armenia

14:24 • 06/12

Pre-election debates 'must be made mandatory norm' under Electoral Code  

13:56 • 06/12

VW brand to accelerate margin hike for core brand

12:56 • 06/12

Luxembourg to become world's first country to make all public transport free

12:49 • 06/12

This New Year Ucom Offers Buying Smartphones at Special Price and Get 20 GB of Mobile Internet

12:35 • 06/12

Deadly car bomb attack hits Iran's Sourth-Eastern port

12:27 • 06/12

Contract servicemen ‘stuck in snowslide’ in Armenia’s south; one reported missing  

11:59 • 06/12

Armenia, Azerbaijan to hold next summit over Karabakh in January, says Azerbaijani FM

11:11 • 06/12

UN rights boss Bachelet seeks international inquiry into Khashoggi murder

10:49 • 06/12

Pashinyan to attend EEU summit in St Petersburg

10:29 • 06/12

New satellite images reveal activity at unidentified North Korean missile base

09:56 • 06/12

New Armenian-Azerbaijani ministerial summit ‘aimed to clarify positions on Karabakh’

09:30 • 06/12

Huawei executive arrested in Canada

18:02 • 05/12

World leaders to attend George HW Bush funeral