Khashoggi murder: Recordings of Saudi journalist’s conversations published for first time

09:56 • 21.11.18

A Turkish news website has published quotes and the identity of some speakers in two audio recordings revealing the last moments of slain Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi. 

Citing Turkish security sources, Haberturk columnist Chetiner Chetin reported on November 19 that the first recording shows Khashoggi was seized by the Saudi hit squad immediately after he entered the kingdom’s consulate in Istanbul on October 2 at 1:14 pm, Hurriyet Daily News reports.

“Release my arm! What do you think you are doing?” Khashoggi was heard saying in the first recording from the consulate’s “A unit,” which houses the visa department.

According to the report, the quarrel between Khashoggi and four members of the hit squad could be heard in this recording for seven minutes.

The four Saudis then brought Khashoggi to the “B unit” of the consulate, which houses administrative departments. The four-minute-long recording from this section involves not only a verbal quarrel, but also noises of a physical fight and then beating and torture.

Beside the four men, three more people could be heard in the recording, other than Khashoggi. According to the report, Turkish security sources concluded that one of them is Maher Abdulaziz Mutreb, the alleged leader of the team who had traveled extensively with Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. The other person is Saudi Consul Mohammad al-Otaibi, while the third person’s identity is yet to be determined.

“Traitor! You will be brought to account!’” Mutreb is heard saying in the second recording as soon as Khashoggi was taken into the consulate’s B unit, the report added. Turkish officials reportedly said they concluded that this voice was Mutreb’s by matching it with his voice sample recorded by Turkish customs police during his entrance to the country from Istanbul’s Atatürk Airport hours before the murder.

The same voice could also be heard in 19 telephone calls from the consulate’s C unit, which houses the consul’s office. The phone calls, the first one made only 13 minutes after Khashoggi entered the consulate, were between Mutreb and Saud al-Qahtani, who was the top aide of the crown prince.

The sounds of beatings and torture that went on for 11 minutes are followed by an hour and 15-minute-long silence, during which Turkish officials believed the Saudi hit team started to operate frequency jammers. Three Saudi officials could then be heard coming down the stairs quickly with one of them locking the A unit’s door and the other deleting the security camera footage before removing the hard disks.

Another voice then breaks the silence in the recordings. “It is spooky to wear the clothes of a man whom we killed 20 minutes ago,” 57-year-old Saudi engineer Mustafa al-Modaini is heard saying as he prepares to act as the body double of Khashoggi under the Saudi hit squad’s instructions.

After he complains that Khashoggi’s derby shoes were too small for his feet, the hit squad is heard allowing al-Modaini to keep his own sneakers instead.

Wearing Khashoggi’s clothes, al-Modaini was seen in security camera footage around Istanbul’s tourist districts immediately after the killing in an attempt to mislead the police. Hürriyet columnist Abdulkadir Selvi had written on October 23 that his sneakers were one of the factors that revealed the plot.

Haberturk added that Turkish officials did not have any recordings from the C unit of the consulate in which Khashoggi’s body was thought to be dismembered. However, the fact that the walls of all three rooms in this section were painted immediately after the murder, as well as chemical remains found in the floors and the suspects’ fingerprints on electrical outlets, including those belonging to forensics expert Salah Mohammad al-Tubaighi, are seen as substantial evidence of a cover-up.

Turkey demands Saudi Arabia to reveal all the perpetrators and instigators of the murder and to reveal the whereabouts of Khashoggi’s body and the identity of the “local cooperator” whom they accused of aiding the hit squad.

Meanwhile, Turkish Defense Minister Hulusi Akar has said the Saudi consulate was not bugged by Turkey.

“The consulate was not bugged. We cannot reveal the source of the audio recordings,” Akar told the BBC on November 19.

Akar replied to a question on whether Turkey would make the recordings public.

“At the moment, no. But it depends on the situation, according to the developments, under the control of the prosecutor,” he said.



LATEST NEWSAll Today news

17:48 • 09/12

Avengers: Endgame trailer beats Infinity War's record for most views in 24 hours

17:41 • 09/12

Frank Sinatra auction fetches $9.2m in New York  

17:30 • 09/12

'Just name any Armenian who isn’t concerned over Artsakh,' Ter-Petrosyan says after voting

16:42 • 09/12

California officially becomes the first state in the US to require ALL new homes to be powered by solar energy

15:15 • 09/12

Serj Tankian: Very proud of Armenian brothers and sister going to polls after fighting corrupt regime

14:56 • 09/12

Turkey’s intel chief informs US senators on Khashoggi murder

14:40 • 09/12

Kocharyan’s arrest ‘unrelated to snap election’, says acting premier

13:51 • 09/12

Thousands march against Serbian leader’s autocratic rule

13:39 • 09/12

Our efforts must focus on economic growth and democracy-building, says parliament speaker

13:06 • 09/12

Dog found waiting for owners where house once stood after California wildfires  

12:44 • 09/12

'This is a vote of future', President calls for responsible attitude to Dec. 9 snap election

12:16 • 09/12

Brazil spiritual healer accused of sex abuse

12:10 • 09/12

All eyes on French Presidnet Macron after fresh 'yellow vest' protests hit Paris again

12:00 • 09/12

Ex-Soviet dissident Lyudmila Alexeyeva dies at 91

11:18 • 09/12

Armenia holds snap parliamentary election

10:21 • 09/12

China threatens Canada with 'grave consequences'

18:07 • 07/12

Robert Kocharyan 'will be taken into custody', lawyer says after appellate hearing

16:50 • 07/12

Pashinyan, Aliyev ‘discussed Karabakh peace’ in St Petersburg

16:10 • 07/12

Australia passes ‘world’s first’ data encryption law

15:51 • 07/12

Oscars 2018: Kevin Hart steps down as host amid backlash from past homophobic tweets

15:09 • 07/12

Armenia ‘turned into big disaster zone’ after 1988 earthquake, Nikol Pashinyan says in Gyumri

14:13 • 07/12

Riots sweep Athens on anniversary of teen’s shooting death

13:27 • 07/12

EAEU member states ‘may transition to single currency’

13:03 • 07/12

Hraparak: Republican MP praises colleagues’ 'principled stance'

12:18 • 07/12

Stunning images taken by powerful new alien-hunting telescopes reveal the raw beauty of our skies

11:46 • 07/12

Armenia to declare December 7 ‘remembrance and disaster resistance day’

11:21 • 07/12

'Thank you for making 41's last ride so special': Emotional George W Bush thanks thousands who turned out to pay respects along the route of his father's funeral train

10:58 • 07/12

'Forgotten calamity': Armenia marks 30th anniversary of devastating earthquake

09:38 • 07/12

Turkey identifies Saudi courrier in Khashoggi murder

09:32 • 07/12

France protests: Eiffel tower to close amid riot fears

18:34 • 06/12

EAEU leaders agree on common oil and gas market, says Russia's Putin  

18:15 • 06/12

Ayb School establishes advisory board  

18:02 • 06/12

Pashinyan: Armenian government sets major task to double population in 20 years

16:58 • 06/12

Armenia interested in further Eurasian integration processes, Pashinyan says in St Petersburg

16:46 • 06/12

BBC Radio Shropshire's Vicki Archer's death was suicide

16:05 • 06/12

Missing Armenian contract serviceman found dead in snowslides  

15:41 • 06/12

Hrant Dink foundation to launch Armenian art workshop series

14:57 • 06/12

Eurasian economic summit may consider revised gas supply prices for Armenia

14:24 • 06/12

Pre-election debates 'must be made mandatory norm' under Electoral Code  

13:56 • 06/12

VW brand to accelerate margin hike for core brand

12:56 • 06/12

Luxembourg to become world's first country to make all public transport free

12:49 • 06/12

This New Year Ucom Offers Buying Smartphones at Special Price and Get 20 GB of Mobile Internet

12:35 • 06/12

Deadly car bomb attack hits Iran's Sourth-Eastern port

12:27 • 06/12

Contract servicemen ‘stuck in snowslide’ in Armenia’s south; one reported missing  

11:59 • 06/12

Armenia, Azerbaijan to hold next summit over Karabakh in January, says Azerbaijani FM

11:11 • 06/12

UN rights boss Bachelet seeks international inquiry into Khashoggi murder

10:49 • 06/12

Pashinyan to attend EEU summit in St Petersburg

10:29 • 06/12

New satellite images reveal activity at unidentified North Korean missile base

09:56 • 06/12

New Armenian-Azerbaijani ministerial summit ‘aimed to clarify positions on Karabakh’

09:30 • 06/12

Huawei executive arrested in Canada

18:02 • 05/12

World leaders to attend George HW Bush funeral

17:23 • 05/12

Armenian parliament speaker hosts delegation from Senate of Italy

16:55 • 05/12

Kanye West's 'stepfather' blames Kardashians for rapper’s erratic behavior

16:39 • 05/12

Australian Open: Andy Murray to use protected ranking to play in Melbourne

16:21 • 05/12

Brazilian woman gives birth, using womb transplanted from dead donor

15:53 • 05/12

Armenia needs mutual clarification of commitments with CSTO allies, Pashinyan tells Russian TV channel

15:05 • 05/12

Turkey seeks arrest of Saudi prince’s aides over Khashoggi murder

14:54 • 05/12

Armenia, Azerbaijan may coordinate statement on Karabakh' at Milan summit

14:38 • 05/12

Alibaba signs e-commerce trade hub agreement with Belgium

14:20 • 05/12

Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov to visit Azerbaijan

14:09 • 05/12

Oscars 2019: Comedian Kevin Hart to host 2019 ceremony

13:26 • 05/12

Kabul ready to talk with Taliban without preconditions – official

13:14 • 05/12

Duchess of Cambridge dons Diana's glittering headpiece once again as she joins William for the Queen's Diplomatic Reception at Buckingham Palace

12:44 • 05/12

Armenia has not made special requests for postponing CSTO summit, says acting premier  

11:57 • 05/12

Heart-stopping moment man falls into a pool of alligators after his rope swing snaps

11:33 • 05/12

US policies on Armenia ‘aimed at fostering independence’  

10:42 • 05/12

US says it will pull out of INF treaty if Russia does not comply within 60 days  

10:21 • 05/12

Zhamanak: Republican’s pre-election strategy 'built on plans to flee Armenia'

09:49 • 05/12

CSTO postpones summit due to snap elections in Armenia

09:39 • 05/12

Tsunami warning issued for Vanuatu and New Caledonia after 7.6 magnitude earthquake

09:13 • 05/12

Italian police arrest mafia's alleged new mob boss and 45 others in major crackdown on organised crime

23:29 • 04/12

As a humanitarian gesture, Artsakh ready to consider Azerbaijani citizen's early release

17:51 • 04/12

EU’s Mogherini holds meeting with acting Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan 

17:38 • 04/12

French Prime Minister Edouard Philippe announces suspension of fuel tax hikes

17:24 • 04/12

South Korean theme park dedicated to cheese features 'wedged-shaped buildings and runs mozzarella-making classes'  

17:08 • 04/12

Kim Kardashian and Kanye West at Cher premiere show

17:01 • 04/12

Scientists detect largest ever black hole collision  

16:48 • 04/12

Three migrants found frozen to death in Turkey

16:18 • 04/12

Iran warns US over attempts to block oil sale

16:13 • 04/12

Israel launches operation to thwart Hezbollah border tunnels

16:05 • 04/12

Ballon d'Or: DJ Martin Solveig sorry for Ada Hegerberg 'twerk' question

15:28 • 04/12

Parliamentary election 2018: Bright Armenia leader calls for re-establishing balance over Karabakh

14:44 • 04/12

Rare gold coins found in Israeli city

14:16 • 04/12

Cannabis firm confirms investment talks with Marlboro maker

14:04 • 04/12

Luka Modric: 'I want to retire at Madrid'

13:58 • 04/12

Audi’s drop dead gorgeous e-Tron concept is full electric and it goes from 0 to 62 mph in 3.5 seconds

13:06 • 04/12

Missing military jet crashes into mountains of Maralik; crew identified (update)

12:43 • 04/12

Armenian authorities seek to establish rule over Artsakh, says politician

12:04 • 04/12

Protest-hit France 'to halt fuel tax rise'

11:50 • 04/12

Sasna Tsrer party vows ‘no concession’ over Karabakh  

11:19 • 04/12

Nepalese bus driver licking own forehead hopeful to break Guiness World Record

11:07 • 04/12

Students blockade schools amid spreading French protests

10:37 • 04/12

Erdogan denies Armenian Genocide during G20 Summit

10:26 • 04/12

Khashoggi funded cyber army against Saudi Arabia's 'beast', Whtsapp messages reveal

10:08 • 04/12

George H.W. Bush honored at Capitol as Americans say goodbye

09:47 • 04/12

Six police officers killed in Mexican state ravaged by gang violence

09:40 • 04/12

OSCE Parliamentary Assembly to send observers to monitor elections in Armenia

09:36 • 04/12

Israel's Netanyahu, US Secretary of State Pompeo meet to talk Iran

09:24 • 04/12

NATO slams use of military force against Ukrainian ships

17:57 • 03/12

Armenian Genocide to feature in Australian parliament debate marking 70 anniversary of Genocide Convention